SNP MP says Scottish government's gender recognition plans should be scrapped

An SNP MP has warned that women's safety will be put at risk if the Scottish government goes ahead with planned gender reforms.

Speaking to The Telegraph, Angus MacNeil, MP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar, said he could not support the Gender Recognition Reform Bill because of the threat to women. 

He warned that the legislation could be exploited by "bad faith actors" who "masquerade" as trans people to enter women-only spaces.

The MP called for the Bill to be "withdrawn and scrapped" over the "loophole".

"This is not about trans people. It is about people who could possibly masquerade as trans people and invade women's safe spaces, who are known as bad-faith actors. I cannot support that," he said. 

"Trans people deserve respect and dignity. But this legislation is not about that. It poses a threat to women, especially those who are vulnerable, in safe spaces and that is clearly wrong.

"I stress this is not about the rights and dignity of trans people, but about those who pretend to be trans to gain access to women's safe spaces. Any legislation that creates that loophole is a concern."

The Bill was passed by MSPs just before Christmas but the UK government is considering a legal challenge to stop the legislation from becoming law.

The legislation would lower the current age limit that Scots can apply for a gender recognition certificate from 18 to 16 and remove the need for a medical diagnosis of gender dysphoria.

The waiting period would also be reduced from two years to three months - or six months in the case of 16 and 17 year olds.

Amendments to keep the age limit at 18 and stop sex offenders being able to change their gender were rejected by MSPs.

Scottish Catholic bishops have called the proposals "unsafe and likely to harm young people". They have also raised concerns about the freedoms of people who oppose transgender ideology.

The Christian Institute has called the legislation "lamentable".

Former Scottish First Minister, Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale, has spoken out against the Bill, saying that it could be used by rapists and sexual predators to gain access to female prisons or changing rooms. 

Harry Potter author JK Rowling has called the Bill "the single biggest assault on rights of Scottish women and girls in my lifetime". 

News
Archbishop of Canterbury withdraws award given to Muslim cleric who praised Bin Laden
Archbishop of Canterbury withdraws award given to Muslim cleric who praised Bin Laden

Reform leader Nigel Farage said the decision to award Hafiz Muhammad Tahir Mehmood Ashrafi was "astonishing". 

How the new General Synod could move beyond the present disagreement over same-sex relationships
How the new General Synod could move beyond the present disagreement over same-sex relationships

How might the next Synod make progress in the next five years based on a recognition that there are those in the Church of England who hold fundamentally opposed positions on the matter? Is there a way of allowing both sides to achieve what they want? Martin Davie argues that the answer to this question is ‘Yes.’

No part of London should become a free speech, gospel exclusion zone
No part of London should become a free speech, gospel exclusion zone

Soho is not exempt from freedom of speech and Christian expression. And Christians do not lose their fundamental freedoms when they cross an invisible boundary into a neighbourhood associated with a different worldview. The streets of London belong to all of us, writes Andrea Williams.

Church of England blessing same-sex relationships 'a bridge too far'
Church of England blessing same-sex relationships 'a bridge too far'

Earlier this year the Church silenced a group of former-homosexuals who wanted to tell of the change in their lives.