Christians threaten MSPs with legal action over conversion therapy ban

 (Photo: Getty/iStock)

The Christian Institute (CI) is ready to take legal action against the Scottish Parliament if it moves ahead with a proposed ban on so-called conversion therapy.

The organisation called the legislation "ill-thought-out" and said that adequate scrutiny by MSPs was unlikely due to "bias". 

In a letter to Holyrood's Presiding Officer Alison Johnstone, the CI expressed concern that members of the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee (EHRCJ) "are too close" to the End Conversion Therapy Scotland (ECTS) campaign group. 

The committee is currently considering an ECTS petition calling for a ban on conversion therapy. Seven of the 10 committee members pledged to back ECTS' campaign. 

CI Deputy Director Simon Calvert, warned of the implications in his letter to Johnstone. 

"How can the Committee be expected to exercise impartial, critical judgement when most of its members have given assurances directly to the campaign group whose claims they are scrutinising and have promised to enact the very policies being sought?" he said. 

The letter goes on to state that only one evidence session heard the concerns of Christian and other groups, while the other seven heard from advocates who support a ban. 

"We are concerned that the majority of MSPs on the Committee are too close to the ECTS campaign for the public to have confidence in the outcome of their deliberations in this sensitive area of policy-making," the letter reads.

The CI was behind a successful legal challenge against the Scottish government's Named Person legislation. The controversial plan sought to have an appointed person monitor the wellbeing of every child in Scotland but was scrapped in 2019 after the Supreme Court said it breached Human Rights laws. 

Mr Calvert said the CI was ready to go to court again to challenge a conversion therapy ban. 

"The Christian Institute was involved in the successful legal challenge to the Named Person legislation where Parliament failed to properly scrutinise proposals," he said.

"Inadequate scrutiny by Parliament in this case may again result in human rights challenges being brought against any resulting legislation."

The Scottish government wants to ban practices that seek to change someone's sexual orientation or gender identity, but the CI and other Christian groups have expressed concern that a broadly worded ban will infringe on the preaching and practice of churches. 

Mr Calvert added, "Ill-thought-out conversion therapy bans in other countries are being strongly resisted by churches, not because they wish to practise 'conversion therapy', but because the bans go much further and outlaw innocent, everyday church activities including people praying for their friends.

"It is very regrettable that concerns such as these seem to have fallen on deaf ears with the EHRCJ. The public expects impartial scrutiny. Instead, Committee members have made promises to campaign groups and taken evidence disproportionately from those supporting the petition."

News
The first Christmas song to be sung in churches
The first Christmas song to be sung in churches

Every Christmas, people sing the song “While Shepherds Watched Their Flocks by Night”. Unlike many other songs and carols that include elements of non-biblical tradition and myth, this song is pure Scripture. It was the first Christmas song authorised to be sung in the Church of England. This is the story …

The story of the Christmas Truce of 1914
The story of the Christmas Truce of 1914

On Christmas Eve in 1914, many men were in the trenches fighting the war, but the spirit of Christmas halted the conflict for a brief period. This is the story …

Report highlights injustices experienced by Christians in the Holy Land
Report highlights injustices experienced by Christians in the Holy Land

Jerusalem Church leaders have released a report detailing the struggles and challenges currently faced be Christians living in the Holy Land.

Have you lost the wonder of Christmas?
Have you lost the wonder of Christmas?

For you who have been followers of Jesus Christ for a long time, maybe the pain and suffering of this world and the darkness you have had to live through this past year has gotten you down to the point of complete and utter discouragement. But all is not lost.