Mother sues doctor over botched abortion that left her unable to have children for life

A human foetus at 10 weeks' old. (Wikimedia Commons)

A mother who underwent abortion in 2013 sued her doctor after a bone fragment of the foetus was left in her body that resulted in her being unable to have children for life.

Jennifer DeBuhr and husband Jason filed the lawsuit before a U.S. District Court of Colorado against abortionist Dr. Warren Hern and his Boulder Abortion Clinic for negligence. They are seeking at least $75,000 in damages for each of the four claims, Christian News Network reports.

In early 2013, Jennifer conceived a baby but an MRI test in November that year revealed that the baby boy in her womb had severe cerebral abnormalities that would reduce the baby's life expectancy to less than a year if he is born.

The couple were told by the doctor that she would have to abort the baby to protect her health.

Jennifer was nearly in her third trimester and could not have an abortion in Nebraska, prompting her to go to the Boulder Abortion Clinic in Colorado, the nearest abortion clinic where she could have the procedure.

She started undergoing abortion on Dec. 3, 2013.

"At this time, Dr. Hern used an ultrasound to find the location of the foetus' heart. Dr. Hern then inserted a syringe containing medication into Jennifer's belly and into the foetus' heart in order to stop the heart," according to the lawsuit.

The following day, laminarias, or rods of dried kelp, were inserted into Jennifer to help dilate the uterine cervix.

Jennifer awoke with stomach cramp and discomfort on Dec. 6 and she began vomiting and the packing and laminaria started to fall out of place.

During the last procedure, the clinic staff was unable to get Jennifer to dilate to more than one to two centimetres but despite this, Dr. Hern proceeded with dilation and evacuation (D&E) procedure of the foetus.

"During the D&E procedure, although numbing cream had been placed along her cervix, Jennifer could feel a lot of pulling from the lower half of her body all the way up to her chest. Jennifer experienced intense pain, and as a result of this pain, at some point during the procedure, she blacked out," the lawsuit read.

Following her release, she began experiencing bleeding in spring of 2014.

Dr. Mark Carlson, a gynaecologist, ordered an ultrasound on Jennifer, which revealed an object of about four centimetres in length that was cutting into her uterine wall that caused her to bleed.

During a surgery, Carlson tried but failed to remove the object and she ordered her to undergo hysterectomy.

"The object was tested and it was determined to be a fragment of bone, the shape of which was consistent with the curved portion of a foetus skull," according to the lawsuit.

As a result of the abortion, the lawsuit says, Jennifer suffered severe and permanent physical and mental injuries including vaginal bleeding, surgery to remove her uterus, and, severe pain, stress, and anxiety.

"As a direct and proximate result of those injuries, Plaintiff Jennifer DeBuhr has suffered damages including permanent injury, disability or impairment to Plaintiff's body; loss of her ability to conceive children; and physical pain and mental suffering endured in the past and reasonably certain to be experienced in the future," it added.

related articles
Abortions in New York decrease 21% since 2008 as more women opt not to undergo procedure
Abortions in New York decrease 21% since 2008 as more women opt not to undergo procedure

Abortions in New York decrease 21% since 2008 as more women opt not to undergo procedure

Cardinal Burke calls Notre Dame award to pro-abortion, pro-same sex marriage U.S. Vice President Biden a \'great scandal\'
Cardinal Burke calls Notre Dame award to pro-abortion, pro-same sex marriage U.S. Vice President Biden a 'great scandal'

Cardinal Burke calls Notre Dame award to pro-abortion, pro-same sex marriage U.S. Vice President Biden a 'great scandal'

Lawmakers move to extend abortion waiting period up to 72 hours in Louisiana
Lawmakers move to extend abortion waiting period up to 72 hours in Louisiana

Lawmakers move to extend abortion waiting period up to 72 hours in Louisiana

Italy criticised over difficulty in obtaining abortions
Italy criticised over difficulty in obtaining abortions

Italy criticised over difficulty in obtaining abortions

CMP\'s David Daleiden files motion to quash indictments, citing leaks, collusion between DA, Planned Parenthood
CMP's David Daleiden files motion to quash indictments, citing leaks, collusion between DA, Planned Parenthood

CMP's David Daleiden files motion to quash indictments, citing leaks, collusion between DA, Planned Parenthood

Bill defining person as human being from moment of fertilisation pushed in Alabama
Bill defining person as human being from moment of fertilisation pushed in Alabama

Bill defining person as human being from moment of fertilisation pushed in Alabama

Catholic university\'s decision to invite Bill Clinton as commencement speaker assailed
Catholic university's decision to invite Bill Clinton as commencement speaker assailed

Catholic university's decision to invite Bill Clinton as commencement speaker assailed

U.S. government admits it doesn\'t need to force religious organisations to provide contraceptives
U.S. government admits it doesn't need to force religious organisations to provide contraceptives

U.S. government admits it doesn't need to force religious organisations to provide contraceptives

Atheists display foetus-shaped cookies at university pro-abortion rally, horrifying students
Atheists display foetus-shaped cookies at university pro-abortion rally, horrifying students

Atheists display foetus-shaped cookies at university pro-abortion rally, horrifying students

U.S. lawmakers show documents proving Planned Parenthood illegally profited from selling baby parts
U.S. lawmakers show documents proving Planned Parenthood illegally profited from selling baby parts

U.S. lawmakers show documents proving Planned Parenthood illegally profited from selling baby parts

Democrats thwart Republican-led effort to defund Planned Parenthood in Iowa
Democrats thwart Republican-led effort to defund Planned Parenthood in Iowa

Democrats thwart Republican-led effort to defund Planned Parenthood in Iowa

Playing God? Picking baby\'s gender violates biblical teachings, ethicist warns
Playing God? Picking baby's gender violates biblical teachings, ethicist warns

Playing God? Picking baby's gender violates biblical teachings, ethicist warns

Woman convicted of fraud for faking cancer to get free abortion in Arizona
Woman convicted of fraud for faking cancer to get free abortion in Arizona

Woman convicted of fraud for faking cancer to get free abortion in Arizona

Northern Ireland: Catholic bishops tell voters to avoid pro-abortion candidates

Northern Ireland: Catholic bishops tell voters to avoid pro-abortion candidates

News
Marriage is the safest relationship, latest figures suggest
Marriage is the safest relationship, latest figures suggest

Of the eight children murdered during lockdown, 7 were killed thanks to the actions of a step parent or new partner.

Abortion rises in Northern Ireland for fifth year running
Abortion rises in Northern Ireland for fifth year running

Abortion was legalised in Northern Ireland in 2019.

Churches helping millions of Brits get by as living costs remain high
Churches helping millions of Brits get by as living costs remain high

Across the country, people are looking to the church for help.

Isaiah 41:10 is YouVersion's Bible verse of the year
Isaiah 41:10 is YouVersion's Bible verse of the year

Isaiah 41:10 had the highest international engagement on YouVersion during 2025, while in the UK it was Jeremiah 29:11 that topped the list.