Good disagreement: Christian principle or vacuous buzzword?

"Good disagreement" is a catchphrase doing the rounds at moment.

The Archbishop of Canterbury made it the central focus in his attempt to steer the Church of England through its ongoing debate on gay marriage. The Church's process of "shared conversations", an effort to reconcile opposing views on sexuality, "has at its heart a search for good disagreement", said Welby.

The buzzword has stuck. Andrew Goddard and Andrew Atherstone compiled a book called Good Disagreement in mid-2015. A number of senior Anglicans contributed to the book, which explored the history and structures behind disagreement and reconciliation, another buzzword for Welby's tenure as Archbishop.

Now the motif has extended to politics. Christians in Politics (CiP), a cross-party charity that aims to excite Christians about political engagement, recently launched a "disagree with tea" video. Andy Flannagan, director of both CiP and Christians on the Left, said "better tone" was needed in politics but that only came from better relationships.

"When you put relationships with political enemies first, you will continue to disagree but better language and better discourse will follow. What happens is a sharpening of each other's opinions in a better way," he told Christian Today.

And now the #DisagreeWell tag has entered the debate on the EU referendum. On Thursday night a "Christian EU debate" was held with the event billed as a model for how to "disagree well".

As the debate unfolded it became clear just how subjective a term it is. "Oh grow up!", Ann Widdecombe, for the Brexit side, told the Remainers. But Sal Brinton, Lib Dem peer and EU supporter, was not to be outdone. "The reason Ann [Widdecombe] never lost her seat in the House of Commons is because we don't have a fair voting system," she said.

To what extent this is just lively debate and to what extent it crosses the threshold of good disagreement was unclear.

Giles Fraser, another Brexiteer at the debate, made the point that lively disagreement did not mean it was not good disagreement.

"I hate the idea Christianity is about being nice to each other," he said. "That is the essence of middle-class Britain but not the essence of Christianity. Sometimes the debate ought to reflect certain passion and vigour."

The convenor of the debate, Adrian Hilton, agreed the undeniably lively debate had been "iron sharpening iron". He concluded: "There has been more light than heat than at any point so far in this debate."

And he was right. No one could deny the intensity and passion on both sides of the debate. "To tell our European neighbours we think we're better off without them would be against our national principle," said Stephen Wall for the Remain side. Fraser retorted: "I would rather eat grass for a year in order to leave the EU."

For some last night's debate would have crossed the threshold of "good disagreement". But that would be a misunderstanding of the phrase. Good disagreement does not mean no disagreement and neither does it mean passive disagreement. Good disagreement can be feisty and it can be passionate. The difference with good disagreement is that both sides don't resort to personal attacks. They recognise the other side has a legitimate case and argue against that.

However lively last night's debate was, it never descended to the dark side of vitriolic abuse and straw man assumptions seen in the mainstream political debate. More light than heat indeed. The disagreement was intense. But it was also good. The Church of England could take note.

29% OFF
Pleco SK01 Solar Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer with App Control (Obsidian & Ivory)
$284.99 $399.99
52% OFF
Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaner C1 with Wall Climbing and App Control (Glossy Black)
$290.69 $599.99
52% OFF
NEWFAST Outdoor WiFi Extender with MU-MIMO and 3 Gigabit Ports (IP66)
$47.99 $99.99
51% OFF
NEWFAST AXE5400 Tri-Band USB WiFi 6E Adapter with 4 Antennas (NF-U357)
$44.45 $89.99
20% OFF
COZEWARE Visio Series 12000 BTU 20 SEER2 Smart Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (230V, 1 Ton)
$431.99 $539.99
20% OFF
COZEWARE Visio Series 9000 BTU 18 SEER2 Ductless Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (115V)
$439.99 $549.99
20% OFF
COZEWARE Visio Series 24000 BTU 20 SEER2 Smart Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (230V, 2 Ton)
$959.99 $1199.99
20% OFF
COZEWARE Visio Series 18000 BTU 20 SEER2 Smart Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (230V, 1.5 Ton)
$607.99 $759.99
20% OFF
COZEWARE E-Save Series 12000 BTU 20 SEER2 Mini Split Air Conditioner (115V)
$592 $740
20% OFF
SmartHome Wi-Fi Water Leak Detector - Safeguard Your Home
$39.98 $49.99
The $400 Mouse I Thought Was Ridiculously Expensive—Until It Changed How I Work
$0 $0
50% OFF
All-Weather HDPE Plastic Adirondack Chair with Cup Holder – Navy Blue
$70 $139.99
50% OFF
7-Color LED Red Light Therapy Mask for Face and Anti-Aging
$29.99 $59.99
49% OFF
Cordless Vacuum Cleaner - 480W/45Kpa Powerful Stick Vacuum with LED Smart Touch Screen
$55.99 $109.99
20% OFF
Hypoallergenic Pet Wipes for Dogs & Cats - 400 Count Extra Large Coconut Scented Grooming Wipes
$24.79 $30.99
49% OFF
MANSPOT Electric Pubic Hair Trimmer - Waterproof Body and Groin Shaver for Men and Women (Black)
$20.39 $40
25% OFF
Lick-Safe Dog Paw and Nose Balm Stick - All-Natural Moisturizer with Coconut Oil for Dry, Cracked Pads and Snout
$11.69 $15.59
77% OFF
Men's Quick Dry Moisture Wicking Polo Shirt - High Elasticity Slim Fit Athletic Top (Runs Small)
$6.99 $29.99
46% OFF
Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Multi-Sport
$12.95 $23.99
50% OFF
NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater
$18.5 $36.99
Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
related articles
Why Britain\'s EU referendum is a moment of crisis for Europe
Why Britain's EU referendum is a moment of crisis for Europe

Why Britain's EU referendum is a moment of crisis for Europe

Archbishop of York on EU Referendum: I haven't heard a cogent argument for Brexit

Archbishop of York on EU Referendum: I haven't heard a cogent argument for Brexit

Church of Scotland reaffirms support of EU

Church of Scotland reaffirms support of EU

EU officials hold secret talks to plan for Brexit

EU officials hold secret talks to plan for Brexit

Leave the EU or Remain, the Church of Scotland shouldn\'t be voting on it
Leave the EU or Remain, the Church of Scotland shouldn't be voting on it

Leave the EU or Remain, the Church of Scotland shouldn't be voting on it

#DisagreeWell: Christian EU debate attempts to shift poisonous rhetoric
#DisagreeWell: Christian EU debate attempts to shift poisonous rhetoric

#DisagreeWell: Christian EU debate attempts to shift poisonous rhetoric

News
Lichfield Cathedral stone gifted to ancient Essex chapel in symbol of shared faith and heritage
Lichfield Cathedral stone gifted to ancient Essex chapel in symbol of shared faith and heritage

Lichfield and Chelmsford have spiritual links going back over a thousand years.

Methodists 'unable to achieve' goal of Net Zero by 2030
Methodists 'unable to achieve' goal of Net Zero by 2030

A Church report said much progress had been made, but that ultimately the 2030 target is unachievable.

When politics disappoints, where do we turn? 
When politics disappoints, where do we turn? 

The Bible tells us to pray for those in authority. But the Bible never tells us to worship them.

Christian teacher Enoch Burke released from prison after High Court order
Christian teacher Enoch Burke released from prison after High Court order

Irish teacher Enoch Burke has been released from prison on the orders of the High Court in Dublin, ending the latest chapter in a long-running legal dispute that has drawn attention beyond Ireland.

Today's Top Deals

Pleco SK01 Solar Powered Robotic Pool Skimmer with App Control (Obsidian & Ivory)

$284.99
$399.99 29% OFF
View Deal

Cordless Robotic Pool Cleaner C1 with Wall Climbing and App Control (Glossy Black)

$290.69
$599.99 52% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST Outdoor WiFi Extender with MU-MIMO and 3 Gigabit Ports (IP66)

$47.99
$99.99 52% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST AXE5400 Tri-Band USB WiFi 6E Adapter with 4 Antennas (NF-U357)

$44.45
$89.99 51% OFF
View Deal

COZEWARE Visio Series 12000 BTU 20 SEER2 Smart Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (230V, 1 Ton)

$431.99
$539.99 20% OFF
View Deal

COZEWARE Visio Series 9000 BTU 18 SEER2 Ductless Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (115V)

$439.99
$549.99 20% OFF
View Deal

COZEWARE Visio Series 24000 BTU 20 SEER2 Smart Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (230V, 2 Ton)

$959.99
$1199.99 20% OFF
View Deal

COZEWARE Visio Series 18000 BTU 20 SEER2 Smart Mini Split AC with Heat Pump (230V, 1.5 Ton)

$607.99
$759.99 20% OFF
View Deal

COZEWARE E-Save Series 12000 BTU 20 SEER2 Mini Split Air Conditioner (115V)

$592
$740 20% OFF
View Deal

SmartHome Wi-Fi Water Leak Detector - Safeguard Your Home

$39.98
$49.99 20% OFF
View Deal

The $400 Mouse I Thought Was Ridiculously Expensive—Until It Changed How I Work

$0
$0 0% OFF
View Deal

All-Weather HDPE Plastic Adirondack Chair with Cup Holder – Navy Blue

$70
$139.99 50% OFF
View Deal

7-Color LED Red Light Therapy Mask for Face and Anti-Aging

$29.99
$59.99 50% OFF
View Deal

Cordless Vacuum Cleaner - 480W/45Kpa Powerful Stick Vacuum with LED Smart Touch Screen

$55.99
$109.99 49% OFF
View Deal

Hypoallergenic Pet Wipes for Dogs & Cats - 400 Count Extra Large Coconut Scented Grooming Wipes

$24.79
$30.99 20% OFF
View Deal

MANSPOT Electric Pubic Hair Trimmer - Waterproof Body and Groin Shaver for Men and Women (Black)

$20.39
$40 49% OFF
View Deal

Lick-Safe Dog Paw and Nose Balm Stick - All-Natural Moisturizer with Coconut Oil for Dry, Cracked Pads and Snout

$11.69
$15.59 25% OFF
View Deal

Men's Quick Dry Moisture Wicking Polo Shirt - High Elasticity Slim Fit Athletic Top (Runs Small)

$6.99
$29.99 77% OFF
View Deal

Men's Running Shorts with Zipper Pockets - Lightweight, Quick-Dry, Multi-Sport

$12.95
$23.99 46% OFF
View Deal

NEWFAST NF-RE523 AC1200 WiFi Extender - 1200Mbps Dual Band Signal Booster & Internet Repeater

$18.5
$36.99 50% OFF
View Deal