Five Reasons MPs Must Not Legalise Assisted Suicide

When Julius Caesar crossed the Rubicon in 49 BC, it changed the course of history. The future shape of the Roman Empire, and therefore the world, depended on whether Caesar would press on over the river. He did, and the rest, as they say, is history.

Why, then, did the Archbishop of Canterbury use this image to describe a private member's bill which will be debated in the House of Commons this week? The answer is simple – whether you agree with assisted suicide or not (and let's call it what it is, suicide, not the more sanitised word, dying) this is a milestone moment.

If Parliament allows doctors to assist in their patients killing themselves, a line will have been crossed in British society. It's far from a straightforward issue. There are heart-rending stories of suffering that we wouldn't wish on anyone. There are powerful, if anecdotal, arguments in favour of relaxing the law. But here are five reasons MPs must vote against a change, and in doing so turn back from the Rubicon...

1. Doctors don't want it

The people who would be expected to administer a lethal dose of drugs to a patient, if assisted suicide became legal, don't want to do it. The British Medical Association, which is the umbrella body representing doctors in the UK, has repeatedly stated its opposition to any change in the law.

Key argument – BMA: "Such a change would be contrary to the ethics of clinical practice, as the principal purpose of medicine is to improve patients' quality of life, not to foreshorten it."

2. Disabled people don't want it

Some of the most strident opposition to the bill has come from disabled activists and commentators. Baroness Tanni Grey-Thompson is one of the most high-profile opponents of assisted suicide. Large charities such as Scope and smaller activist networks like DPAC are calling for MPs to vote no to a change.

Key argument – DPAC: "We want support to live not die. At a time when essential support is being taken away from us... it is more dangerous than ever to introduce legislation which encourages suicide as a solution to the barriers Disabled people face."

3. Parliament doesn't want it

There have been numerous attempts to liberalise the law already. Lord Falconer has devoted the last few years to attempting to change it, but he has been constantly thwarted by measured arguments. Proponents of assisted suicide are now trying the House of Commons. MPs on all sides have argued against a change in legislation.

Key Argument – Lord Winston: "We see the increasing difficulties in the health service when dealing with cancer care at the moment and the provision of drugs. "There will be pressures on budgets and increasing pressures on patients who will feel under pressure to take a decision [to kill themselves] that is not entirely theirs."

4. Christian leaders don't want it

Some of the strongest and most cogent arguments against a change in the law have come from Christian leaders. The Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby has made a powerful case against liberalising the law, while standing alongside leaders of other faiths including Muslims, Jews and Sikhs.

Key argument – Welby: "How can we be absolutely certain that individuals will not be put under considerable pressure to end their lives?... How can we be absolutely sure that a 'right to die' will not eventually become a 'duty to die'?"

5. We've been warned where it ends up

We're not making this decision in a vacuum. Several US states have legalised euthanasia and European countries have been having the same debate. Belgium is the furthest down the road. You can read various reports of where that has ended up (physically healthy 24-year-olds being granted assisted suicide, for example).

Key argument – Catholic Herald: "Bet­ween 2009 and 2013, annual deaths more than doubled from 822 to 1,803. One study even concluded that euthanasia is under-reported by approximately 50 per cent and that 1,000 patients a year have their lives ended without an explicit request."

50% OFF
All-Weather HDPE Plastic Adirondack Chair with Cup Holder – Navy Blue
$70 $139.99
50% OFF
7-Color LED Red Light Therapy Mask for Face and Anti-Aging
$29.99 $59.99
49% OFF
Cordless Vacuum Cleaner - 480W/45Kpa Powerful Stick Vacuum with LED Smart Touch Screen
$55.99 $109.99
20% OFF
Hypoallergenic Pet Wipes for Dogs & Cats - 400 Count Extra Large Coconut Scented Grooming Wipes
$24.79 $30.99
49% OFF
MANSPOT Electric Pubic Hair Trimmer - Waterproof Body and Groin Shaver for Men and Women (Black)
$20.39 $40
25% OFF
Lick-Safe Dog Paw and Nose Balm Stick - All-Natural Moisturizer with Coconut Oil for Dry, Cracked Pads and Snout
$11.69 $15.59
77% OFF
Men's Quick Dry Moisture Wicking Polo Shirt - High Elasticity Slim Fit Athletic Top (Runs Small)
$6.99 $29.99
46% OFF
Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Multi-Sport
$12.95 $23.99
50% OFF
NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater
$18.5 $36.99
48% OFF
G Gradual Men's 7-inch Workout Running Shorts - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Comfort
$12.91 $24.99
30% OFF
NOVETE Under Sink Water Filter - 3 Years, 30,000 Gallons, High-Efficiency Filtration
$41.99 $59.99
50% OFF
HDPE All-Weather Adirondack Chair with Built-In Cup Holder - Tool-Free Assembly (Grey)
$69.99 $139.99
60% OFF
HOMETUK Clear Plastic Storage Bins with Dividers - 3-Pack Stackable Acrylic Organizer Containers for Fridge and Pantry
$19.99 $49.99
58% OFF
G Gradual Men's Fishing Shirt - UPF 50+ Lightweight Short Sleeve Button Down with Zipper Pockets
$14.99 $35.99
55% OFF
Everyfun 60" Rectangular Platform Tree Swing - 700lbs Heavy Duty Adjustable Outdoor Swing (Colorful)
$49.99 $110.99
61% OFF
Ekouaer Women's Casual Loose Jumpsuit - One-Piece Printed Sleeveless Wide Leg Romper with Pockets
$14.99 $37.99
36% OFF
Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry
$12.74 $19.99
61% OFF
Modern Ceiling Fan with Light and Remote - Reversible Quiet DC Motor
$69.3 $179.99
50% OFF
MOOKA H13 True HEPA Air Purifier for Home Large Room - 1076 sq ft Odor Eliminator
$39.97 $79.95
40% OFF
X-Sense XS01-WX Smart Smoke Alarm - 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi Photoelectric Fire Detector with Mobile App Alerts
$65.99 $109.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
related articles
Lord Carey: Assisted dying would be \'profoundly Christian and moral\'
Lord Carey: Assisted dying would be 'profoundly Christian and moral'

Lord Carey: Assisted dying would be 'profoundly Christian and moral'

Assisted Suicide: Jesus came to restore and heal – he expects us to do the same
Assisted Suicide: Jesus came to restore and heal – he expects us to do the same

Assisted Suicide: Jesus came to restore and heal – he expects us to do the same

Justin Welby: Legalising assisted dying would dehumanise society forever
Justin Welby: Legalising assisted dying would dehumanise society forever

Justin Welby: Legalising assisted dying would dehumanise society forever

Fiona Bruce: Assisted dying Bill is \'a dangerous counsel of despair\'
Fiona Bruce: Assisted dying Bill is 'a dangerous counsel of despair'

Fiona Bruce: Assisted dying Bill is 'a dangerous counsel of despair'

Assisted dying is \'Pandora\'s box\' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP
Assisted dying is 'Pandora's box' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP

Assisted dying is 'Pandora's box' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP

News
Church of England apologises for 'pain and trauma' from its role in historical adoption practices
Church of England apologises for 'pain and trauma' from its role in historical adoption practices

The Church of England has apologised for its role in adoption practices involving unmarried women and girls during the post-War period, with the Archbishop of Canterbury acknowledging the "pain, trauma and stigma experienced - and still carried - by many people". 

Catholic Church opposes reintroduction of assisted suicide bill
Catholic Church opposes reintroduction of assisted suicide bill

Labour MP Lauren Edwards has reintroduced the bill and has suggested the Parliament Act could be used to force the measure through.

Festival celebrates Anglesey pilgrimage route
Festival celebrates Anglesey pilgrimage route

The pilgrimage route pays homage to two sixth century saints who lived and worshipped on the island of Anglesey.

Christians urged not to 'demonise' each other over politics
Christians urged not to 'demonise' each other over politics

“As His followers, our calling is not merely to defend positions, win arguments, or secure victories in cultural debates. Our calling is to follow Him," said prayer movement leader Jonathan Oloyede.

Today's Top Deals

All-Weather HDPE Plastic Adirondack Chair with Cup Holder – Navy Blue

$70
$139.99 50% OFF
View Deal

7-Color LED Red Light Therapy Mask for Face and Anti-Aging

$29.99
$59.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Cordless Vacuum Cleaner - 480W/45Kpa Powerful Stick Vacuum with LED Smart Touch Screen

$55.99
$109.99 49% OFF
View Deal

Hypoallergenic Pet Wipes for Dogs & Cats - 400 Count Extra Large Coconut Scented Grooming Wipes

$24.79
$30.99 20% OFF
View Deal

MANSPOT Electric Pubic Hair Trimmer - Waterproof Body and Groin Shaver for Men and Women (Black)

$20.39
$40 49% OFF
View Deal

Lick-Safe Dog Paw and Nose Balm Stick - All-Natural Moisturizer with Coconut Oil for Dry, Cracked Pads and Snout

$11.69
$15.59 25% OFF
View Deal

Men's Quick Dry Moisture Wicking Polo Shirt - High Elasticity Slim Fit Athletic Top (Runs Small)

$6.99
$29.99 77% OFF
View Deal

Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Multi-Sport

$12.95
$23.99 46% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater

$18.5
$36.99 50% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's 7-inch Workout Running Shorts - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Comfort

$12.91
$24.99 48% OFF
View Deal

NOVETE Under Sink Water Filter - 3 Years, 30,000 Gallons, High-Efficiency Filtration

$41.99
$59.99 30% OFF
View Deal

HDPE All-Weather Adirondack Chair with Built-In Cup Holder - Tool-Free Assembly (Grey)

$69.99
$139.99 50% OFF
View Deal

HOMETUK Clear Plastic Storage Bins with Dividers - 3-Pack Stackable Acrylic Organizer Containers for Fridge and Pantry

$19.99
$49.99 60% OFF
View Deal

G Gradual Men's Fishing Shirt - UPF 50+ Lightweight Short Sleeve Button Down with Zipper Pockets

$14.99
$35.99 58% OFF
View Deal

Everyfun 60" Rectangular Platform Tree Swing - 700lbs Heavy Duty Adjustable Outdoor Swing (Colorful)

$49.99
$110.99 55% OFF
View Deal

Ekouaer Women's Casual Loose Jumpsuit - One-Piece Printed Sleeveless Wide Leg Romper with Pockets

$14.99
$37.99 61% OFF
View Deal

Men's Athletic Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight & Quick Dry

$12.74
$19.99 36% OFF
View Deal

Modern Ceiling Fan with Light and Remote - Reversible Quiet DC Motor

$69.3
$179.99 61% OFF
View Deal

MOOKA H13 True HEPA Air Purifier for Home Large Room - 1076 sq ft Odor Eliminator

$39.97
$79.95 50% OFF
View Deal

X-Sense XS01-WX Smart Smoke Alarm - 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi Photoelectric Fire Detector with Mobile App Alerts

$65.99
$109.99 40% OFF
View Deal