Dying girl, aged 5, prefers 'heaven' over hospital: Did she and her parents make the right choice?

Can a terminally ill five-year-old child decide whether to live or die?

As far as a family in Oregon is concerned, the answer is yes. But other people are not so sure whether it's the right call.

Michelle Moon recently shared online the touching story of Julianna Snow, her five-year-old daughter, who is suffering from a neurodegenerative disorder called Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. CNN then came up with a two-part series on Julianna dramatising the struggles the child and her family are going through. The story has since then been picked up by other news organisations.

According to various reports, Julianna's ailment has caused her to become so weak that even a minor cold could kill her.

The doctors have given up on Julianna, saying that if she becomes ill again, she would likely be sedated and placed on a respirator for the rest of her life until she breathes her last.

With no hope to cling to, Michelle and her husband Steve Snow decided to offer their daughter a choice, asking her: If you become ill again would you want to go to the hospital again, or to heaven instead?

Julianna chose heaven.

In her online post, Michelle recounts a conversation she had with her daughter as transcripted by CNN:

Michelle: Julianna, if you get sick again, do you want to go to the hospital again or stay home?

Julianna: Not the hospital.

Michelle: Even if that means that you will go to heaven if you stay home?

Julianna: Yes.

Michelle: And you know that mommy and daddy won't come with you right away? You'll go by yourself first.

Julianna: Don't worry. God will take care of me.

Michelle: And if you go to the hospital, it may help you get better and let you come home again and spend more time with us. I need to make sure that you understand that. Hospital may let you have more time with mommy and daddy.

Julianna: I understand.

Michelle: (crying) - I'm sorry, Julianna. I know you don't like it when I cry. It's just that I will miss you so much.

Julianna: That's OK. God will take care of me. He's in my heart.

If Julianna were an adult, it would be less controversial if she decided to say "enough" of the pain she suffers from whenever she is hospitalised.

But the problem is that Julianna is just 5 years old, raising the question on whether it was right for her parents to have allowed her to make a life-and-death choice.

Michelle received a mixed response from her blog post, with some readers voicing their support for her.

But others questioned her and her husband's decision. "Unbelievable that any parent would think a four-year-old (Julianna's age then) is able to understand or make a decision on life," Susan Timko wrote in the comments section. "Clearly that mother asks her leading questions. This article sickens me. I have a child with a chronic illness as well."

Following the criticism, Michelle wrote a second blog explaining her decision. She said it pains her and her husband to contemplate life without their child. She said her first instinct was to continue taking Julianna to the hospital, but they decided to honour Julianna's decision instead.

"We have had more conversations, mostly initiated by Julianna," Michelle wrote. "She's scared of dying, but has, to me, demonstrated adequate knowledge of what death is. She hasn't changed her mind about going back to the hospital, and she knows that this means she'll go to heaven by herself. If she gets sick, we'll ask her again, and we'll honour her wishes."

Michelle said Julianna's doctors support their decision to honour their child's wish.

But other doctors disagree on whether a child can already make the call between life and death. "This doesn't sit well with me. It makes me nervous," Art Caplan, the founding director of the Division of Medical Ethics at New York University, told CNN. "I think a 4-year-old might be capable of deciding what music to hear or what picture book they might want to read. But I think there's zero chance a 4-year-old can understand the concept of death. That kind of thinking doesn't really develop until around age nine or 10."

Michelle said Julianna has been out of the hospital for a year now and that she's enjoying her time with her while she's still breathing. When Julianna becomes gravely sick again, that will be the time when they will make the ultimate decision on whether to take their daughter back to the hospital—or just allow her to "go to heaven" inside their home.

related articles
Right to Die? It is always better to care, not to kill
Right to Die? It is always better to care, not to kill

We must challenge individualistic worldview on 'right to die, says Nola Leach.

Fearing intense pain, woman with terminal  cancer asks California to allow her to die
Fearing intense pain, woman with terminal cancer asks California to allow her to die

Although faith groups oppose doctor-assisted suicide, a 46-year-old Christian woman diagnosed with terminal cancer is asking the state of California to allow her to die.

Assisted Suicide: Respect for life is the glue which binds society together
Assisted Suicide: Respect for life is the glue which binds society together

In Christian thinking we are not just individuals making choices and doing our own thing. We are locked together in community, bound together by duties of care, responsibility and compassion, writes Professor John Wyatt.

Assisted suicide safeguards under threat, new evidence suggests
Assisted suicide safeguards under threat, new evidence suggests

The safeguards surrounding assisted suicide are unstable and impermanent, a recent report has suggested.

Assisted dying is \'Pandora\'s box\' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP
Assisted dying is 'Pandora's box' that will fundamentally change society - senior Tory MP

Assisted suicide is "understandable but wrong," Liam Fox, a senior Conservative MP, told Christian Today.

Five Reasons MPs Must Not Legalise Assisted Suicide
Five Reasons MPs Must Not Legalise Assisted Suicide

This is a milestone moment - here are five arguments against a change in the law.

Right to die law: Why California governor signed it and why critics are not buying it
Right to die law: Why California governor signed it and why critics are not buying it

After months of introspection and indecision, California Gov. Jerry Brown finally came out to put his stamp of approval on a literally life and death matter. On Monday, he signed ABX2 15, also called the "End of Life Option Act."

News
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously
John Lennox says there is enough evidence to take Christianity seriously

Speaking with agnostic YouTuber Joe Folley, Oxford mathematician John Lennox argued that the historical evidence for Jesus’ resurrection is enough of a reason for sceptics to explore whether his promises hold true in their own lives.

Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019
Calls for inquiry as recorded assisted suicide deaths in Hawaii rise 293% since 2019

Pro-life organisation Right To Life UK has called for an independent inquiry into Hawaii’s assisted suicide system after official figures showed a record number of deaths and the state’s Department of Health acknowledged gaps in its reporting.

Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?
Can Labour tackle the youth jobs crisis without addressing its roots?

The barriers that keep young people out of work can take shape long before they leave school. Tackling them starts with supporting families and giving every child the chance to develop their gifts.

Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan
Christian group calls for prayer for forced marriage victims in Pakistan

Every year it is estimated that around 1,000 girls in Pakistan are kidnapped, forcibly converted to Islam and married, often to a much older man.