U.S. intelligence chief identifies gene editing as weapon of mass destruction

Nuclear arms and chemical weapons are generally considered as weapons of mass destruction (WMD). The United States' director of national intelligence, James Clapper, however, recently added one item on this category of weapons: gene editing.

In his report entitled "Worldwide Threat Assessment of the U.S. Intelligence Community" submitted to the Senate Armed Services Committee, Clapper said that genetic modification experiments being conducted by other nations, including those adversarial to the U.S., may create new types of biological threats.

"Research in genome editing conducted by countries with different regulatory or ethical standards than those of Western countries probably increases the risk of the creation of potentially harmful biological agents or products," the U.S. intelligence chief said.

"Given the broad distribution, low cost, and accelerated pace of development of this dual-use technology, its deliberate or unintentional misuse might lead to far-reaching economic and national security implications," he added in his report.

Clapper nevertheless said it might take some time before scientists come up with these "harmful biological agents" from gene editing.

"Researchers will probably continue to encounter challenges to achieve the desired outcome of their genome modifications, in part because of the technical limitations that are inherent in available genome editing systems," he said.

Daniel Gerstein, a former undersecretary at the Department of Homeland Defense, agreed with the intelligence chief's decision to consider genome editing as a weapon of mass destruction, admitting that such experiments may have harmful implications.

"Biotechnology, more than any other domain, has great potential for human good, but also has the possibility to be misused," Gerstein, who currently works as a senior policy analyst at RAND, told the MIT's Technology Review.

"We are worried about people developing some sort of pathogen with robust capabilities, but we are also concerned about the chance of misutilisation. We could have an accident occur with gene editing that is catastrophic, since the genome is the very essence of life," he added.

related articles
GM embryos: What do Christians think?

The Church of England is in hot water with conservative evangelicals after it hinted it may support the genetic modification of human embryos. Harry Farley takes a look at the ethical points to consider

Christian leader warns of \'Frankenstein monsters\' due to scientific movement called transhumanism
Christian leader warns of 'Frankenstein monsters' due to scientific movement called transhumanism

A famous Christian leader warned against the potentially disastrous effects of a scientific effort called "transhumanism."

Human DNA more complex than earlier thought, thus confounding evolutionists, U.K. scientists reveal

A team of scientists from the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom recently found out that the DNA, which stores human beings' biological information, and the way it is affected by modifications, is more complex than the scientific community earlier thought.

\'Designer babies\' now possible as U.K. allows scientists to genetically modify human embryos
'Designer babies' now possible as U.K. allows scientists to genetically modify human embryos

The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) in the UK has given its go ahead to a research application from the Francis Crick Institute which plans to use new "gene editing" techniques on human embryos.

News
King Charles honours 400 year old church in Bermuda
King Charles honours 400 year old church in Bermuda

Bermuda was not visited as part of the King's recent Caribbean tour.

Ex-BBC reporter tells of 'cabal' of journalists who influenced trans coverage
Ex-BBC reporter tells of 'cabal' of journalists who influenced trans coverage

Robin Aitken, who spent 25 years at the BBC, said that the idea of impartiality at the BBC is “a complete and utter fiction”.

Belfast City Council votes again to celebrate abortion after failed attempt
Belfast City Council votes again to celebrate abortion after failed attempt

Next Easter will be marked with a celebration of abortion.