Egypt: Doctor and father acquitted after girl, 13, 'died from FGM'

A landmark trial in Egypt has seen the doctor and father of a 13-year-old girl who died after allegedly undergoing female genital mutilation (FGM) walk free.

Both men were cleared of all charges, after insisting that teenager Suhair al-Bata'a, who died in June last year, was killed by a penicillin allergy.

Campaigners have expressed their disappointment with the outcome of the trial, with hopes for a crackdown against FGM now dashed. Manal Fawzy of the Childhood and Development Association told the BBC that "Now it will be easy for any doctor to perform such surgeries."

"Of course there will be no stopping any doctor after this. Any doctor can do any FGM he wants now," Atef Aboelenein, a lawyer for the Women's Centre for Guidance and Legal Awareness, has also warned.

FGM is illegal under Egyptian law, but the practice remains alarmingly widespread. Suhair's case was the first time that a doctor has been brought to trial in the country on charges of undertaking the procedure.

Dr Raslan Fadl denied carrying out FGM. He said he removed a wart from Suhair's genital area, making only a small incision.

However, evidence provided by Egypt's forensic authority "proved what happened in the genital area of the girl was a clear circumcision operation," the prosecuting lawyer said.

The judge did not give a reason for his not-guilty verdict yesterday. It was not even announced in the courtroom, but was instead written on a leger.

"It is awful that after what seemed to be strong moves towards a positive outcome, Suhair has not been given justice," said Suad Abu Dayyeh from Equality Now, an NGO which has campaigned on the case.

"It sends a very negative message. It was the first case in the country and we were hoping we could build on it."

She urged the Egyptian government to "take FGM seriously," adding that it is "vital" to protect millions of women and girls who are at risk.

FGM is also known as female circumcision, or female genital cutting, and refers to any procedure that removes part or all of the external female genitalia, or alters or injures the genital organs in any way without medical reason.

Unicef estimates that more than 90 per cent of Egyptian women under 50 have undergone the procedure. It is regarded as a rite of passage into womanhood by many cultures, while some believe that it makes a woman less likely to commit adultery.

A summit was held in London in July of this year in the hopes of mobilising initiatives to end FGM and forced-marriages around the world.

125 million girls worldwide are thought to have undergone the procedure, and David Cameron has set up a £1.4 million FGM prevention programme. He has denounced the practice as "abhorrent".

"All girls have the right to live free from violence and coercion, without being forced into marriage or the lifelong physical and psychological effects of female genital mutilation," he said.

"Abhorrent practices like these, no matter how deeply rooted in societies, violate the rights of girls and women across the world, including here in the UK."

related articles
UK must do more to end female genital mutilation
UK must do more to end female genital mutilation

World Vision has released a new report to mark the International Day of Zero Tolerance on Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) on 6 February.

What do women have to say about their place in this world?

We speak to some inspirational Christian women to find out what they have to say about International Women's Day

\'Girls in UK Sunday schools are victims of FGM - the Church must take a stand\'
'Girls in UK Sunday schools are victims of FGM - the Church must take a stand'

66,000 girls aged 13 and under are at risk of FGM in the UK. IN Tanzania, it's more prevalent among Christians than Muslims. Ann-Marie Wilson tells Christian Today why she's challenging Synod to act.

David Cameron to unveil £1.4million FGM prevention programme at #GirlSummit
David Cameron to unveil £1.4million FGM prevention programme at #GirlSummit

A conference to end FGM, child and forced marriage is being held in London today, July 22.

What is FGM and what can be done during \'cutting season\'?
What is FGM and what can be done during 'cutting season'?

How can we protect the 66,000 girls in the UK at risk of being cut?

News
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda

A judge in Uganda has sentenced five Muslims to death for killing two Christian evangelists in 2024.

Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests
Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests

Authorities in Indonesia recently allowed construction to proceed on worship buildings of two churches in different provinces despite vigorous protests from Muslim groups.

Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations
Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations

Scholar Dan McClellan alleged that Wes Huff plagiarized a 2016 Tyndale Seminary paper.

Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth
Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth

Adult baptisms in the Church of England have increased by a third in a year, with almost 10,000 adults being baptised in 2025, according to newly published figures.