'Gay cake' case: Ashers should not have been found guilty, says Attorney General

The Christian bakery at the heart of the gay-cake case should not have been found guilty of discrimination, Northern Ireland's Attorney General has told the court.

Ashers Baking Company refused to bake a cake with the slogan "Support Gay Marriage" for Gareth Lee, who is an LGBT activist. The Christian-owned bakery was found guilty of discrimination against Lee by a county court in 2014.

The company has appealed the ruling and a case is ongoing at the region's Court of Appeal.

The case was scheduled to be heard earlier this year but was postponed after a last minute intervention by John Larkin, Northern Ireland's Attorney General.

Larkin was granted permission to take part after he raised concerns that Northern Ireland's equalities legislation could discriminate against those who hold a religious belief. He told the court this case was far wider than the cake in question. "This case is about expression," he said.

He added that if Lee had "been refused some of Ashers excellent chocolate eclairs because he was gay or perceived to be gay then I would be standing on the other side of court".

He added: "But it's not about that, it's about expression and whether it's lawful under Northern Ireland constitutional law for Ashers to be forced...to articulate or express or say a political message which is at variance with their political views and in particular their religious views."

He said Lee's sexual orientation was of "supreme irrelevance" to the bakery.

However a barrister for Lee said the McArthur family, who own Ashers, were not forced to do anything against their beliefs.

"It is no more forced speech than any of the delivery merchants or the post office or any of the companies that printed the numerous hoardings around Belfast and the rest of Northern Ireland for the Assembly elections this week."

One of the three judges presiding over the case asked if the phrase "Support Gay Marriage" could be argued to be blasphemous.

Lee's barrister said it was not blasphemous because the campaign for gay marriage was a civil recognition.

"It's not abusive of religion to say 'support gay marriage'," he added.

"Just because you ice a cake with 'Larne Ladies Football Club' doesn't mean you support them, even if all your staff were arch rivals of Larne Ladies Football Club," he said.

The hearing continues.

related articles
Ashers\' Bakery: The real loser here is a tolerant society
Ashers' Bakery: The real loser here is a tolerant society

The Ashers 'gay cake' judgment is troubling because of what it reveals about the conflict between rights.

The Christian bakers \'gay cake\' case has cost £100,000 so far
The Christian bakers 'gay cake' case has cost £100,000 so far

The Ashers "gay cake" case has so far cost more than £100,000 in litigation costs, it has been disclosed. This compares to an original cost of £36.50 for the cake itself.

'Gay cake' case returns to court: 'We pray for a just outcome'

The Christian family caught up in 'gay-cake' case will return to court for their appeal on Monday and have said they are praying for justice.

WATCH: Full interview with McArthur family ahead of gay cake case
WATCH: Full interview with McArthur family ahead of gay cake case

Daniel and Amy McArthur have spoken about the ordeal of a court trial as their appeal will return to Belfast High Court on Monday.

News
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda

A judge in Uganda has sentenced five Muslims to death for killing two Christian evangelists in 2024.

Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests
Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests

Authorities in Indonesia recently allowed construction to proceed on worship buildings of two churches in different provinces despite vigorous protests from Muslim groups.

Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations
Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations

Scholar Dan McClellan alleged that Wes Huff plagiarized a 2016 Tyndale Seminary paper.

Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth
Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth

Adult baptisms in the Church of England have increased by a third in a year, with almost 10,000 adults being baptised in 2025, according to newly published figures.