U.S. pastor proposes all-gender bathrooms will fully separated stalls, each with its own toilet and amenities

Ryan Phipps' all-gender bathroom proposal. (Open Convergence/Ryan Phipps)

With the growing debate on bathroom laws in the U.S., a New York City pastor is proposing the construction of all-inclusive restrooms that would accommodate everyone in malls, schools and other places frequented by the public.

Ryan Phipps of the Forefront Church in Manhattan says, "I've had about as much as I can take of the 'anti-transgender-people-in-bathrooms' discussion."

"We have dressing rooms in just about every major clothing store that are not gender segregated. Why can't we have bathrooms be the very same?" he writes on the Open Convergence blog.

He says his restroom plan will suit the needs "of all human beings, whether they be gay, straight, transgender, man, woman, child, handicapped, you name it."

Under his proposal, the restroom will have fully separated stalls, each with its own toilet, sink, mirror, trash can, hand dryer and diaper changing station.

He says security cameras will be installed to monitor people entering and exiting the facility for safety reasons but these will not see anything happening in each stall.

The stalls will have walls and doors from floor to ceiling to protect the privacy of the user.

"By making one bathroom that all people can use, available space is doubled by the elimination of the other gender-separated space. In addition, eliminating the sinks outside the stalls creates space for them inside each stall," he explains.

Phipps said his proposal has much more to do with faith.

"The church should be at the very forefront of ideas that promote the dignity, worth, and well-being of all people, demolishing debates and discussions that don't get to the real subject at hand. The subject is people, not principle," he says.

He says there are practical ways to serve everyone, but it will never surface if everyone is bickering over principle.

"There are ways for everyone to have a place, whether that is in a dressing room, a bathroom, or even a church, but we must take the high road in our thinking. I think the Apostle Paul said it well," he says.

The pastor tells Christians to ask themselves: "Are you doing this? Are you demolishing arguments and pretension that keep people from knowing God? Are you taking your thoughts captive to the way of Jesus, who didn't turn people away, but who found a way to welcome them?"

related articles
South Dakota\'s Republican governor vetoes bathroom bill that seeks to protect privacy of students in school
South Dakota's Republican governor vetoes bathroom bill that seeks to protect privacy of students in school

South Dakota's Republican governor vetoes bathroom bill that seeks to protect privacy of students in school

New York City mayor signs order allowing transgenders to use city-owned facilities
New York City mayor signs order allowing transgenders to use city-owned facilities

New York City mayor signs order allowing transgenders to use city-owned facilities

Phoenix City council brings back prayer to public meetings — but limited to fire, police chaplains
Phoenix City council brings back prayer to public meetings — but limited to fire, police chaplains

Phoenix City council brings back prayer to public meetings — but limited to fire, police chaplains

San Francisco mayor bans travel to North Carolina over bathroom privacy law
San Francisco mayor bans travel to North Carolina over bathroom privacy law

San Francisco mayor bans travel to North Carolina over bathroom privacy law

North Carolina attorney general refuses to defend bathroom law, calling it a \'national embarrassment\'
North Carolina attorney general refuses to defend bathroom law, calling it a 'national embarrassment'

North Carolina attorney general refuses to defend bathroom law, calling it a 'national embarrassment'

Hundreds of Christians join North Carolina rally to support new bathroom privacy law
Hundreds of Christians join North Carolina rally to support new bathroom privacy law

Hundreds of Christians join North Carolina rally to support new bathroom privacy law

North Carolina governor amends bathroom law to allow private establishments to set their own rules
North Carolina governor amends bathroom law to allow private establishments to set their own rules

North Carolina governor amends bathroom law to allow private establishments to set their own rules

Cirque du Soleil cancels North Carolina shows over bathroom law; governor scores gay lobby
Cirque du Soleil cancels North Carolina shows over bathroom law; governor scores gay lobby

Cirque du Soleil cancels North Carolina shows over bathroom law; governor scores gay lobby

Lawmakers may override Tennessee governor's veto, make Bible official state book

Lawmakers may override Tennessee governor's veto, make Bible official state book

L.A. school opens gender-neutral restroom, sparking protest from concerned parents
L.A. school opens gender-neutral restroom, sparking protest from concerned parents

L.A. school opens gender-neutral restroom, sparking protest from concerned parents

U.S. appeals court rules in favour of transgender student in bathroom case
U.S. appeals court rules in favour of transgender student in bathroom case

U.S. appeals court rules in favour of transgender student in bathroom case

Obama says North Carolina, Mississippi bathroom laws are \'wrong and should be overturned\'
Obama says North Carolina, Mississippi bathroom laws are 'wrong and should be overturned'

Obama says North Carolina, Mississippi bathroom laws are 'wrong and should be overturned'

News
King Charles attends Royal Maundy service in Wales
King Charles attends Royal Maundy service in Wales

Hundreds of people gathered at St Asaph Cathedral on Thursday for the annual Royal Maundy service, held in Wales for only the second time in the service's 800-year history.

Welsh church to hear full bell ring for first time at Easter service
Welsh church to hear full bell ring for first time at Easter service

Over 150 years since a north Wales church was built with plans for a full ring of bells, the sound long intended for its tower is finally set to be heard at an Easter service.

'Gordon Brown: Power with Purpose', by James Macintyre
'Gordon Brown: Power with Purpose', by James Macintyre

'Gordon Brown: Power with Purpose' is beautifully written, with an unusually nuanced approach to political matters.

MPs reminded of impact of Christian faith in politics with book gift
MPs reminded of impact of Christian faith in politics with book gift

Alastair Campbell famously declared "We don't do God."