How to tell whether a person is possessed by a demon or is just mentally ill? Veteran exorcist explains

Painting of Saint Francis Borgia performing an exorcism, by Goya. (Wikipedia)

How can you determine whether a person is possessed by an evil spirit or is simply suffering from a mentally illness?

The answer may not be apparent to ordinary people since a possessed person and one who is mentally ill may exhibit similar physical reaction.

However, Father Cipriano de Meo, a long-time exorcist and priest in Rome, said a well-trained exorcist should know the difference.

Speaking to CNA's Italian agency ACI Stampa, De Meo said in many alleged cases of possession, the victims turned out to be just struggling with some form of mental illness.

An exorcist since 1952, De Meo said the key to telling the difference is through discernment in prayer on the part of the exorcist and the possessed and in the potentially possessed person's reaction to the exorcist himself and the prayers being said.

The exorcist will typically say "(a) prolonged prayer to the point where if the Adversary is present, there's a reaction," he said.

"A possessed person has various general attitudes towards an exorcist, who is seen by the Adversary as an enemy ready to fight him," he added.

De Meo said one telling indication that a person is possessed is the latter's response to the exorcist's prayer.

"There's no lack of frightening facial expressions, threatening words or gestures and other things," he said, "but especially blasphemies against God and Our Lady."

The veteran exorcist priest said the best defence against demonic possession is a simple and sacramental life of prayer.

"It's absolutely fundamental to get rid of sin and live in the grace of God," he said.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) offers detailed guidance on how to avoid demonic possession.

It calls on the faithful to avoid "consulting horoscopes, astrology, palm reading, interpretation of omens and lots, the phenomena of clairvoyance, and recourse to mediums," saying they "all conceal a desire for power over time, history, and, in the last analysis, other human beings, as well as a wish to conciliate hidden powers."

"They contradict the honor, respect, and loving fear that we owe to God alone," it says.

De Meo said the exorcists need to remain humble and to remember that their power comes from Christ.

"Regarding spiritual preparation, humility and the conviction that we exorcists aren't the ones who are going to cast out the demon that's fighting Christ. We're called to fight on behalf of Christ," he said.

related articles
Devil worshippers\' gathering in Detroit not a joke; they\'re \'playing with fire\'— priest
Devil worshippers' gathering in Detroit not a joke; they're 'playing with fire'— priest

Devil worshippers' gathering in Detroit not a joke; they're 'playing with fire'— priest

Demon possession cases rise in Philippines; Catholic church seeks more exorcists
Demon possession cases rise in Philippines; Catholic church seeks more exorcists

Demon possession cases rise in Philippines; Catholic church seeks more exorcists

\'Don\'t play games with Satan\': US Catholic archdiocese denounces live exorcism show
'Don't play games with Satan': US Catholic archdiocese denounces live exorcism show

'Don't play games with Satan': US Catholic archdiocese denounces live exorcism show

Young woman \'possessed\' after playing with Ouija board dies at church during exorcism ritual
Young woman 'possessed' after playing with Ouija board dies at church during exorcism ritual

Young woman 'possessed' after playing with Ouija board dies at church during exorcism ritual

Exorcist says Hollywood wrongly depicts Satan, says he\'s \'a being who God created as good but became evil\'
Exorcist says Hollywood wrongly depicts Satan, says he's 'a being who God created as good but became evil'

Exorcist says Hollywood wrongly depicts Satan, says he's 'a being who God created as good but became evil'

TV turns to demons for entertainment as Fox orders reboot of \'The Exorcist\'; pastors warn of dangers
TV turns to demons for entertainment as Fox orders reboot of 'The Exorcist'; pastors warn of dangers

TV turns to demons for entertainment as Fox orders reboot of 'The Exorcist'; pastors warn of dangers

Pray for Peru: More than 80 students believed possessed by evil spirits in school
Pray for Peru: More than 80 students believed possessed by evil spirits in school

Pray for Peru: More than 80 students believed possessed by evil spirits in school

News
Church of England directs £600,000 towards clergy mental health and financial support
Church of England directs £600,000 towards clergy mental health and financial support

The funding package includes new grants for two national charities working with clergy facing psychological strain and financial pressure.

St William shrine fragments return to York Minster after 500 years underground
St William shrine fragments return to York Minster after 500 years underground

Fragments of a long-lost medieval shrine honouring St William of York have returned to York Minster for the first time in nearly 500 years, marking a major moment in the cathedral’s history and a highlight of its programme for 2026.

New research sheds light on why women are more religious than men
New research sheds light on why women are more religious than men

Gender gaps were found to narrow in line with degrees of modernisation, secularisation, and gender equality. But, the paper finds, the "gap does not vanish entirely – even in highly secular countries women remain more religious than men".

Prince and Princess of Wales visit Lambeth Palace to meet new Archbishop of Canterbury
Prince and Princess of Wales visit Lambeth Palace to meet new Archbishop of Canterbury

The Prince and Princess of Wales have paid an official visit to Lambeth Palace.