UK law is 'intolerant' towards Christians, says cardinal

A former Catholic Archbishop has called for greater religious freedom in Britain, insisting that the law has done "too little" to protect and promote the rights of Christians.

Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor has written an open letter to The Telegraph in response to its leader article which declared: "It is obvious that there is a growing conflict between religious freedoms and equalities legislation, and that a new balance has to be struck".

The Telegraph itself was responding to a recent speech given by Baroness Hale, the UK's most senior female judge, who suggested that the law may be discriminatory against Christians.

Speaking before the Law Society of Ireland in Dublin, Hale highlighted the case of Christian hoteliers Peter and Hazelmary Bull, who were found guilty of discrimination against a gay couple after upholding a policy that only married couples were allowed to stay in their double bedrooms.

Baroness Hale herself ruled on this case, but last week pondered whether a "more nuanced approach" might be necessary when dealing with issues of religious liberty in UK courts in the future.

"I am not sure our law has found a reasonable accommodation of all these different strands," she said. "An example of treatment which Christians may feel to be unfair is the recent case of Bull v Hall. Should we be developing an explicit requirement upon providers of employment, goods and services to make reasonable accommodation for the manifestation of religious beliefs?

"If the law is going to protect freedom of religion and belief it has to accept that all religions and beliefs and none are equal. It cannot realistically inquire into the validity or importance of those beliefs, or any particular manifestation of them, as long as they are genuinely held," she added.

Hale also suggested that a "conscience clause" allowing exemption on the grounds of religious beliefs may go some way to ensure full freedom of religion in the UK.

The Telegraph has labelled Hale's comments "refreshing", underlining her courage in "bravely enter[ing] the debate," which is fraught with contention.

"Of course, there are arguments for and against such a clause," the article continues.

"Christian campaigners would doubtless say that it is necessary to protect employers, employees and providers of services who find that something they have been doing their whole life has been rendered illegal by the introduction of equalities legislation...Opponents of a conscience clause might counter that it is perverse to give a privileged status to certain religious groups, allowing them to opt out of laws that they happen to disagree with.

"Could freedom of conscience not just as easily be cited by the governors and teachers in Birmingham schools who are accused of promoting their own brand of conservative Islam?

"Nevertheless, Britain does need to have a conversation about this subject and it is not something that we should shy away from – especially not for fear of falling foul of the unwritten laws of political correctness," it concludes.

"A Britain that is comfortably modern and diverse has to ensure that there is both equality and a respectful tolerance for differences of opinion. Otherwise, those differences could be twisted into bitter resentments."

Cardinal Cormac has expressed that he "warmly welcome[s]" these comments from The Telegraph, insisting that "The law in these past years has done too little to protect the beliefs of Christians and the legitimate freedoms of Christian organisations".

He goes on to mention the myriad Catholic adoption agencies which were forced to close when the law changed to insist that all such organisations must accept same-sex couples as prospective adoptive parents.

"Because of our conviction that children are better placed in a home with a man and a woman, a father and mother, the agencies were unable to offer a service to same-sex couples. Providing an exception to allow these few small religious voluntary agencies to continue would not in any way have denied gay couples access to mainstream providers of adoption services," the cardinal writes.

"It would in fact have been a sensible and proportionate accommodation, recognising that religious organisations have a distinct identity and ethos that very often brings a valuable contribution to the wider common good of society."

The forced closure of such Catholic adoption agencies has been "a sad loss for the Church and society," the former Archbishop continues, echoing Baroness Hale who has previously branded it "fascinating that a country with an established Church can be less respectful of religious feelings than one without".

"How extraordinary that a law, in the name of tolerance, should become so intolerant to a charity that aims only to do good and foster the most vulnerable children," Cardinal Cormac concludes his letter.

"We do indeed need in our pluralist society to strike a much fairer balance which recognises the importance of religion and belief and allows a more open and mature accommodation of differences while ensuring that the law protects everyone equally and prevents harm."

related articles
Christian B&B owners take gay discrimination case to Supreme Court
Christian B&B owners take gay discrimination case to Supreme Court

The Christian owners of a B&B are at the Supreme Court today to challenge a previous ruling that their double bedroom policy discriminated against a gay couple in a civil partnership.

Christian guesthouse couple take legal action to Europe
Christian guesthouse couple take legal action to Europe

A Welsh Christian couple running a guesthouse have taken their legal action defence of a policy to restrict double beds to married couples to the European Court of Human Rights

Supreme Court judge calls for \'reasonable accommodation\' of Christian beliefs
Supreme Court judge calls for 'reasonable accommodation' of Christian beliefs

Britain's second most senior judge has spoken of the need for more respect of Christian beliefs in the UK legal system

Top UK judge: \'Law may discriminate against Christians\'
Top UK judge: 'Law may discriminate against Christians'

Reflecting on the Christian B&B case, the UK's most senior female judge has admitted that the law may be discriminatory against Christians.

News
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously

Speaking with agnostic YouTuber Joe Folley, Oxford mathematician John Lennox argued that the historical evidence for Jesus’ resurrection is enough of a reason for sceptics to explore whether his promises hold true in their own lives.

Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019

Pro-life organisation Right To Life UK has called for an independent inquiry into Hawaii’s assisted suicide system after official figures showed a record number of deaths and the state’s Department of Health acknowledged gaps in its reporting.

Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?
Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?

The barriers that keep young people out of work can take shape long before they leave school. Tackling them starts with supporting families and giving every child the chance to develop their gifts.

Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan
Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan

Every year it is estimated that around 1,000 girls in Pakistan are kidnapped, forcibly converted to Islam and married, often to a much older man.