The myth of modern atheism? Unbelief dates back to 500 BC, says Cambridge study

A new Cambridge University study published today argues that atheism is not a modern invention, but rather dates back to 500 BC.

"There is evidence from the 5th Century [BC] onwards, initially quite sketchy but certainly from the 2nd Century BC people were compiling lists of arguments against the existence of the gods," Professor Tim Whitmarsh, Professor of Greek Culture at Cambridge and author of the study, told the Telegraph.

In Battling with the Gods, published today, Whitmarsh sought to debunk the "myth" that atheism is a modern, post-enlightenment invention.

"Adherents wish to present scepticism toward the supernatural as the result of science's progressive eclipse of religion, and the religious wish to see it as a pathological symptom of a decadent Western world consumed by capitalism," he wrote.

"Both are guilty of modernist vanity. Disbelief in the supernatural is as old as the hills."

Speaking to the Telegraph, Whitmarsh said: "Atheism, of course, is a Greek word.

"It started out as a negative term but I think there is evidence that people positively identified as that, using that word."

While the "rhetoric used to describe it [atheism] is hyper-modern", the reality is that "early societies were far more capable than many since of containing atheism within the spectrum of what they considered normal," he said.

The book cites evidence for atheism in the work of ancient Greek thinkers including Xenohanes of Colophon, who was born around 570 BC, and Cameades in the 2nd Century who compiled arguments against the existence of gods.

Without the use of science, "these early atheists were making what seem to be universal objections about the paradoxical nature of religion – the fact that it asks you to accept things that aren't intuitively there in your world.

"The fact that this was happening thousands of years ago suggests that forms of disbelief can exist in all cultures, and probably always have."

related articles
What to say when someone asks for proof of God\'s existence
What to say when someone asks for proof of God's existence

In the second of his series on apologetics, David Robertson tackles the classic question: where is the evidence for Christianity?

Why an atheist philosopher is one of our century\'s greatest prophets
Why an atheist philosopher is one of our century's greatest prophets

His writing about God, human nature and the limits of atheism mean he's in some ways a very astute theologian. Meanwhile his political predictions have seen his hailed as something of a 21st Century prophet. This may well be surprising, given he is also an atheist.

Why should Christians care about theology?
Why should Christians care about theology?

Theology can often seem dense and unappealing, but Krish Kandiah believes it's an essential companion to our flourishing as Christian disciples.

Has the Church succumbed to half-brained thinking?
Has the Church succumbed to half-brained thinking?

Krish Kandiah explores right- and left-brained thinking, and the impact it may have had on the Church.

News
'Passion' star Jim Caviezel recalls the time Jesus appeared to him
'Passion' star Jim Caviezel recalls the time Jesus appeared to him

Actor Jim Caviezel recently claimed that Jesus Christ supernaturally appeared to him more than 20 years ago as he was considering whether to take the starring role in "The Passion of the Christ," Mel Gibson's 2004 film depicting the Crucifixion. 

Frasier star Kelsey Grammer says standing up for Jesus is worth the cost
Frasier star Kelsey Grammer says standing up for Jesus is worth the cost

Emmy Award-winning actor Kelsey Grammer has said he’ll never deny his faith in Jesus Christ, even if standing by his beliefs comes at a personal cost, and shared why he believes Christians have a responsibility to remain steadfast in an increasingly fractured culture.

Why John Stott’s ‘Christian Counter-Culture’ still challenges the church
Why John Stott’s ‘Christian Counter-Culture’ still challenges the church

After more than 45 years, John Stott’s teaching on the Sermon on the Mount remains a fresh challenge to a church too comfortable with the world.

MP challenges plans to light up Belfast City Hall in support of abortion on Easter Sunday
MP challenges plans to light up Belfast City Hall in support of abortion on Easter Sunday

Carla Lockhart MP has spoken out against plans to light up Belfast City Hall in support of abortion on Easter Sunday.