Honest Mums' Club: Meet the Christian mother speaking out about postnatal depression

After giving birth to her first child, Christian author Hannah Oakland was shocked when the bliss she expected to feel was replaced by an unwelcome "dark cloud of numbness". She describes feeling like she'd failed, and like she was – in her own words – a bad mother. She feared judgment from other mums for struggling with motherhood at a time when it seemed that everything should feel just right.

Like one in seven new mothers, Hannah was suffering from from postnatal depression (PND).

After her second child and a second round of PND, Hannah decided to counter the culture of shame, and speak out about her experiences of motherhood and depression.

As she shared her struggles with God, her husband and other women, she broke free of the isolation she'd felt trapped by. She has now written a book, The Honest Mums' Club, detailing the ups and downs of her journey.

Hannah, mother to five-year-old Evie and three-year-old Joel, spoke to Christian Today about how suffering from PND has challenged and changed her life, her faith and her experience of church.

While the depression has been dark, she has found hope in the experience which has both changed and deepened her relationship with God. "I am really loved by him and held by him for who I am, not what I can do," she said.

Today is World Maternal Mental Health Day, a day specifically aimed at promoting awareness of postnatal depression and other maternal mental health illnesses that remain stigmatised by society.

"There is a real feeling of having failed when you struggle with motherhood," Hannah said.

"I always felt like you're just supposed to know what to do and motherhood is meant to be a glorious and blissful time. I was worried that my friends would judge me and think I was a bad mother."

Depression of any kind can have an isolating effect, she added. It leaves individuals struggling to recognise their own value, and often feeling ashamed.

"The first time I had PND I was almost too embarrassed to talk to anyone about it. The absolute killer with depression is that it makes you feel alone and that you're not good enough for anyone to help."

The cycle is self-perpetuating, Hannah said, as if you don't share your experiences, you won't receive the support you need, which can lead to the depression worsening.

But when she decided to share her illness with her friends, she was amazed by the number of people who had also been silently struggling.

"It just changed everything," she said.

"Suddenly people who I had no idea were suffering thanked me for talking about it and said they felt exactly the same. For a long time I felt so alone, but when I began sharing my experiences I realised there are goodness-knows how many of us. It's incredibly liberating."

The church she was going to was "phenomenal" in their response, she said. They "held our whole family and looked after us – we were so privileged to be part of such a community."

But although her experience was positive, she warned that "there is a general feeling that there is a stigma attached to mental health in the Church more widely. A sense that maybe you're suffering because you haven't prayed hard enough, or the right person hasn't prayed for you. Maybe you're not reading your Bible diligently enough, suggesting that if you were doing things right you wouldn't feel like this.

"It breaks my heart, as the Church should be the safest place to go."

This negative association with mental health affected Hannah's own relationship with God. When she first got PND, after the birth of Evie, she was "almost too embarrassed to approach God. I didn't want to involve him."

After her son was born, however, the experience "made me re-evaluate the way I relate to God", she told Christian Today.

"I had always wanted to show him how good I was – I wanted to move up his list of favourites. But when I literally had nothing to give him, or anyone else, I found out who he really is.

"The second time I have felt really loved by him and held by him for who I am, not what I can do. Simply because I am his and he loves me. The experience has taught me about the power of grace."

Though her experiences have been incredibly painful, Hannah is adament that there is hope in the darkness. The journey with PND "will be the thing that changed me and made me who I am," she said. 

"For me, before the depression I was very concernced to come across well, to develop a facade of someone who has it together. The depression ripped that from underneath me. It forced me to be more honest and more real, to accept my limitations and learn to accept help from other people."

PND still isn't talked about enough, she says, and is determined to see that change. She has written a blog since Joel was nine months old, has set up a support group for women going through the same thing and has now launched her book.

"I dream for the day when it is normal to answer the question 'how are you' with 'this is really difficult', and no one bat an eyelid," she said.

'The Honest Mums' Club' is published by Darton, Longman and Todd, and is available now.

related articles
How can we tackle the stigma around mental health?
How can we tackle the stigma around mental health?

The conversation on mental health has opened up once again this week following the tragic suicide of Robin Williams. What can the Church do to help those living with depression?

How men can be better allies to women fighting inequality

The Matt Haig Twitterstorm shows us how men can be better allies to women fighting inequality, says Hannah Mudge.

Why being called God\'s precious princess isn\'t all that helpful
Why being called God's precious princess isn't all that helpful

Telling women God sees them as 'precious and beautiful' doesn't tackle route issues, writes Hannah Mudge.

Ten MYTHS about emotional health we need to eradicate from churches
Ten MYTHS about emotional health we need to eradicate from churches

With emotional health so often in the news, we're all becoming more aware.

The Christian storytelling boom: vulnerability, openness and emotional burnout
The Christian storytelling boom: vulnerability, openness and emotional burnout

Hannah Mudge looks at how the trend for harrowing personal essays plays out in the Christian blogosphere.

More than a third of Christians have suffered mental health problems

Over 35 per cent of Christians have experienced some form of mental health issue and more than 80 per cent knew a close friend or relative with similar experiences.

How the mental health system is failing young people and why Christians should care
How the mental health system is failing young people and why Christians should care

The end of last week brought more press reports of the worrying rise in mental health problems among children and young people in the UK.

Mercy Multiplied: Did it exorcise vulnerable women?
Mercy Multiplied: Did it exorcise vulnerable women?

An article for Slate claims to have identified a pattern of inappropriate and coercive treatment at Mercy Multiplied, formerly Mercy Ministries.

News
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda
Muslims sentenced to death for killing two evangelists in Uganda

A judge in Uganda has sentenced five Muslims to death for killing two Christian evangelists in 2024.

Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests
Indonesian authorities back church construction despite Muslim protests

Authorities in Indonesia recently allowed construction to proceed on worship buildings of two churches in different provinces despite vigorous protests from Muslim groups.

Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations
Wes Huff addresses plagiarism allegations

Scholar Dan McClellan alleged that Wes Huff plagiarized a 2016 Tyndale Seminary paper.

Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth
Adult baptisms rise by a third as Church of England sees fifth consecutive year of growth

Adult baptisms in the Church of England have increased by a third in a year, with almost 10,000 adults being baptised in 2025, according to newly published figures.