Conservative bloggers claim some passages in encyclical on family were ghost written

An adviser to Pope Francis from his home country of Argentina was a "ghostwriter" of some of the most important passages of his new document on the family, according to the influential Rome blogger Sandro Magister

Central passages of Amoris Laetitia are based on earlier writings by Víctor Manuel Fernández, he claims.

"They are the key paragraphs," he writes. "And they are also the most intentionally ambiguous."

Crucially, he adds, they are the paragraphs of chapter eight that appear to give the go-ahead to communion for the divorced and remarried.

Magister draws similarities between texts in the encyclical and two articles from 2005 and 2006 by Fernández when he was professor of theology at the Universidad Católica Argentina in Buenos Aires. Fernández was ordained a bishop shortly after the election of Pope Francis in 2013.

Magister also quotes Fernández' first book: Heal me with your mouth. The art of kissing, published in 1995 in Argentina. The author wrote: "In these pages I would like to summarise the popular sentiment, that which people feel when they think of a kiss, that which mortals feel when they kiss. This is why I spoke for a long time with many persons who have a great deal of experience in this matter, and also with many young people who are learning to kiss in their way. Moreover, I have consulted many books and I wanted to show how the poets speak of the kiss.

"In this way, with the intention of summarizing the immense richness of life have come these pages on behalf of the kiss, which I hope may help you to kiss better, urge you to liberate in a kiss the best of your being."

Religious commentator Damian Thompson, writing in The Spectator, says Magister's claims "will severely embarrass Francis as he tries to clear up confusion over the Church's teaching on Communion for the divorced and remarried."

On the question of whether Catholics in an irregular second marriage are living in a state of mortal sin, Thompson suggests Francis borrowed his thinking from Fernández.

"Vatican sources claim that Archbishop Fernández has been boasting that he wrote parts of Amoris Laetitia. If so, they don't appear to be empty boasts," he writes.

related articles
Amoris Laetitia: How the Pope\'s exhortation could shake up the Church
Amoris Laetitia: How the Pope's exhortation could shake up the Church

The Pope's long-anticipated exhortation following the two Synods on the family, Amoris Laetitia (The Joy of Love) has been published.

Amoris Laetitia: Why can\'t divorced and remarried Catholics receive the Eucharist and other questions you may have about Communion after Pope Francis\' apostolic exhortation
Amoris Laetitia: Why can't divorced and remarried Catholics receive the Eucharist and other questions you may have about Communion after Pope Francis' apostolic exhortation

There was much speculation that Pope Francis would directly address the question of Communion for divorced and remarried Catholic couples in his apostolic exhortation today, but the reference to it was limited and open to interpretation. For many Catholics, the Pope's statement will raise more questions that it answers. And for non-Catholics, the release of the Amoris Laetitia ("The Joy of Love")and the significance of the whole Communion question is likely to leave them feeling puzzled too.

The top 5 reasons people like Pope Francis
The top 5 reasons people like Pope Francis

He's one of the most popular public figures in the world. So what is it that people say they like about Pope Francis, and what can it teach us about leadership?

Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia and feminism: Is the Pope pro-women?

Laura Bates, author of Everyday Sexism, debated in the Guardian yesterday whether or not Pope Francis can be deemed a feminist. She said it's complicated, and she's right.

Pope Francis affirms \'new possibilities\' for remarried, says no politics in meeting with Bernie Sanders
Pope Francis affirms 'new possibilities' for remarried, says no politics in meeting with Bernie Sanders

Pope Francis appeared to have confirmed his critics' deepest concern, telling journalists on Sunday that the apostolic exhortation on family he issued recently did open up "new concrete possibilities" for Catholics who divorce and remarry without first obtaining annulments.

News
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin

The pair discussed peace with Ukraine and Christians in the Middle East.

Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations
Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations

Dame Sarah Mullally has said that the Church of England’s funding model needs attention as she acknowledged that "too many clergy are struggling".

Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction
Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction

Former Conservative minister and now Anglican prison chaplain, Jonathan Aitken, says the convicted comedian has asked for prayer.

Attacks on Christians in Europe rise by 44%, report finds
Attacks on Christians in Europe rise by 44%, report finds

Recorded attacks on Christians in Europe rose by 44% in 2025, according to a new report that also raises concerns about restrictions on the public expression of Christian faith.