Lead theft puts churches in financial difficulty and distracts from mission

Four historic churches around Leicester have become the latest target of roofing lead thieves within the past fortnight, in what appears to be a spike in the crime across the UK in recent weeks.

The churches, some of which date back to the 12th Century, are in the Melton, Market Harborough and Oakham areas and were all raided in six days from Thursday, 4 August.

The latest churches to be targeted are St Mary's in Manton, near Rutland Water; All Saints, in Lubenham, near Market Harborough; St Edmund's, in Egleton, near Rutland Water, and St Mary's at Wyfordby, near Melton.

The Lubenham and Wyfordby churches are in the Diocese of Leicester, while the others are in the Peterborough Diocese.

The thefts come after two men were arrested on suspicion of stealing lead from a church roof in Liverpool. Police were called after two men were spotted on the roof of St James' Church on Mill Lane, West Derby.

And in Birmingham, a 20-year-old man was arrested on 31 July, for stealing lead from the roof of St Mary's Church in Cratfield in December last year.

Following a number of similar thefts across Leicestershire and Rutland in recent years, Leicestershire Police and local church figures urged the public to be on the look-out for suspicious behaviour.

The Archdeacon of Leicester, Tim Stratford said: "I am very sad that once again churches have been targeted by thieves stealing lead from the roof. Despite our best efforts, which include roof alarms, Smartwater, and advice about security awareness, four churches in a relatively small area have lost parts of their roof...This is not a victimless crime. Insurance does not cover the replacement and small, local communities often cannot afford the repairs. We appeal to everyone to be alert for vans parked near churches, frequently looking as though they are working professionally."

Tim Alban-Jones, the Peterborough Diocese Bishop's Chaplain said: "The loss of lead from church roofs is always a major blow to a parish. It has a hugely disproportionate effect on the life of a parish church as the cost of replacing the lead is always far higher than the value of the stolen lead, and it takes time and energy away from the mission of the church."

Meanwhile, in Milngavie in East Dunbartonshire, Scotland, thieves last week targeted St. Paul's Church of Scotland church for the fifth time in recent years. The latest theft follows one in 2012, two in February 2013 and another one in November 2014.

This raises the issue of the rules from Historic England that mean church roofs must be replaced by lead 'like-for-like'. The Church of England said that some churches can appeal against the rules. But critics argue that the rule is counter-productive, leading to repeated thefts from the same church roofs.

A spokesperson for Historic England condemned the thefts but defended the 'like-for-like' rule, telling Christian Today: "The theft of metal from church roofs is an irresponsible and disheartening crime, attacking the spiritual, communal and architectural backbone of our villages, towns and cities. We sympathise with those who look after churches and are faced with such vandalism. There is no question that protecting the church from the elements should be the priority in these situations. There are good reasons why our guidance recommends like-for-like replacement - lead is very durable and performs extremely well as a roofing material. Also, it can easily be repaired and much of it comes from recycled sources."

The Historic England spokesperson emphasised that churches can change to an alternative material for their roofs under certain circumstances. "Our guidance makes it very clear that Historic England will consider supporting the replacement of stolen lead with an alternative material after one incidence of theft if it is satisfied that security measures are unlikely to prevent further attacks, and if the proposed alternative material is suitable in terms of technical performance and appearance," the spokesperson said.

The guidance says: "Every case is assessed on its merits but we appreciate that there will be instances when a change of material will be appropriate. After a theft, in some situations, a durable replacement such as terne coated stainless steel or tiles, might be the most prudent way to repair the building."

A Church of England spokesperson told Christian Today: "The key point is that lead is the best roofing material and replacement is the default, but where there is a great risk of repeated theft, alternatives might be considered."

The Archdeacon of Leicester added: "Whilst there are many roofing materials in use today, lead has an important place in the history of our buildings. For this reason there is an expectation among statutory agencies and planning authorities that historic buildings with lead roofs will be re-roofed with the same material as the need arises. At present this expectation among the regulators of historic buildings prevents the church from replacing lead with similar looking materials less attractive to thieves, such as terne coated steel, unless it can make a special argument on a case-by case basis. This is possible where there have been repeated thefts from a particular building but it is not something that can be agreed for most churches."

related articles
New bishop calls for obligatory SmartWater checks

The next Bishop of Shrewsbury has said all scrap metal dealers should be obliged to check for SmartWater as a condition of their licence.

Churches fight metal thieves with new labelling technology

Tens of thousands of Church of England buildings have now taken measures to combat metal thieves intent on stealing their valuable lead fittings.

Home Office petition to fight back against church lead theft

The Diocese of London is encouraging churches to sign an epetition seeking to end cash-in-hand transactions on the sale of scrap metal

Campaign to save churches from metal theft

Church leaders, MPs and Liz Hurley are among those supporting a campaign to save thousands of churches from metal thieves

Metal theft from churches reaches six-year low

The number of churches experiencing metal theft has fallen to its lowest in six years.

New scrap metal law \'step in the right direction\', says Church of England
New scrap metal law 'step in the right direction', says Church of England

The Church of England is optimistic that new laws on scrap metal will help to reduce the "scourge" of metal theft.

Church worker\'s efforts in tackling metal theft recognised
Church worker's efforts in tackling metal theft recognised

A church worker has been recognised for his efforts in bringing to justice a group of metal thieves who had been stripping lead from church roofs in Lincolnshire.

News
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019

Pro-life organisation Right To Life UK has called for an independent inquiry into Hawaii’s assisted suicide system after official figures showed a record number of deaths and the state’s Department of Health acknowledged gaps in its reporting.

Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?
Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?

The barriers that keep young people out of work can take shape long before they leave school. Tackling them starts with supporting families and giving every child the chance to develop their gifts.

Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan
Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan

Every year it is estimated that around 1,000 girls in Pakistan are kidnapped, forcibly converted to Islam and married, often to a much older man.

New AI-assisted resource to help traumatised Iranians
New AI-assisted resource to help traumatised Iranians

Transform Iran is using AI to offer confidential trauma support to more Iranian women than it could reach through one-to-one counselling alone.