California judge sides with atheists in stopping public school district from reciting prayer at meetings

Brad Dacus, president of the Pacific Justice Institute, says, 'In a free society we can't have freedom from religion but freedom of religion, and that's what this lawsuit's all about.' (Pacific Justice Institute)

A judge in California has barred a public school district from allowing prayers at its board meetings and ordered it to cover the court costs and plaintiff fees.

U.S. District Judge Jesus Bernal issued the decision on Feb. 18 against the Chino Valley Unified School District.

In November 2014, the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) filed the lawsuit against the school board's prayers.

In his decision, Bernal said, "The court finds ... permitting religious prayer in board meetings, and the policy and custom of reciting prayers, Bible readings, and proselytizing at board meetings, constitute unconstitutional government endorsements of religion in violation of plaintiffs' First Amendment rights."

The FFRF is known for its vehement opposition to public displays of Christianity such as a Ten Commandments monument, prayers by a football coach at games and cross decals on police patrol cars, according to the Christian News Network.

The FFRF accused the Chino school board of violating the First Amendment.

"The Chino Valley School Board begins each meeting with a prayer. Indeed the meetings resemble a church service more than a school board meeting, complete with Bible readings by the board members, Bible quotations by board members, and other statements by board members promoting the Christian religion," FFRF's lawsuit reads.

It said the school board prayers violated the U.S. and California Constitution, telling the board of education that the prayers are "unnecessary, inappropriate, and divisive."

Brad Dacus, president of the Pacific Justice Institute (PJI), which defended the prayers in court, said "some of the board members are very committed to their faith."

"In a free society we can't have freedom from religion but freedom of religion, and that's what this lawsuit's all about," Dacus told One News Now.

In the ruling, Bernal added, "[M]embers of the Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education ... are hereby enjoined from conducting, permitting or otherwise endorsing school-sponsored prayer in board meetings."

related articles
Yielding to atheists, Alabama city removes Christian flag, citing high cost of litigation
Yielding to atheists, Alabama city removes Christian flag, citing high cost of litigation

Yielding to atheists, Alabama city removes Christian flag, citing high cost of litigation

Judge dismisses atheist\'s lawsuit seeking  to remove Ten Commandments monument
Judge dismisses atheist's lawsuit seeking to remove Ten Commandments monument

Judge dismisses atheist's lawsuit seeking to remove Ten Commandments monument

Tennessee sheriff rejects atheists\' request to  remove \'In God We Trust\' decals from cars
Tennessee sheriff rejects atheists' request to remove 'In God We Trust' decals from cars

Tennessee sheriff rejects atheists' request to remove 'In God We Trust' decals from cars

Texas police chief tells atheists who dislike \'In God We Trust\' car decals: \'Go fly a kite\'
Texas police chief tells atheists who dislike 'In God We Trust' car decals: 'Go fly a kite'

Texas police chief tells atheists who dislike 'In God We Trust' car decals: 'Go fly a kite'

Oklahoma, Arkansas come out strongly in defence of students\' right to pray in school
Oklahoma, Arkansas come out strongly in defence of students' right to pray in school

Oklahoma, Arkansas come out strongly in defence of students' right to pray in school

Florida university agrees to post secular quotes in compromise with atheist group
Florida university agrees to post secular quotes in compromise with atheist group

Florida university agrees to post secular quotes in compromise with atheist group

Lawsuit seeks to remove Nativity Scene from Indiana school Christmas show
Lawsuit seeks to remove Nativity Scene from Indiana school Christmas show

Lawsuit seeks to remove Nativity Scene from Indiana school Christmas show

New Mexico city of Belen defies atheists\' call to remove nativity scene as it holds its biggest Christmas event ever
New Mexico city of Belen defies atheists' call to remove nativity scene as it holds its biggest Christmas event ever

New Mexico city of Belen defies atheists' call to remove nativity scene as it holds its biggest Christmas event ever

School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars \'live\' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana
School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars 'live' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana

School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars 'live' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana

Pennsylvania school district spends $64,000 to fight atheists over Ten Commandments monument
Pennsylvania school district spends $64,000 to fight atheists over Ten Commandments monument

Pennsylvania school district spends $64,000 to fight atheists over Ten Commandments monument

Christians score legal victory in Texas as Supreme Court supports display of Bible verses on cheerleaders\' banners
Christians score legal victory in Texas as Supreme Court supports display of Bible verses on cheerleaders' banners

Christians score legal victory in Texas as Supreme Court supports display of Bible verses on cheerleaders' banners

Kansas post office removes \'God Bless America\' banner from building, angering residents
Kansas post office removes 'God Bless America' banner from building, angering residents

Kansas post office removes 'God Bless America' banner from building, angering residents

North Carolina sheriff\'s department puts \'In God We Trust\' decals — paid for by church — on patrol cars
North Carolina sheriff's department puts 'In God We Trust' decals — paid for by church — on patrol cars

North Carolina sheriff's department puts 'In God We Trust' decals — paid for by church — on patrol cars

News
Christian teacher who said being LGBT was a sin loses High Court challenge
Christian teacher who said being LGBT was a sin loses High Court challenge

The High Court has upheld the dismissal of a Christian teacher who told pupils at the London school where she worked that being LGBT was a sin. 

Christian nurse launches legal action after investigation for calling convicted transgender paedophile ‘Mr’ 
Christian nurse launches legal action after investigation for calling convicted transgender paedophile ‘Mr’ 

A Christian senior nurse was investigated and deemed “a potential risk” after she referred to a convicted transgender child sex offender as ‘Mr’. 

AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?
AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?

The relationship between faith and storytelling has always been central to Christianity. From the parables of Jesus to grand cinematic adaptations of biblical narratives, each generation has found new ways to bring Scripture to life. 

Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE
Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE

An independent review into the national curriculum for schools has highlighted the urgent need for standardised religious education (RE) across the country and greater subject specialism to ensure “mastery in the subject”.