John Stott's classic 'Basic Christianity' under fire

A publisher has hit back at claims that a revised edition of John Stott's classic Basic Christianity changes the book's meaning and is "a bad imitation of the original".

Basic Christianity was first published in 1958. A second edition followed in 1971 and the book has sold millions of copies. Stott, who died in 2011, was an influential Anglican evangelical who inspired several generations of Christians.

A revised edition was undertaken by IVP in the UK and published in 2008. It was published in the US by Eerdmans. Barton Swaim says on the conservative First Things website that Stott's book has been "bowdlerised" for a modern readership. "Two out of every three sentences, I estimate, involve some new wording," he claims.

Blaming Eerdmans rather than IVP, Swaim objects to the revisers dropping references to hymns that were well known in 1971 but are less so today, and to the way in which Stott's language has been updated. He criticises a rewriting of Stott's description of atonement which stresses 'reconciliation', saying: "The newer text leaves the reader free (or freer) to think of the reconciliation Christ has accomplished as the sort of therapeutic fence-mending urged on brawling high-schoolers by their guidance counselors." He says: "The editor and publisher had no right to transform Stott's book as they did, whether or not the author granted his permission."

Swaim's critique was picked up on social media and widely shared.

What Eerdmans did to John Stott's "Basic Christianity" is an insult to both the book's author and its readers https://t.co/VGNclwj5nU

— BetweenTwoWorlds (@between2worlds) April 15, 2016 " data-caption="null" data-credit="null">

However, it received a robust rebuttal from Wm B Eerdmans' editor in chief, James Ernest, who pointed out that Stott himself approved the rewrite and hit out at "incomplete research and careless re-tweeting".

Ernest said: "John Stott did not see himself as the author of a classic. He wanted to – and did – author a little book that served a practical, evangelistic purpose. And, stellar preacher and communicator that he was, he understood that what communicates effectively in one time and place must be changed to communicate effectively in another."

He continued: "First Things and Barton Swaim published an essay that appears designed to provoke readers and score culture-war points – all at the expense of Eerdmans's reputation. They did so without bothering to ascertain certain relevant facts, which we would have gladly supplied if they had asked us."

The chief executive of IVP-UK, Sam Richardson, told Christian Today: "The new edition was undertaken with John Stott's approval and I know he was happy with the approach taken.

"I see it as an update rather than a substantial revision. The update re-established the book as one of IVP's best-selling titles and as a result it continues to impact the lives of many people."

First Things issued an apology for Swaim's errors but defended his overall critique of the book. 

related articles
Christians hail John Stott’s legacy

Tributes continue to be paid to John Stott, one of the world’s most important evangelical leaders, who died on Wednesday at the age of 90.

Christians bid final farewell to Uncle John

There were moments of poignant reflection but also much laughter and thanksgiving at the funeral of John Stott today.

The woman John Stott couldn\'t live without
The woman John Stott couldn't live without

'John Stott wrote 50 books. I typed 50 books.' The story of John Stott's right hand woman, Frances Whitehead, has been published in a new book by Julia Cameron.

SPCK and IVP unite: Does evangelical publishing have a future?
SPCK and IVP unite: Does evangelical publishing have a future?

Evangelical publisher IVP is to come under the umbrella of rival publisher SPCK.

News
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin

The pair discussed peace with Ukraine and Christians in the Middle East.

Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations
Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations

Dame Sarah Mullally has said that the Church of England’s funding model needs attention as she acknowledged that "too many clergy are struggling".

Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction
Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction

Former Conservative minister and now Anglican prison chaplain, Jonathan Aitken, says the convicted comedian has asked for prayer.

Attacks on Christians in Europe rise by 44%, report finds
Attacks on Christians in Europe rise by 44%, report finds

Recorded attacks on Christians in Europe rose by 44% in 2025, according to a new report that also raises concerns about restrictions on the public expression of Christian faith.