Johnny Depp and Richard Dawkins: Is atheism really more rational than Christian faith?

Johnny Depp remains a big name at the box office. Whenever his name is attached to a project, it can be guaranteed that people will turn out. While that usually means buying a ticket at the box office for his latest movie, the organisers of a 'Reason Rally' are hoping he'll prove just as popular at their event.

This week Depp, along with the likes of Richard Dawkins, was announced as one of the speakers at this year's rally. Dawkins, along with Lawrence Krauss, are typical of the event's speakers – they're well-known scientific and educationalist figures who say they're 'free thinkers' or 'rationalists.'

This is where we hit a problem. Many of the Reason Rally's aims seem laudable. In a pluralist, free society, statements like "Democracy works best when everyone's voice is heard" should be welcomed. A vibrant democracy needs a wide variety of voices. The issue with the rally isn't that it wants a plurality of voices in public debate – the problem is that it seems to be claiming 'reason' and even 'rationality' solely for the atheist camp.

This is a major overreach on the part of the atheist community and it doesn't stand up to scrutiny.

Reason is a good thing, as is rationality. We should all have reasons for the faith (or lack of) that we proclaim. 1 Peter 3:15 tells us as much. Atheists, humanists, secularists and others are happy to do the same of course – to give a reason for their ideological and metaphysical commitments.

Atheism isn't, though, the default, or only 'reasonable' position.

Similarly with rationalism. It's vital that we rationally engage with our faith. St Paul demonstrated his willingness to argue for his beliefs, not just from the perspective of the revelation given to him, but on a rational basis as well.

He debated with the Stoic and Epicurian philosophers in Athens, as recounted in Acts 17. Similarly today many Christians, atheists and those of other persuasions are happy to engage in debate for the rational basis for their commitments.

Again, this is fine. But there is overreach if atheists claim that their worldview is the only one with a rational basis. Christian (and other theist) philosophers have been debating the rational basis for faith in God for thousands of years. There are some aspects of atheism that cannot be said to be 'more rational' than an orthodox Christian viewpoint.

Take Lawrence Krauss for instance. In his book, A Universe From Nothing Krauss claims, "The metaphysical 'rule'... that 'out of nothing nothing comes,' has no foundation in science... All it represents is an unwillingness to recognize the simple fact that nature may be cleverer than philosophers or theologians."

Notice the two ways in which Krauss tries to martial 'rationality' to his cause here. He suggests that the only way to ascertain if something is true is via science. Then he claims that nature is cleverer than those he disagrees with. It's pretty thin gruel really, as an argument. Yet his huge book sales imply many agree with him.

Thank goodness then for those who point out the gaping chasms in the argument that to be atheist is the only way to be rational. One of them is David Bentley Hart. The Orthodox philosopher argues, "Those who most like to flatter themselves that they are the austerest of rationalists (that is, atheists, materialists, metaphysical naturalists... that crowd) would find the notion that reason arises from an irreducibly fiduciary movement of the will risible, even perhaps sordid... The unyielding rationalist turns out to be the most irrational fideist of all: one who believes in reason even though there cannot possibly be any reason for that belief."

Faith commitments should be held up to scrutiny and argument. But claims of atheists and materialists, be it Dawkins or Depp, must be held up to the same level of scrutiny.

Three cheers then, for reason and rationality. But beware before claiming all reason and rationality under the sun for your side of the argument.

related articles
What to say when someone asks for proof of God\'s existence
What to say when someone asks for proof of God's existence

In the second of his series on apologetics, David Robertson tackles the classic question: where is the evidence for Christianity?

What to say when someone says science has disproved God
What to say when someone says science has disproved God

The belief that science and faith are opposed is one of those atheist myths that have grown so strong in popular culture that it is has become a major hindrance to sharing the gospel.

What to say when someone says the Bible can't be trusted

"Show me the evidence for God and I will believe" is the claim of the unbeliever, quickly backed up with, "there is/can be no evid

Richard Dawkins prayer row: 5 things it taught me about religion in Britain

David Robertson reflects on the 'praying for Dawkins' prayer row.

How can we believe in the God of the Old Testament?
How can we believe in the God of the Old Testament?

Can we really trust in a God who seems so cruel and merciless? David Robertson continues his apologetics series, tackling the Achilles heel of the Christian faith.

News
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously

Speaking with agnostic YouTuber Joe Folley, Oxford mathematician John Lennox argued that the historical evidence for Jesus’ resurrection is enough of a reason for sceptics to explore whether his promises hold true in their own lives.

Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019

Pro-life organisation Right To Life UK has called for an independent inquiry into Hawaii’s assisted suicide system after official figures showed a record number of deaths and the state’s Department of Health acknowledged gaps in its reporting.

Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?
Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?

The barriers that keep young people out of work can take shape long before they leave school. Tackling them starts with supporting families and giving every child the chance to develop their gifts.

Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan
Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan

Every year it is estimated that around 1,000 girls in Pakistan are kidnapped, forcibly converted to Islam and married, often to a much older man.