Tamir Rice: Police who killed 12-year-old carrying toy gun acted 'reasonably'

Two outside experts have concluded a Cleveland police officer's fatal shooting of a 12-year-old boy who was carrying a toy gun was a reasonable response to a perceived threat, according to reports released by an Ohio prosecutor's office on Saturday.

The independent conclusions submitted to the Cuyahoga County prosecutor's office come ahead of an expected decision by a grand jury on whether criminal charges are warranted in the November 2014 shooting of Tamir Rice, which was captured on surveillance video.

Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Timothy McGinty said in a statement his office was not reaching any conclusions based on the reports, but an attorney for Rice's family criticized the reports as a "whitewash."

Rice was black while the officer who shot him is white, and the case is one in a series of high-profile deaths of African-Americans at the hands of law enforcement which have raised questions about the use of force by police.

Nearly one year ago, Cleveland police received an emergency call about someone brandishing a gun outside a city recreation center.

Officer Timothy Loehmann shot Rice twice in the abdomen, seconds after his partner who also is white drove their vehicle to within 5 feet (1.5 meters) of the boy. Rice died the next day.

The gun turned out to be an airsoft-type replica pistol that shoots pellets, but had the orange tip removed.

Retired FBI agent Kimberly Crawford, in a review of the shooting, wrote that it was "apparent not only was Officer Loehmann required to make a split-second decision, but also that his response was a reasonable one."

In another report, Colorado prosecutor S. Lamar Sims also concluded that "Officer Loehmann's belief that Rice posed a threat of serious physical harm or death was objectively reasonable, as was his response to that perceived threat."

The reports, which cited federal case law, stood at odds with an opinion from a Cleveland judge who in June found probable cause that Loehmann should face a murder charge. Municipal Court Judge Ronald Adrine's opinion did not compel charges or require the officer's arrest.

McGinty has said the case will go to a grand jury.

"Any presentation to a grand jury — without the prosecutor advocating for Tamir as prosecutors do for crime victims every day — is a charade," Subodh Chandra, an attorney for the Rice family, said in a statement.

related articles
Thousands march in Washington for Congress action on police violence against African-Americans
Thousands march in Washington for Congress action on police violence against African-Americans

Thousands of demonstrators gathered in Washington on Saturday for a march to protest the killings of unarmed black men by law enforcement officers and to urge Congress to do more to protect African-Americans from unjustified police violence.

Walter Scott shooting: the rise and rise of police racism in the US
Walter Scott shooting: the rise and rise of police racism in the US

Last Saturday, an unarmed black man was shot five times by a white police officer in North Charleston, South Carolina, in an incident that is becoming frighteningly familiar.

Baltimore riots: The church must be a \'moral voice\' says pastor as leaders urge peace
Baltimore riots: The church must be a 'moral voice' says pastor as leaders urge peace

Religious leaders have formed a united front as tensions rise in Baltimore following the death of Freddie Gray, a 25-year-old black man who suffered a spinal-injury while in the custody of city police.

Cleveland: Protests erupt after not guilty verdict for white officer who killed black suspects
Cleveland: Protests erupt after not guilty verdict for white officer who killed black suspects

The case is one in a series that have raised questions over police and race relations in the US.

News
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin
Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem meets Vladimir Putin

The pair discussed peace with Ukraine and Christians in the Middle East.

Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations
Archbishop says Church must address struggles of clergy and congregations

Dame Sarah Mullally has said that the Church of England’s funding model needs attention as she acknowledged that "too many clergy are struggling".

Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction
Jonathan Aitken says Russell Brand asked him for prayer after rape conviction

Former Conservative minister and now Anglican prison chaplain, Jonathan Aitken, says the convicted comedian has asked for prayer.

Attacks on Christians in Europe rise by 44%, report finds
Attacks on Christians in Europe rise by 44%, report finds

Recorded attacks on Christians in Europe rose by 44% in 2025, according to a new report that also raises concerns about restrictions on the public expression of Christian faith.