#UseMeInstead: Clergy protest against use of mugshots for police target practice

A police mugshot used for target practice next to that of a protester. Facebook

The revelation that a Florida police department was using mugshots of real people for target practice has caused widespread outrage and sparked a protest by clergy on social media.

It was discovered last month that North Miami Beach's police department used pictures of black men at its gun range. National Guard sergeant Valerie Deant was shocked to find one of them in a rubbish bin – with her brother's face on it.

The city council has now banned the practice following protests which included the display of poster-sized photos of Police Chief Scott Dennis riddled with bullet holes. Dennis told the Miami Herald that he felt "very, very badly" about the practice.

"I sincerely apologised for what my department has done," he said. "This was a training program that had been going on long before I was here and when I found out about it, I ceased it."

However, the revelations that the mugshots – all of black men – were used at all has played into allegations that police have been careless toward black lives, following the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson and the death of Eric Garner in New York. There have been widespread street protest over the issue.

Then a closed Facebook group for Lutheran clergy shared the idea of sending in their own photos for target practice. The Twitter protest adopted the hasthag 'UseMeInstead' and features a number of ministers in clerical collars.

The Facebook statement said: "Although we acknowledge the need for a police force that is trained in the use of their firearms, we feel that, if pictures of human targets are used for target practice, great care should be taken in not allowing the selection of these targets to allow for the dehumanisation of those most vulnerable to police violence.

"Our faith teaches us that all human life is sacred. And when human life is devalued, Jesus teaches us to put ourselves in the place of those whose humanity is denied, just as he did.

"To the members of the North Miami Beach Police: If you must use pictures of real humans for your target practice, we request that you use ours. We're sending pictures of ourselves, in our clergy uniforms, to use."

While the protests have proved popular, some activists have also drawn criticism because most of those taking part are white, and black clergy have largely chosen not to participate. 

related articles
Thousands march in Washington for Congress action on police violence against African-Americans
Thousands march in Washington for Congress action on police violence against African-Americans

Thousands march in Washington for Congress action on police violence against African-Americans

Protests flare in St Louis after fatal police shooting
Protests flare in St Louis after fatal police shooting

Protests flare in St Louis after fatal police shooting

Police anger at New York mayor remains, sharp fall in arrests
Police anger at New York mayor remains, sharp fall in arrests

Police anger at New York mayor remains, sharp fall in arrests

Ferguson killing: grand juror sues prosecutor over \'skewed\' evidence
Ferguson killing: grand juror sues prosecutor over 'skewed' evidence

Ferguson killing: grand juror sues prosecutor over 'skewed' evidence

TD Jakes: Racial tensions in US are \'a tremendous opportunity for the church to be the light\'
TD Jakes: Racial tensions in US are 'a tremendous opportunity for the church to be the light'

TD Jakes: Racial tensions in US are 'a tremendous opportunity for the church to be the light'

News
Sarah Mullally reiterates apology as safeguarding record comes under the spotlight
Sarah Mullally reiterates apology as safeguarding record comes under the spotlight

The incoming Archbishop of Canterbury, Sarah Mullally, has come under pressure over her handling of past safeguarding cases. 

Evangelical vicar accused of abuse won't stand trial
Evangelical vicar accused of abuse won't stand trial

A leading figure among conservative evangelical Anglicans will not stand trial for alleged abuse, it has emerged.

Church of England bishops delay final decision on same-sex blessings
Church of England bishops delay final decision on same-sex blessings

The Church of England's House of Bishops has postponed a final decision on the Living in Love and Faith process as it continues to work on proposals. 

Faith in the festive chaos: how you can sustain your family’s faith this Christmas
Faith in the festive chaos: how you can sustain your family’s faith this Christmas

Anna Hawken, Parenting for Faith from BRF Ministries, has some helpful tips for families to connect with God in the midst of the "December tornado".