Trump's Abortion Executive Order: What Is It And Will It Do More Harm Than Good?

Donald Trump on Monday signed a controversial executive order banning federal money going to international groups which perform abortions, or provide information about them.

In the week of the 44th anniversary of Roe v Wade, the land-mark 1973 Supreme Court decision that legalised abortion across the US, Trump signed the 'Mexico City Policy', named as such because President Reagan first implemented it at a United Nations population conference in Mexico City in 1984. The policy was abandoned under President Clinton, reinstated under George W Bush and revoked again under Barack Obama's administration.

Now it has been introduced again, requiring that non-governmental organisations receiving federal funding agree "neither [to] perform nor actively promote abortion as a method of family planning in other nations". The active promotion of abortions, in this case, means not only referrals but also counselling. The measure is thus also known by some as the "global gag rule".

So what exactly does the policy mean? And how is it likely to effect women on the ground?

To be clear: American taxpayers' money has never been used directly to fund abortions by international NGOs as the Helms Amendment, passed in 1973, prohibits the direct use of American funding for terminations.

But the Mexico City Policy goes further in blocking all funding to any organisation that carries out or promotes abortions in its development work, even if US money is not used directly for that purpose.

In other words: many health groups receive US assistance to provide women's services, while using different funding sources to provide abortion counselling and procedures. Those organisations will now have to stop providing abortions if they want to continue to receive US aid for their other programmes.

Trump's move has been welcomed by conservative groups and evangelical Christians.

Russell Moore, the president of the Southern Baptist Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, said: "This decision will save lives...This is a welcome step in the right direction, and my hope is that the president will continue to defend human dignity and hold the predatory abortion industry accountable."

Alveda King, the evangelist and niece of civil rights campaigner Martin Luther King, also praised the new president. "The die is cast and the path is clear for America to learn that abortion is not health care," she said. "Abortion kills babies and all too often harms the wombs, health, psyche and souls of mothers. By reinstating the 'Mexico City Policy' which saves the lives of thousands of babies and women, President Trump is raising the bar for genuine concern for the lives and health of mothers and our children."

Elsewhere, campaigners reacted with delight over a move which will result in the 'defunding' of the pro-choice group International Planned Parenthood. Critics argue that among other areas, International Planned Parenthood assists the population control programme in Communist China. Reggie Littlejohn, the President of Women's Rights Without Frontiers said: "We are elated that US taxpayer dollars will stop going to International Planned Parenthood, which has been working hand in hand with the Chinese Communist Party in their brutal, coercive population control programme in China, which includes forced abortion and sterilisation of women."

But is the effect of the measure purely positive? Trump has been widely criticised since a photograph of him signing the order surrounded by a group of men went viral in the West, with feminists arguing that men were trying to control women's reproductive organs.

However, experts say that the real effect will be on the developing world, where the policy will freeze millions of dollars in funding that has gone to critical health treatment, including HIV testing and neonatal care, the Washington Post reports.

Some feminist critics to say that women "will die" as a result of the measure.

In Kenya for example, there are fears that fewer accessible abortions will result in an increased number of women resorting to dangerous methods for terminations, including drinking battery acid, using wire coat hangers and hiring local healers to stamp on their stomachs until the pregnancy is considered to be over.

"Trump's policy means even fewer services will be offered," said Chimaraoke Izugbara, a researcher at the African Population and Health Research Center (APHRC) in Nairobi. "Some women will not be reached, and providers may not be available to offer services. I think we are headed to a major disaster."

According to Izugbara, of the nearly 8,000 women who die in Kenya every year from complications caused by pregnancy and childbirth, at least a fifth of those deaths are caused by self-induced abortions.

Across Africa, around 1.6 million women are treated each year for complications from unsafe abortions, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a research organisation based in New York.

Meanwhile, International Planned Parenthood claims that its USAID funding goes towards contraceptives in Ethiopia, counselling for HIV/AIDS patients in Kenya and family planning services in Nepal. In a statement, the group said it "will not support policies which actively restrict or take away an individual's right to choose".

Away from the speculation, perhaps the best clue as to what will happen comes from past experience.

According to a report published in the Bulletin of the World Health Organization in 2011, when the policy was implemented under Bush, it actually led to "increases in abortion rates in sub-Saharan African countries".

One possible reason for the increase was that the policy in effect curtailed the activities of organisations that provided condoms and other birth-control methods, resulting in more unwanted pregnancies.

"The results were exactly the opposite as the intended effect of the policy," said Eran Bendavid, one of the researchers and an assistant professor of medicine at Stanford University.

30% OFF
Lumbar Support Pillow for Car with Headrest – Memory Foam Full-Length S-Curve Back & Neck Cushion for Long Drives, Fits Cars, SUVs & Trucks
$32.89 $46.99
46% OFF
Soothfeel Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets – Quick Dry Athletic Shorts in 9", 7" & 5" Inseams for Basketball, Gym & Workout
$12.91 $23.99
40% OFF
Men's Slip On Walking Shoes – Hands-Free Casual Sneakers with Arch Support, Wide Stable Base, Breathable Knit Upper, Non-Slip Traction
$29.99 $49.99
52% OFF
Pudolla Men's UPF 50+ Sun Shirt – Long Sleeve Quick Dry Hiking & Running Shirt with Thumb Holes, Lightweight Moisture-Wicking Rash Guard Base Layer
$11.99 $24.99
35% OFF
Vilanva Women's Walking Shoes – Cushioned Lightweight Running Sneakers with Slip-Resistant Sole, Breathable Woven Upper for Everyday Wear & Workouts
$35.09 $53.99
67% OFF
Rocoren 12-Pack Magnetic Cable Clips – 360° Rotating Cord Organizer with No-Residue Adhesive, Cord Holder for Desk, Nightstand, Wall, Car & Office, White
$6.5 $19.99
60% OFF
Red Light Therapy Mask for Face – 7-Color LED Silicone Facial Mask, Cordless Rechargeable Skincare Device with 240 LEDs for Home & Travel
$39.99 $99.99
77% OFF
Men's Slim Fit Polo Shirt – Quick Dry Moisture Wicking, High Elasticity, Athletic Fit Polo for Golf, Tennis, Work & Casual Wear (Runs Small, Size Up)
$6.99 $29.99
28% OFF
AVANTEK Wireless Doorbell CB-11 – 1000 ft Range, 1 Button + 1 Plug-In Receiver, 115 dB Volume, LED Flash, 52 Chimes, Waterproof, 3-Year Battery
$12.91 $17.99
50% OFF
Women's Workout Shirts – Bum-Covering Length Short Sleeve Dry Fit Tops, Lightweight & Breathable for Athletic, Hiking, Running & Summer Wear
$6.99 $13.99
50% OFF
Coostar Men's Casual Dress Sneakers – Lightweight Wingtip Oxford Style with Breathable Knit Upper, Rubber Sole & Slip-On Elastic Collar, Business & Walking Shoe
$22.49 $44.99
45% OFF
Pudolla Men's Quick Dry Hiking and Golf Shorts with 3 Zipper Pockets
$14.84 $26.99
50% OFF
Venture Pal Ceremonial Grade Matcha Green Tea Powder – First Harvest, Shade Grown, 100% Pure with No Additives, Unsweetened, Vegan & Gluten-Free, 30g Tin
$7.5 $14.99
40% OFF
Venture Pal Sugar Free 7g BCAA + EAA Powder – 9 Essential Amino Acids with L-Glutamine, Caffeine, Electrolytes & Vitamins for Muscle Recovery, Growth & Hydration
$14.99 $24.99
30% OFF
Venture Pal Sugar Free Protein Coffee – Cold Brew Mocha Instant Iced Coffee with MCT Oil, Probiotics, Fiber & 13 Vitamins, 70mg Caffeine, Keto & Gluten-Free, 20 Servings
$13.29 $18.99
20% OFF
Venture Pal Mushroom Hot Cocoa – Natural Sleep Aid with 12 Superfoods, Melatonin 3mg, Magnesium Glycinate, L-Theanine, Glycine, Lion's Mane, Reishi & Turkey Tail, Bedtime Cocoa Mix, 30 Servings
$23.99 $29.99
24% OFF
Cortisol Supplement for Women & Men with Ashwagandha & GABA – Magnesium, L-Theanine & Rhodiola, Stress Support for Sleep, Mood & Focus, 60-Day Supply, Made in USA
$15.29 $19.99
50% OFF
Venture Pal 18-in-1 Creatine for Women – Creatine Monohydrate with Collagen, Myo & D-Chiro Inositol, Electrolytes & Vitamins for Strength, Recovery & Skin Support, Sugar Free, 10.58 oz
$14.99 $29.99
32% OFF
Venture Pal 1000mg Vitamin C Powder with Zinc & Elderberry – Sugar Free B Complex, 10 Vitamins, Minerals & Electrolytes, Daily Immune & Energy Support Packets, 60 Count
$13.59 $19.99
20% OFF
Venture Pal Burn Electrolyte Packets – Sugar Free Hydration with 7 Electrolytes, L-Carnitine, Berberine, ACV & Chromium, Metabolic & Satiety Support, Keto & Vegan, 16 Sticks
$15.99 $19.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
DUP MP Jim Shannon charged with common assault
DUP MP Jim Shannon charged with common assault

DUP MP and prominent Christian parliamentarian Jim Shannon has been charged with common assault.

Vietnamese pastor sentenced to over 7 years in jail
Vietnamese pastor sentenced to over 7 years in jail

Ethnic minority Christians are often accused of being political agitators.

The 'very survival of Christianity' is at risk in Syria
The 'very survival of Christianity' is at risk in Syria

Attempts to build an "inclusive" society have been hampered by militant groups.

Catholic MP Florence Eshalomi appointed new faith minister
Catholic MP Florence Eshalomi appointed new faith minister

Labour MP Florence Eshalomi has been appointed as the government's new faith minister as part of a wider brief covering homelessness, communities and democracy.

Today's Top Deals

Lumbar Support Pillow for Car with Headrest – Memory Foam Full-Length S-Curve Back & Neck Cushion for Long Drives, Fits Cars, SUVs & Trucks

$32.89
$46.99 30% OFF
View Deal

Soothfeel Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets – Quick Dry Athletic Shorts in 9", 7" & 5" Inseams for Basketball, Gym & Workout

$12.91
$23.99 46% OFF
View Deal

Men's Slip On Walking Shoes – Hands-Free Casual Sneakers with Arch Support, Wide Stable Base, Breathable Knit Upper, Non-Slip Traction

$29.99
$49.99 40% OFF
View Deal

Pudolla Men's UPF 50+ Sun Shirt – Long Sleeve Quick Dry Hiking & Running Shirt with Thumb Holes, Lightweight Moisture-Wicking Rash Guard Base Layer

$11.99
$24.99 52% OFF
View Deal

Vilanva Women's Walking Shoes – Cushioned Lightweight Running Sneakers with Slip-Resistant Sole, Breathable Woven Upper for Everyday Wear & Workouts

$35.09
$53.99 35% OFF
View Deal

Rocoren 12-Pack Magnetic Cable Clips – 360° Rotating Cord Organizer with No-Residue Adhesive, Cord Holder for Desk, Nightstand, Wall, Car & Office, White

$6.5
$19.99 67% OFF
View Deal

Red Light Therapy Mask for Face – 7-Color LED Silicone Facial Mask, Cordless Rechargeable Skincare Device with 240 LEDs for Home & Travel

$39.99
$99.99 60% OFF
View Deal

Men's Slim Fit Polo Shirt – Quick Dry Moisture Wicking, High Elasticity, Athletic Fit Polo for Golf, Tennis, Work & Casual Wear (Runs Small, Size Up)

$6.99
$29.99 77% OFF
View Deal

AVANTEK Wireless Doorbell CB-11 – 1000 ft Range, 1 Button + 1 Plug-In Receiver, 115 dB Volume, LED Flash, 52 Chimes, Waterproof, 3-Year Battery

$12.91
$17.99 28% OFF
View Deal

Women's Workout Shirts – Bum-Covering Length Short Sleeve Dry Fit Tops, Lightweight & Breathable for Athletic, Hiking, Running & Summer Wear

$6.99
$13.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Coostar Men's Casual Dress Sneakers – Lightweight Wingtip Oxford Style with Breathable Knit Upper, Rubber Sole & Slip-On Elastic Collar, Business & Walking Shoe

$22.49
$44.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Pudolla Men's Quick Dry Hiking and Golf Shorts with 3 Zipper Pockets

$14.84
$26.99 45% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal Ceremonial Grade Matcha Green Tea Powder – First Harvest, Shade Grown, 100% Pure with No Additives, Unsweetened, Vegan & Gluten-Free, 30g Tin

$7.5
$14.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal Sugar Free 7g BCAA + EAA Powder – 9 Essential Amino Acids with L-Glutamine, Caffeine, Electrolytes & Vitamins for Muscle Recovery, Growth & Hydration

$14.99
$24.99 40% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal Sugar Free Protein Coffee – Cold Brew Mocha Instant Iced Coffee with MCT Oil, Probiotics, Fiber & 13 Vitamins, 70mg Caffeine, Keto & Gluten-Free, 20 Servings

$13.29
$18.99 30% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal Mushroom Hot Cocoa – Natural Sleep Aid with 12 Superfoods, Melatonin 3mg, Magnesium Glycinate, L-Theanine, Glycine, Lion's Mane, Reishi & Turkey Tail, Bedtime Cocoa Mix, 30 Servings

$23.99
$29.99 20% OFF
View Deal

Cortisol Supplement for Women & Men with Ashwagandha & GABA – Magnesium, L-Theanine & Rhodiola, Stress Support for Sleep, Mood & Focus, 60-Day Supply, Made in USA

$15.29
$19.99 24% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal 18-in-1 Creatine for Women – Creatine Monohydrate with Collagen, Myo & D-Chiro Inositol, Electrolytes & Vitamins for Strength, Recovery & Skin Support, Sugar Free, 10.58 oz

$14.99
$29.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal 1000mg Vitamin C Powder with Zinc & Elderberry – Sugar Free B Complex, 10 Vitamins, Minerals & Electrolytes, Daily Immune & Energy Support Packets, 60 Count

$13.59
$19.99 32% OFF
View Deal

Venture Pal Burn Electrolyte Packets – Sugar Free Hydration with 7 Electrolytes, L-Carnitine, Berberine, ACV & Chromium, Metabolic & Satiety Support, Keto & Vegan, 16 Sticks

$15.99
$19.99 20% OFF
View Deal