War-time Pope secretly plotted to kill Hitler

The wartime leader of the Roman Catholic Church who has been described as "Hitler's Pope" was in fact a secret opponent of the Nazis and secretly plotted to kill Hitler, a new book claims.

Mark Riebling in Church of Spies says Pope Pius XII ran a secret war against the Nazi regime and did not speak out against the crimes against Jews and others because he feared this would hamper his efforts to undermine national socialism.

"When he learned of the Holocaust, Pius played his cards close to his chest. He sent birthday cards to Hitler while secretly plotting to kill him," the book claims.

Riebling's book counters the charges against Pius XII made by author John Cornwell in Hitler's Pope. Cornwell argued that Pius did not do enough to fight Hitler and instead furthered his own agenda of increasing the power of the Papacy. Cornwell also said Pius was anti-Semitic.

Riebling, a historian, instead says that Pius XII worked with the German resistance and others to plot Hitler's death. The plot failed for several reasons, he reports, but it was in the hopes that it might succeed that Pius XII did not criticise Hitler and the Nazi regime more openly, even though he had been a vocal critic of National Socialism before the war.

Hitler bore a hatred for the Catholic Church, warning against "assassins whipped up by the black crows in confessionals."

Pope Pius used a Catholic source, Josef Müller, to dig out information on Hitler's movements and carry messages back and forth. The book says  Müller was able to provide information on Hitler and also help German bishops communicate secretly with the Vatican. Müller's code name in the ingtrigue was Herr X and Pius XII was The Chief.

David Brown reports on MentalFloss that the Pope ordered the death of Hitler in 1939 and the generals were prepared to go through with the plan but the problem was a lack of assurances. 

He writes: "It was the Vatican's agents and allies who were so successful in everything from finding and leaking Hitler's plans for German invasion of Belgium, to helping orchestrate multiple attempts on the tyrant's life. And, as Church of Spies explains in extraordinary and well-documented detail, it all happened because Pope Pius XII had no qualms with killing the evilest man in the world." 

related articles
Dietrich Bonhoeffer 70 years on: 10 quotes you need to read
Dietrich Bonhoeffer 70 years on: 10 quotes you need to read

70 years ago today, Dietrich Bonhoeffer was murdered by the Nazis aged 39. Krish Kandiah reflects on his wisdom.

Republican candidate Ben Carson says guns could have mitigated Holocaust

Republican presidental candidate Ben Carson has claimed that arming German citizens with guns could have helped prevent the Holocaust.

Netanyahu\'s Holocaust claims: Why they don\'t stand up
Netanyahu's Holocaust claims: Why they don't stand up

Israel's President Benjamin Netanyahu sparked controversy yesterday by a speech in which he blamed the Holocaust on a Palestinian.

Germany rebuffs Israeli PM Netanyahu for blaming Palestinian, not Hitler, for killing of 6 million Jews
Germany rebuffs Israeli PM Netanyahu for blaming Palestinian, not Hitler, for killing of 6 million Jews

Even Germany was shocked when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared on Tuesday that the Holocaust, the mass slaughter of 6 million Jews during World War II, was instigated not by German Führer Adolf Hitler but by a Palestinian religious leader named Haj Amin al-Husseini, the mufti of Jerusalem at that time who was a Nazi sympathiser.

News
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda

A judge in Uganda has sentenced five Muslims to death for killing two Christian evangelists in 2024.

Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests
Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests

Authorities in Indonesia recently allowed construction to proceed on worship buildings of two churches in different provinces despite vigorous protests from Muslim groups.

Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations
Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations

Scholar Dan McClellan alleged that Wes Huff plagiarized a 2016 Tyndale Seminary paper.

Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth
Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth

Adult baptisms in the Church of England have increased by a third in a year, with almost 10,000 adults being baptised in 2025, according to newly published figures.