Judicial review challenges liberalisation of assisted suicide 'by the back door'

Assisted suicide is being liberalised "by the back door," disability campaigners warned as a court considers a relaxation in prosecution policy.

Two High Court judges and the President of the Queen's Bench Division will hear the case today

Two high court judges and the president of the Queen's Bench Division will today consider a judicial review on a change in guidelines for prosecuting cases of assisted suicide. The challenge is being brought by disability campaigners who say the change decreases the likelihood of healthcare professionals being prosecuted for assisting suicide.

"This may appear a subtle change but it is substantive and highly significant," said Nikki Kenward, who is paralysed and is bringing the case with her husband Merv.

"It makes it less likely that doctors and other healthcare workers would be prosecuted if they encourage or facilitate suicide and that places people at risk.

"Disabled people, the elderly, the terminally ill and others who are vulnerable need to be able to trust that doctors are there to protect life, not to assist death.

"This change undermines that. It is liberalisation by the back-door."

Encouraging or assisting suicide is a criminal offence under the Suicide Act 1961 and carries a penalty of up to 14 years' imprisonment. However in October 2014 the director of public prosecutions, Alison Saunders, amended the guidelines without consulting Parliament or the public.

The Kenwards argue the change means "ideologically motivated" doctors who assist suicides are more likely to escape responsibility.

Nikki Kenward was left paralysed by Guillain-Barré Syndrome for five months in 1990, only able to blink her right eye. Today she uses a wheelchair and says the change in wording "leaves vulnerable people at risk from dodgy doctors."

It is the first time a court has considered assisted suicide since Rob Marris MP's assisted suicide bill was firmly rejected by the House of Commons in September and it is unlikely to be the last, according to Andrea Williams.

"Assisted suicide campaigners repeatedly brought high profile cases to court to pressure Parliament to change the law," said Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre which is supporting the Kenwards.

"In September, the House of Commons gave very careful attention to the issue and voted against it by an overwhelming majority.

"Having lost the argument there, assisted suicide campaigners have signalled that they will refocus their attention on the courts," continued Williams.

"This relentless challenge must be resisted. The current law tempers justice with mercy and provides essential safeguards against abuse. We mustn't allow those safeguards to be undermined."

related articles
Assisted suicide: Dependence is part of being human
Assisted suicide: Dependence is part of being human

Assisted suicide: Dependence is part of being human

Assisted dying is \'Pandora\'s box\' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP
Assisted dying is 'Pandora's box' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP

Assisted dying is 'Pandora's box' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP

Five Reasons MPs Must Not Legalise Assisted Suicide
Five Reasons MPs Must Not Legalise Assisted Suicide

Five Reasons MPs Must Not Legalise Assisted Suicide

Assisted dying devalues life, warns Archbishop of Canterbury

Assisted dying devalues life, warns Archbishop of Canterbury

MPs vote overwhelmingly against assisted dying
MPs vote overwhelmingly against assisted dying

MPs vote overwhelmingly against assisted dying

Abortion law devolved to Scotland as MPs pass Scotland Bill

Abortion law devolved to Scotland as MPs pass Scotland Bill

News
Pope seeks prayers for peace in Christmas Day message
Pope seeks prayers for peace in Christmas Day message

The Pope asked people to pray in particular for the "tormented people of Ukraine" in his Christmas Day 'Urbi et Orbi' message. 

Who was St Stephen and why is he remembered on December 26?
Who was St Stephen and why is he remembered on December 26?

The carol says, “Good King Wenceslas last looked out on the Feast of Stephen.” In many countries, December 26, also known as Boxing Day, is better known as St Stephen’s Day. Stephen was the first Christian martyr. This is the story …

King Charles reflects on pilgrimage, reconciliation and hope in Christmas Day address
King Charles reflects on pilgrimage, reconciliation and hope in Christmas Day address

King Charles III used his Christmas Day speech to reflect on the significance of pilgrimage as he appealed to the nation "to cherish the values of compassion and reconciliation". 

2 Timothy 3:16 is Logos' Bible verse of the year, Matthew was the most studied book
2 Timothy 3:16 is Logos' Bible verse of the year, Matthew was the most studied book

One of the most-studied Bible verses of the year is from 2 Timothy in the New Testament, according to an analysis of millions of Bible study sessions that tracked how believers worldwide are engaging with Scripture.