Opposition to 'three parent' babies grows

MPs and members of the public have been voicing their concerns about the proposed creation of 'three parent' embryos, which the Government is said to want to push through parliament this autumn.

Earlier this year the Government published proposals to move ahead with 'three parent' embryos, despite the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority stating that more research is required before steps are taken.

Campaigners are concerned that the effects of the procedures on the babies produced are being ignored, as well as the fact that the proposed legislation will be in a format that will have weaker scrutiny than usual.

In a debate this week, Conservative MP Fiona Bruce told the House of Commons that there was scientific evidence of chromosomal abnormalities in embryos produced by this technique, and that the UK Government should not approve it until further research had been carried out. The issue relates to the transfer of DNA into an embryo from a different person's mitochondria, the energy factories of human cells.

"Two peer-reviewed articles in Nature have suggested that mitochondrial transfer is inherently risky, one of them citing a figure of 52 per cent of embryos created through MST having chromosomal abnormalities," she told the House of Commons. "More research ought to be undertaken and a full assessment conducted of the potential risk to children born as a result."

There are fears that the proposals could open the door to further genetic engineering of human beings. "Monday's debate was about safety, but there are other Christian concerns that extend beyond safety, and relate to the ethics of what's being proposed," Christian charity CARE spokesman Dan Boucher told Christian Today. "Britain would be the first country in the world to allow this procedure, which involves the deliberate genetic engineering of a human. Because of this considerable opposition has been expressed not just in this country but also abroad."

Other MPs who spoke against the proposals were Labour MP Robert Flello, Tory David Burrowes and Labour MP Jim Dobbin.

As well as the politicians and Christian groups who are against the draft legislation, it appears that the public are increasingly opposed to the idea too. A ComRes poll commissioned by CARE found that fewer than one in five people support the creation of three parent babies. This was a significant drop compared to a poll earlier in the year.

"There has been a dramatic shift from wafer thin support in February to clear opposition in August, with just 18 per cent now in favour compared to as much as 55 per cent against," said Labour MP Flello, who was a co-sponsor of the debate.

Those who support the practice say it will reduce the number of people born with diseases related to mitochondrial DNA.

"This is an incredibly difficult issue, with emotive arguments being used as to why we must change the law," said Nola Leach, chief executive of CARE. "The problem is that the scientific evidence does not support the change. That is why top geneticists like Professor Stuart Newman, Professor of Cell Biology and Anatomy at New York Medical College has described the genetically modifying children as 'inherently unsafe'.

"Now we see that the public does not support changing the law either and are concerned about the Government's motives behind wanting to change the law. They are worried that patient safety would be compromised for the sake of claiming a world first.

"It is vital the Government gets this right and that means listen to the evidence including the very serious ethical issues before rushing into a decision."

related articles
Embryos: two parents good, three parents bad?
Embryos: two parents good, three parents bad?

Designer children are on the way – at least if we are to believe some of the headlines in the press.

UK Government criticised over three-parent embryo plans
UK Government criticised over three-parent embryo plans

Members of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, which is in plenary session this week in Strasbourg, have adopted a Written Declaration severely criticising the UK Government proposal to allow scientists to genetically engineer human embryos which would have three genetic parents.

European court to rule on status of human embryos
European court to rule on status of human embryos

The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights will decide whether embryos are property or have rights

Three parent embryos unpopular with voters
Three parent embryos unpopular with voters

Voters are lukewarm about the Government's decision to change the law to allow three-parent embryos.

Controversial cloning used to make stem cells for diabetes treatment

American scientists have successfully cloned a human embryo and harvested its stem cells to create insulin producing cells genetically identical to the patient that needs them.

Christian ethicists concerned over \'three parent baby\' IVF plan
Christian ethicists concerned over 'three parent baby' IVF plan

New IVF technique 'mitochondrial replacement therapy' raises questions over genetic modification of embryos.

News
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain

Architectural historian Steven Brindle talks to Christian Today about the faith that shaped 1930s Britain, the churches that supported struggling communities and what lessons the decade might have for us today.

Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach
Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach

Shine Your Light is aiming to mobilise half a million Christians to share the gospel with five million people across the UK this Christmas, with more than 2,000 churches already signed up, organisers say.

The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'
The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'

The Church of England's uneasiness about the government's ‘conversion practices’ bill is a perfect lesson in the old adage, 'be careful what you wish for,' writes Dr Martin Davie.

Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns
Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns

An internal Home Office report lists concerns about immigration, multiculturalism and changing social values among the characteristics associated with what it calls "Christian extremism", it has been reported.