Atheists file lawsuit against Texas governor for removal of Bill of Rights 'nativity' scene at State Capitol

A group of atheists has filed a lawsuit against Texas Gov. Greg Abbott for removing a Bill of Rights "nativity" display at the State Capitol in Austin, Texas last December, which the governor found offensive.

The lawsuit was filed on Feb. 25 by the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) before the U.S. District Court in the Western District of Texas.

It alleged that Abbott and the Texas State Preservation Board, which approved the display, violated its free speech, equal protection and due process rights, and Establishment Clause when they removed the display, which featured "Cut-out figures celebrating the December 15 nativity of the Bill of Rights."

It showed "Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, George Washington, and the Statue of Liberty gathered around the Bill of Rights, which was placed in a manger."

The display was put on Dec. 18 last year and was removed upon the orders of Abbott three days later.

In a post on Twitter, Abbott wrote, "Mocking the Capitol nativity scene is offensive. I demand [the] removal of [the] satirical 'nativity scene' from Capitol," according to WND.

In a letter to the State Preservation Board, a copy of which was obtained by Breitbart News, Abbott said the "juvenile parody violates the Preservation Board's regulations and should be removed immediately."

"The biblical scene of the newly born Jesus Christ lying in a manger in Bethlehem lies at the very heart of the Christian faith. Subjecting an image held sacred by millions of Texans to the Foundation's tasteless sarcasm does nothing to promote morals and the general welfare," Abbott said.

Instead, he said, the display "is intentionally designed to belittle and offend, which undermines rather than promotes any public purpose a display promoting the Bill of Rights might otherwise have had."

FFRF's lawsuit said Abbott's action showed "unambiguous viewpoint discrimination" and was also motivated by "animus" towards it and its nontheistic message.

According to the atheist group, Abbott has a long history of hate against FFRF when he was the state attorney general.

"Gov. Abbott has consistently advocated for displays of religion in the public sphere, while actively opposing any expression of nonreligious principles," FFRF said.

related articles
Kentucky students defy atheists by holding \'illegal\' prayer at pre-football game event
Kentucky students defy atheists by holding 'illegal' prayer at pre-football game event

Students at a Kentucky school defied an aetheist group's campaign against religious practices when they recited a prayer at a pre-footbal game ceremony.

Lawyers\' group defends US schools from atheists who want football chaplains out
Lawyers' group defends US schools from atheists who want football chaplains out

A religious organization has vowed to defend colleges and universities that have footbal chaplains against claims by a group of atheists who charged that they are unconstitutional.

Pastor asks atheist critics of Georgia school football team\'s mass baptism: \'When did it  become illegal to say I\'m a Christian?\'
Pastor asks atheist critics of Georgia school football team's mass baptism: 'When did it become illegal to say I'm a Christian?'

The pastor of the First Baptist Church in Villa Rica, Georgia, has responded to a group of atheists who denounced the mass baptism of the football coach and players of the Villa Rica High School, asking: "When did it become illegal to bow your head and pray? When did it become illegal to say I'm a Christian?"

Atheists end 25-year-old Christmas choir tradition, but Christians are fighting back
Atheists end 25-year-old Christmas choir tradition, but Christians are fighting back

The Wisconsin-based atheist group might think that they have scored a victory by taking down the 25-year Christmas tradition called Grotto's Christmas Festival of Lights in Oregon, but Christians living in the area are not willing to let it go without a fight.

Gideons says its Bibles save souls, but atheists want hotels to replace them with Charles Darwin\'s book
Gideons says its Bibles save souls, but atheists want hotels to replace them with Charles Darwin's book

The largest association of atheists and agnostics in the United States has asked the hotel and motel industry to offer Bible-free rooms and has accused Gideons International of exploitation.

New Mexico city of Belen defies atheists\' call to remove nativity scene as it holds its biggest Christmas event ever
New Mexico city of Belen defies atheists' call to remove nativity scene as it holds its biggest Christmas event ever

A letter sent by an atheist group to Belen, New Mexico to remove a nativity scene from a city-owned park has fired up residents that led to the city's biggest Christmas event ever.

School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars \'live\' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana
School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars 'live' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana

A school in Indiana was able to present its annual nativity scene at a school concert despite a court ruling that barred a "live nativity," infuriating atheists who sought to prevent it.

Pennsylvania school district spends $64,000 to fight atheists over Ten Commandments monument
Pennsylvania school district spends $64,000 to fight atheists over Ten Commandments monument

A school district in Pennsylvania paid a law firm $64,000 to fight off a lawsuit by an atheist group, which targeted the removal of a Ten Commandments monument in school property.

Christians score legal victory in Texas as Supreme Court supports display of Bible verses on cheerleaders\' banners
Christians score legal victory in Texas as Supreme Court supports display of Bible verses on cheerleaders' banners

In a unanimous decision, the Texas Supreme Court has ruled in favour of the Kountze Independent School District student cheerleaders' petition to review a case involving their right to display Bible verses on sports banners during football games.

Kansas post office removes \'God Bless America\' banner from building, angering residents
Kansas post office removes 'God Bless America' banner from building, angering residents

A post office in Pittsburg, Kansas removed last Wednesday a "God bless America" banner hanging from its building after an atheist group filed a complaint that it violated the Establishment Clause, angering residents and sparking the distribution of similar banners in the community.

North Carolina sheriff\'s department puts \'In God We Trust\' decals — paid for by church — on patrol cars
North Carolina sheriff's department puts 'In God We Trust' decals — paid for by church — on patrol cars

The sheriff's department in Rutherford County, North Carolina has started sticking "In God We Trust" decals on its 50 patrol cars.

California judge sides with atheists in stopping public school district from reciting prayer at meetings
California judge sides with atheists in stopping public school district from reciting prayer at meetings

A judge in California has barred a public school district from allowing prayers at its board meetings and ordered it to cover the court costs and plaintiff fees.

News
Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach
Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach

Shine Your Light is aiming to mobilise half a million Christians to share the gospel with five million people across the UK this Christmas, with more than 2,000 churches already signed up, organisers say.

The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'
The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'

The Church of England's uneasiness about the government's ‘conversion practices’ bill is a perfect lesson in the old adage, 'be careful what you wish for,' writes Dr Martin Davie.

Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns
Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns

An internal Home Office report lists concerns about immigration, multiculturalism and changing social values among the characteristics associated with what it calls "Christian extremism", it has been reported.

Tearfund calls for COP31 funding to reach farmers struggling with climate change and food insecurity
Tearfund calls for COP31 funding to reach farmers struggling with climate change and food insecurity

Tearfund warns that worsening climate conditions are threatening food production and pushing more people towards hunger.