Christian Durham Free School closed after damning Ofsted report

A Christian school in Durham is set to close after a damning Ofsted inspection found that it was "inadequate", the worst level possible, across all areas of its work.

The Durham Free School was set up in 2012 on Christian principles. However, it has struggled to attract pupils and found itself facing a cash crisis last year. Its head teacher, Peter Cantley, was terminated on "performance grounds" but was fighting his case through an employment tribunal, arguing that he had been unfairly dismissed because of his "whistleblowing".

The Ofsted report, carried out in November, rated the school as inadequate in all four categories: leadership and management, behaviour and safety of pupils, quality of teaching and achievement of pupils. It was put in 'special measures', with inspectors saying that the standard of students' work was low and progress was inadequate, that leaders did not have high enough expectations and that students' "low aspirations" were not challenged.

Inspectors also said that governors placed "too much emphasis on religious credentials when they are recruiting key staff and not enough on seeking candidates with excellent leadership and teaching skills".

The report criticised standards of teaching and also noted that "Some students hold discriminatory views of other people who have different faiths, values or beliefs from themselves."

It said that progress was being made under acting head Julian Eisner, who had taken over after Cantley's departure.

However, Education Secretary Nicky Morgan – herself a Christian – said that she had taken the "difficult decision" to close the school as she did not believe it could be sufficiently improved in a reasonable time. In a statement for the Northern Echo explaining her decision to withdraw funding she said: "My moral mission as Education Secretary is to ensure that every time a pupil enters the school gate they step into an environment where they can flourish. One day spent in a failing school is one day too many, and I am deeply concerned when I hear of pupils being let down."

She continued: "What Ofsted found is enough to shock any parent, including me. Its report, published on Monday, paints a picture of a school in disarray. Bad behaviour, including cases of bullying, appears to be rampant. Standards are low, while progress is inadequate. And school leaders are failing to prepare pupils for life in modern Britain.

"I have considered if it is possible for this to be turned around quickly and investigated the possibility of injecting new leadership. But it is clear to me that this has been a troubled school for some time and there is no imminent prospect of improvement.

"That is why I have taken the difficult decision to close the school."

She said that the closure of the school was "an extremely rare case" and that officials were working with the local council to ensure that all the children would have places at other local schools. The decision, Morgan said, was made "with the best interests of the children in mind".

The school did not reply to a request for comment. However, on its website it says that it was set up in response to parents' concerns that secondary school provision was concentrated in the north of the city, with many children disadvantaged. It also says: "We also want to support the ethos of Church of England primary schools, by offering continuity of ethos, but without imposing church attendance related admissions criteria."

It also includes testimonials from parents saying that they are happy with their childrens' progress at the school and paying tribute to the teaching there. One said: "I back the school 100 per cent! My son is getting on so well and it's all thanks to the love and care in the school," while another added: "We're very proud of what the school has achieved... Mine and my husband's views are great school great friendly staff and it will go far."

The Archbishop of York was quoted in today's Daily Telegraph as attacking the principle of free schools. He said: "What I haven't bought is the idea that we should have free schools. Because the ones that have gone for free schools in the majority are people with means and ability ... I think that is just a confusion of policy.

"What should have happened is that the Government should have invested all that money in raising the level of achievement in schools that are less achieving, not by putting in these so-called competing places."

related articles
Bradford plans to 'tax' faith schools, say Catholics

A plan by Bradford council to end free travel to faith schools has been labelled a "tax" by Catholic groups.

Catholic schools should not have admissions cap, says MP
Catholic schools should not have admissions cap, says MP

Tory MP Mark Hoban has called for the cap to be lifted on the number of Catholic children who can be admitted to Catholic schools.

UK faith schools to have fewer religious pupils
UK faith schools to have fewer religious pupils

New Church of England schools are not likely to give priority to Anglican pupils, instead offering 100 per cent of admissions to students from all faiths and none

Government bans creationism from free school science lessons
Government bans creationism from free school science lessons

The Government has changed the rules to stop creationism being taught in science lessons in free schools and academies.

Legal challenge to Government\'s Trojan Horse response is a gospel freedom issue
Legal challenge to Government's Trojan Horse response is a gospel freedom issue

Colin Hart, director of the Christian Institute, responds to criticism of the Institute's legal challenge against the Government's response to the Trojan Horse scandal.

Church of England schools to promote tolerance for other faiths and lifestyles
Church of England schools to promote tolerance for other faiths and lifestyles

The Church of England has indicated it will comply with new rules that will compel all schools including faith schools actively to promote fundamental British values, including tolerance for other faiths and lifestyles.

News
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019

Pro-life organisation Right To Life UK has called for an independent inquiry into Hawaii’s assisted suicide system after official figures showed a record number of deaths and the state’s Department of Health acknowledged gaps in its reporting.

Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?
Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?

The barriers that keep young people out of work can take shape long before they leave school. Tackling them starts with supporting families and giving every child the chance to develop their gifts.

Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan
Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan

Every year it is estimated that around 1,000 girls in Pakistan are kidnapped, forcibly converted to Islam and married, often to a much older man.

New AI-assisted resource to help traumatised Iranians
New AI-assisted resource to help traumatised Iranians

Transform Iran is using AI to offer confidential trauma support to more Iranian women than it could reach through one-to-one counselling alone.