Church decline: Is evangelicalism to blame?

Nearly half the country has no religion, says a new survey by Lancaster University researchers.

There's also been a significant increase in the number of "nones" in the last three years.

The significance of these figures in terms of actual numbers attending church isn't all that obvious; we all know that's been going down for ages, and whether you accept the assurances of church leaders that the green shoots have bottomed out depends largely on your propensity to optimism.

This survey – whose results are released tomorrow – isn't just about numbers attending, though, but about how people actually feel about Church. Increasing numbers no longer feel it represents their spiritual and moral values. This is a change. In times past, people might not have attended very often, if at all, but they still identified at some level with it. "I'm C of E, I suppose" was the unreflecting response to questions about religion.

One reason is that society has changed and most of the Church has not. Lancaster University's Linda Woodhead says: "Religious sexism and homophobia is one part of the reason why we are now a 'no religion' majority country – overwhelmingly so amongst younger generations."

Resistance to women's ministry might not, in fairness, be exactly sexism, and resistance to same-sex marriage might not be down to homophobia, but that's the perception. That, conservatives might say, is the price you pay for faithfulness to the gospel. Chasing popularity at the expense of principle is the road to ruin.

This is a problem without a solution: being against homosexuality in a liberal society is never going to be wildly popular except among people with whom the Church wouldn't really wish to be associated. Whether a Church that embraced same-sex marriage would do any better at the numbers game is a different question. Judging by the experience of the Episcopal Church in the US, the answer is no; it is declining rapidly.

But is the problem even more fundamental than that?

During the last few years evangelicalism has become the dominant force in UK Christianity. One of its key distinctives is the need for the individual to choose to become a disciple of Jesus. For evangelicals, no one is born a Christian. It is a personal decision, to be marked in the lively and flourishing charismatic-type churches by baptism, the rite of initiation into the Church. Churches might have a "fringe" of people who attend parents and toddler groups and other social-type meetings – and they might even turn up to services occasionally – but they aren't part of the "real" church unless they're committed believers.

On this understanding, the reluctance of people to say that they are Christians is an inevitable part of the evangelical narrative: "We know we aren't Christians, because you tell us we aren't."

And that, an evangelical Christian might say, is the price you pay for faithfulness to the gospel. Chasing popularity at the expense of principle is the road to ruin.

article,article,article,article,article Also by Mark Woods

But what it means is that just as the world is moving further away from the Church, through the public affirmation of forms of behaviour the Church really struggles with, so the Church is moving further away from the world, with its increasing insistence on drawing hard and fast lines around who's in and who's out.

Many evangelicals – perhaps most – will want to say, "That's just the way it is. The Church is a Church of disciples or it isn't a Church at all."

At its most fundamental level, that has to be true. As a Baptist, my own spiritual ancestors left the established Church of England because they couldn't accept that it included so many people who were part of it by virtue of their baptism but showed no evidence of faith in their lives.

But evangelicalism has to ask itself whether it's entirely helpful to remove people's sense of belonging by confronting them with a choice they might not be ready to make. A binary, in-or-out, adversarial gospel is not always very appealing.

Is it possible to combine warm inclusivity with a full-blooded call to repentance and faith? It won't be easy, but without that sort of theological and pastoral effort the Church will be increasingly sidelined from the mainstream of public life and thought.

Follow Mark Woods on Twitter: @RevMarkWoods

50% OFF
HDPE All-Weather Adirondack Chair with Built-In Cup Holder - Tool-Free Assembly (Grey)
$69.99 $139.99
10% OFF
aumuca Undercoat Rake for Dogs & Cats - Professional Deshedder and Dematting Grooming Comb
$17.99 $19.99
15% OFF
Hypoallergenic Pet Wipes for Dogs & Cats - 400 Count Extra Large Coconut Scented Grooming Wipes
$25.49 $29.99
60% OFF
HOMETUK Clear Plastic Storage Bins with Dividers - 3-Pack Stackable Acrylic Organizer Containers for Fridge and Pantry
$19.99 $49.99
58% OFF
G Gradual Men's Fishing Shirt - UPF 50+ Lightweight Short Sleeve Button Down with Zipper Pockets
$14.99 $35.99
11% OFF
VitaUp Beet Root Gummies with CoQ10 & Grape Seed - Nitric Oxide Circulation Support (60 Count)
$24.91 $27.91
51% OFF
G Gradual Men's Athletic Workout T-Shirt - Moisture Wicking Cooling Short Sleeve Running Tee
$9.89 $19.99
55% OFF
Everyfun 60" Rectangular Platform Tree Swing - 700lbs Heavy Duty Adjustable Outdoor Swing (Colorful)
$49.99 $110.99
49% OFF
Ekouaer Jumpsuits for Women Dressy Casual - Ruffle Cap Sleeve Rib Knit Summer Romper
$14.99 $29.51
61% OFF
Ekouaer Women's Casual Loose Jumpsuit - One-Piece Printed Sleeveless Wide Leg Romper with Pockets
$14.99 $37.99
50% OFF
Ekouaer Lounge Sets for Women - V-Neck Two-Piece Short Pajama Set with Large Pockets
$9.9 $19.99
40% OFF
ROTAKE TB3 20V Heavy Duty 1/2" Cordless Impact Wrench Kit - 1380 Ft-Lbs Torque
$132 $219.99
36% OFF
Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry
$12.74 $19.99
61% OFF
Modern Ceiling Fan with Light and Remote - Reversible Quiet DC Motor
$69.3 $179.99
50% OFF
MOOKA H13 True HEPA Air Purifier for Home Large Room - 1076 sq ft Odor Eliminator
$39.97 $79.95
50% OFF
LINGDU V630 3-Channel 4K Dash Cam - Front, Cabin, and Rear Triple Car Camera with 64GB Card
$69.99 $139.99
60% OFF
GKBK Women’s Ribbed Short Sleeve Scoop Neck Slim Fit Tee – Stretchy Basic Summer Top 2026 Trendy Outfit Essential
$4 $9.99
60% OFF
Ekouaer Women's Satin Silky Pajama Set - Short Sleeve Pullover Top & Wide-Leg Pants
$13.99 $34.99
55% OFF
Ekouaer 3-Piece Maternity & Nursing Pajamas Set - Short Sleeve Top with Shorts and Pants
$14.99 $32.99
Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump
$0 $113.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
related articles
Comment: Why Evangelicals can\'t support Israel\'s land grabs
Comment: Why Evangelicals can't support Israel's land grabs

Comment: Why Evangelicals can't support Israel's land grabs

Mark Woods: Stephen Fry, eye-worms and bone cancer - how Christians can still believe in the goodness of God
Mark Woods: Stephen Fry, eye-worms and bone cancer - how Christians can still believe in the goodness of God

Mark Woods: Stephen Fry, eye-worms and bone cancer - how Christians can still believe in the goodness of God

The Government\'s blind spot: Why it doesn\'t get Islam
The Government's blind spot: Why it doesn't get Islam

The Government's blind spot: Why it doesn't get Islam

Why it\'s OK not to go to church this Sunday
Why it's OK not to go to church this Sunday

Why it's OK not to go to church this Sunday

Blue Monday: Why God doesn\'t want you to be happy
Blue Monday: Why God doesn't want you to be happy

Blue Monday: Why God doesn't want you to be happy

News
Biblical models and the creation of King Arthur
Biblical models and the creation of King Arthur

It is a frequent feature of Christian history that believers seek to understand their contemporary world by drawing parallels with biblical history. This can lead to some very ‘creative’ (and selective) interactions with the Bible; usually with Old Testament events. One remarkable example led to the creation of the figure of (King) Arthur. 

UK Supreme Court to hear Christian schools’ challenge to VAT on private school fees
UK Supreme Court to hear Christian schools’ challenge to VAT on private school fees

The UK Supreme Court has granted permission for a group of independent Christian schools, parents and pupils to appeal against the government’s decision to impose VAT on private school fees.

Christian police officer reaches settlement over diversity training discrimination claim
Christian police officer reaches settlement over diversity training discrimination claim

North Yorkshire Police have reached a confidential settlement with a former police community support officer (PCSO) who claimed he was discriminated against and forced out after raising questions about Islam during mandatory diversity training.

Historic Lancashire church secures £250,000 National Lottery grant for major roof repairs
Historic Lancashire church secures £250,000 National Lottery grant for major roof repairs

A historic Lancashire church has secured £250,000 in funding from the National Lottery Heritage Fund to carry out urgent repairs that will safeguard one of Oswaldtwistle's oldest buildings.

Today's Top Deals

HDPE All-Weather Adirondack Chair with Built-In Cup Holder - Tool-Free Assembly (Grey)

$69.99
$139.99 50% OFF
View Deal

aumuca Undercoat Rake for Dogs & Cats - Professional Deshedder and Dematting Grooming Comb

$17.99
$19.99 10% OFF
View Deal

Hypoallergenic Pet Wipes for Dogs & Cats - 400 Count Extra Large Coconut Scented Grooming Wipes

$25.49
$29.99 15% OFF
View Deal

HOMETUK Clear Plastic Storage Bins with Dividers - 3-Pack Stackable Acrylic Organizer Containers for Fridge and Pantry

$19.99
$49.99 60% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's Fishing Shirt - UPF 50+ Lightweight Short Sleeve Button Down with Zipper Pockets

$14.99
$35.99 58% OFF
View Deal

VitaUp Beet Root Gummies with CoQ10 & Grape Seed - Nitric Oxide Circulation Support (60 Count)

$24.91
$27.91 11% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's Athletic Workout T-Shirt - Moisture Wicking Cooling Short Sleeve Running Tee

$9.89
$19.99 51% OFF
View Deal

Everyfun 60" Rectangular Platform Tree Swing - 700lbs Heavy Duty Adjustable Outdoor Swing (Colorful)

$49.99
$110.99 55% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer Jumpsuits for Women Dressy Casual - Ruffle Cap Sleeve Rib Knit Summer Romper

$14.99
$29.51 49% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer Women's Casual Loose Jumpsuit - One-Piece Printed Sleeveless Wide Leg Romper with Pockets

$14.99
$37.99 61% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer Lounge Sets for Women - V-Neck Two-Piece Short Pajama Set with Large Pockets

$9.9
$19.99 50% OFF
View Deal

ROTAKE TB3 20V Heavy Duty 1/2" Cordless Impact Wrench Kit - 1380 Ft-Lbs Torque

$132
$219.99 40% OFF
View Deal

Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry

$12.74
$19.99 36% OFF
View Deal

Modern Ceiling Fan with Light and Remote - Reversible Quiet DC Motor

$69.3
$179.99 61% OFF
View Deal

MOOKA H13 True HEPA Air Purifier for Home Large Room - 1076 sq ft Odor Eliminator

$39.97
$79.95 50% OFF
View Deal

LINGDU V630 3-Channel 4K Dash Cam - Front, Cabin, and Rear Triple Car Camera with 64GB Card

$69.99
$139.99 50% OFF
View Deal

GKBK Women’s Ribbed Short Sleeve Scoop Neck Slim Fit Tee – Stretchy Basic Summer Top 2026 Trendy Outfit Essential

$4
$9.99 60% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer Women's Satin Silky Pajama Set - Short Sleeve Pullover Top & Wide-Leg Pants

$13.99
$34.99 60% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer 3-Piece Maternity & Nursing Pajamas Set - Short Sleeve Top with Shorts and Pants

$14.99
$32.99 55% OFF
View Deal

Sealy 2-Pack Tritech 16" Twin Inflatable Air Mattress with Built-in AC Pump

$0
$113.99 0% OFF
View Deal