Supreme Court will decide fate of Catholic midwives in abortion objection case

Two Catholic midwives who contested their duty to be involved in abortion procedures are today having their case reviewed by the Supreme Court in London.

Five justices will decide whether Mary Doogan and Connie Wood, both of Scotland, are able to withdraw from any involvement in a practice which they believe would "'violate their conscience".

The court appearance today follows their landmark victory last year, in which a court of appeal in Edinburgh ruled that the women had a right to refuse to delegate, supervise or support staff involved in terminations.

They had previously been denied this right, when a judge in 2012 ruled that their human rights had not been violated because they were not directly involved in the procedure.

At the time, judge Lady Smith said: "Nothing they have to do as part of their duties terminates a woman's pregnancy. They are sufficiently removed from direct involvement as, it seems to me, to afford appropriate respect for and accommodation of their beliefs."

However, the overturning of this ruling was last year supported by the Roman Catholic Church in Scotland. Archbishop Philip Tartaglia of Glasgow said it was a "victory for freedom of conscience and for common sense".

"The midwives are to be commended for their courage and determination in standing up to an unjust requirement of the employer that they be involved in abortion procedures. As the judges state, the right of conscientious objection extends not only to the actual medical or surgical termination but to the whole abortion process," he said.

"I hope that many pro-life health professionals will take heart from this judgement and have the courage to express their own objections if and when they are asked to carry out tasks which are morally wrong and violate their conscience.

He added: "Respect for workers' freedom of conscience is a hallmark of a civilised society."

The right to conscientious objection is protected by the 1967 Abortion Act. However, some health professionals are concerned about the wider implications of allowing midwives to abstain from all complicity.

"bpas [British Pregnancy Advisory Service] supports the right of healthcare professionals to conscientious objection, not least because women deserve better than being treated with contempt by those who think they are sinners. But ultimately a balance needs to be struck between that exercise of conscience and women's access to legal services," Ann Furedi, bpas chief executive, told Press Association.

"It would be grossly unjust if an interpretation of conscientious objection was allowed to stand which would disrupt services to the point that those committed to helping women were unable to do so."

Gillian Smith, Royal College of Midwives director for Scotland, also warned that changing the current law could "compromise" the care of women undergoing an abortion.

"We will be encouraging our members to continue to provide professional care to women who require this type of treatment," she said.

A spokesperson for the two organisations yesterday announced that both are "deeply concerned" that a favourable judgement for Doogan and Wood "extends the right of conscientious objection beyond the provisions intended by the Abortion Act".

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is bringing the appeal today. A judgement is expected next year.

related articles
Court hears Glasgow abortion midwife appeals

The Court of Session in Edinburgh has held appeal hearings on the case of two midwives seeking to uphold the right of conscience objection to abortion.

Catholic midwives' abortion victory welcomed

The Roman Catholic Church in Scotland has welcomed a court ruling upholding the right to conscientious objection of two midwives who refused to have any role in abortion procedures.

Planned Parenthood: Having an abortion \'will not change God\'s relationship with you\'
Planned Parenthood: Having an abortion 'will not change God's relationship with you'

Religious leaders who support abortion have written a pastoral letter to women contemplating terminating their pregnancy to assure them God loves them regardless of the decision they make.

Desiring God blog: The abortion industry will \'self-destruct\'
Desiring God blog: The abortion industry will 'self-destruct'

Blogger and author Jonathan Parnell has declared that the abortion industry will "self-destruct", accusing pro-choice activists of being "a psychotic threat to humanity".

US abortion doctor defends work as \'ministry\'
US abortion doctor defends work as 'ministry'

A US doctor who performs dozens of abortions a day has controversially defended the service he offers as a Christian 'ministry'.

News
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously

Speaking with agnostic YouTuber Joe Folley, Oxford mathematician John Lennox argued that the historical evidence for Jesus’ resurrection is enough of a reason for sceptics to explore whether his promises hold true in their own lives.

Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019

Pro-life organisation Right To Life UK has called for an independent inquiry into Hawaii’s assisted suicide system after official figures showed a record number of deaths and the state’s Department of Health acknowledged gaps in its reporting.

Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?
Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?

The barriers that keep young people out of work can take shape long before they leave school. Tackling them starts with supporting families and giving every child the chance to develop their gifts.

Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan
Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan

Every year it is estimated that around 1,000 girls in Pakistan are kidnapped, forcibly converted to Islam and married, often to a much older man.