Assisted suicide 'cannot be made safe' - Labour peer

Labour peer Lord Hunt has warned of the risk to vulnerable people from "unscrupulous relatives" if assisted suicide is legalised.

Proposals are being considered in Westminster and Scotland, with Baroness Meacher's Bill returning to the Lords for a second reading this month.

Writing in The Telegraph, Lord Hunt warned that assisted suicide "will always be open to bullying and exploitation".

"The process cannot be made safe because the ill will be exposed to fears of being a burden or to pressure from unscrupulous relatives," he said.

Lord Hunt, a former Labour spokesperson for health and social care, said he could understand why some people supported assisted suicide after witnessing the "difficult" demise of his mother following a stroke.  

While the experience forced him to reflect on his beliefs around assisted suicide, he says it has not persuaded him to support the Meacher Bill. 

"Over those many hours I realised that while I could certainly sympathise with the compassionate instincts of those who support assisted dying, it remains my sincere belief that we owe those same loved ones a further protection from feeling pressured into ending their lives because of a fear that they might be a burden and from those who might seek to gain from the accelerated death of a relative," he said. 

Lord Hunt cited Oregon, in the US, as evidence of the "heavy weight of familial pressures" that can come into play after research by the state found that over half of all patients who opted for assisted suicide said they had done so for fear of being a burden. 

But he warned of the additional risk of financial abuse by family members. 

"Copious evidence of elder abuse related to assisted dying in other jurisdictions leads to only one conclusion: any assisted dying law would be fundamentally unsafe for the elderly in our society," he said.

"Particularly vulnerable to familial pressures, elderly members of our communities would be left exposed to the very real danger of their premature death to serve the financial self-interest of others." 

He added, "I will be urging peers to reject a Bill that, however kindly meant, would expose vulnerable patients to either experiencing pressure from relatives to die before their time or to feeling that they are a burden and consequently requesting an assisted death."

News
What do we know about Simon of Cyrene?
What do we know about Simon of Cyrene?

Easter may have passed, but some figures in the story stay with us long after the day itself. One of those is Simon of Cyrene - a man who appears for only a moment, says nothing, and then disappears. And yet, his story carries lessons we can hold onto all year round.

There may not be a Christian revival, but Britain’s traditional churches aren’t doomed
There may not be a Christian revival, but Britain’s traditional churches aren’t doomed

There are good reasons to doubt that Britain is experiencing a Christian revival today – but that does not mean it is dying out.

Pastor preaches in Bristol city centre despite fears of arrest
Pastor preaches in Bristol city centre despite fears of arrest

A pastor has returned to street preaching in Bristol city centre just over four months after he was arrested for his comments on Islam and transgender ideology. 

The biblical backstory of Iran
The biblical backstory of Iran

Iran is back in the headlines. The word “Iran” does not appear in the Bible, but the names of preceding peoples and empires occupying that land today are written into the biblical narrative. This is the story …