Kentucky clerk's case all about forcing Christians to violate their religious beliefs, lawyers say

The case of Kim Davis, the Rowan County clerk, is not about granting marriage licences to same-sex couples but forcing Christians to violate their religious beliefs, Davis' lawyers contended.

In a filing with the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday, Davis' lawyers said US District Judge David Bunning, who issued the injunction and imprisonment of Davis, erred in his decisions as he violated her right to due process and religious freedom.

Davis imposed a no marriage licence policy on her office after the US Supreme Court legalised same-sex marriage (SSM) last June.

Davis, the filing read, "has consistently argued that there were multiple alternatives by which her undisputed sincerely held religious beliefs protected by the Kentucky Religious Freedom Restoration Act and the First Amendment, both of which predate and survive Obergefell, could be accommodated while simultaneously ensuring individuals who are qualified to marry under Kentucky law may obtain valid marriage licences in Rowan County," according to WND.

"In a rush to judgment that promoted expediency over due process, the district court's original injunction [from Bunning] in this dispute tramples upon Davis' religious rights in subjugation to plaintiffs' 'preference' for a marriage licence authorised by a particular person in a particular county," it said.

The filing said same-sex couple's "purported rights should not trump Davis' undisputed sincerely held religious beliefs."

It said the plaintiffs could have gone to a different county to get their marriage licence.

"Marriage licences – including licences issued to same-sex couples — are and have been readily available across Kentucky in more than 130 locations, and plaintiffs are indisputably financially and physically able to drive to those locations to secure a licence, as shown by their 60-mile and 100-mile trips to attend court hearings," the brief said.

The lawyers argued that nothing in the Supreme Court decision "compels states to accomplish recognition [or equal treatment] of SSM by invading and trampling upon the conscience of individual county clerks, as occurred with the SSM mandate."

It said Davis' imprisonment was done "without affording her appropriate due process, violating her rights under the Federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act, and discarding fundamental principles of federalism and comity by commandeering a state office run by a publicly elected official."

Davis tried to get accommodation for the religious beliefs from the legislature or the governor but none responded.

It said the same-sex couples targeted a Christian from which to get their licence.

"Plaintiffs admitted that they never even attempted to obtain a licence in any county other than Rowan County, despite the widespread availability of such licences and even though plaintiffs have the economic means and no physical handicap preventing such travel. ... In fact, plaintiffs only attempted to obtain a marriage licence from the Rowan County clerk's office after becoming aware of Davis' religious objections to SSM," it said.

related articles
Pope Francis met privately with jailed US county clerk Kim Davis, law firm says
Pope Francis met privately with jailed US county clerk Kim Davis, law firm says

Pope Francis told Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis to "stay strong" as he met her and her husband in Washington, D.C., according to a press statement issued by the Liberty Counsel.

Pope Francis told Kim Davis to \'stay strong\' in private meeting
Pope Francis told Kim Davis to 'stay strong' in private meeting

Pope Francis reportedly met privately with Kim Davis while he was in Washington on Thursday and commended her courage in refusing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples.

Kim Davis denies Vatican account of her meeting with Pope, says she was invited
Kim Davis denies Vatican account of her meeting with Pope, says she was invited

Disturbed by statements coming from the Vatican, gay marriage nemesis Kim Davis would like to set the records straight that it was the Vatican that extended an "unsolicited invitation" for her to hold a "private meeting" with Pope Francis at the Vatican embassy in Washington D.C. last Sept. 24.

Lesbian couple show \'true colours\' in new attack on Christian county clerk Kim Davis
Lesbian couple show 'true colours' in new attack on Christian county clerk Kim Davis

The founder of a law firm representing defiant Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis accused a same-sex couple who filed a suit against her for forcing their beliefs on her.

Christian voters strongly back Mike Huckabee as next US president: \'Closest to a King David running\'
Christian voters strongly back Mike Huckabee as next US president: 'Closest to a King David running'

If Christian voters only had their way, then former Arkansas governor and Republican presidential hopeful Mike Huckabee would become the next president of the United States.

Gays push proposed Equality Act aimed at destroying religious freedom in US
Gays push proposed Equality Act aimed at destroying religious freedom in US

After the US Supreme Court legalized gay marriage in June, a new bill seeks to provide more rights to LGBT.

Pat Robertson maintains that gay marriage is still illegal despite Supreme Court ruling
Pat Robertson maintains that gay marriage is still illegal despite Supreme Court ruling

Even though the United States Supreme Court earlier ruled that same-sex marriage is now legal in the United States, Christian televangelist and "The 700 Club" host Pat Robertson said on Monday that the act is still illegal.

Justice Anthony Kennedy likens US Supreme Court to Hitler\'s judiciary on same-sex marriage decision
Justice Anthony Kennedy likens US Supreme Court to Hitler's judiciary on same-sex marriage decision

This is quite incredible but true: An Associate Justice of the US Supreme Court has compared the judiciary in today's America to that of Nazi Germany during the time of Adolf Hitler on how it decided on the same-sex marriage issue.

News
3 sentenced to death for deadly church mass shooting in Jordan
3 sentenced to death for deadly church mass shooting in Jordan

Three men have been sentenced to death by hanging in Jordan for a mass shooting that killed nine people at a funeral in a Greek Orthodox church last month.

Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin

The pair discussed peace with Ukraine and Christians in the Middle East.

Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations
Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations

Dame Sarah Mullally has said that the Church of England’s funding model needs attention as she acknowledged that "too many clergy are struggling".

Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction
Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction

Former Conservative minister and now Anglican prison chaplain, Jonathan Aitken, says the convicted comedian has asked for prayer.