Court says John MacArthur's church can hold indoor services, with singing and unlimited people

John MacArthur's church has been told it can hold indoor worship with singing and no limit on the number of people attending.

In-person services have continued to take place at MacArthur's Grace Community Church in defiance of California's lockdown orders.  MacArthur, whose church is located in Sun Valley, has maintained that the lockdown restrictions go too far.

The battle escalated when MacArthur filed a lawsuit against the state of California.  Last week, Los Angeles County then moved to impose a restraining order to stop the services taking place. 

The lawsuit filed against California questioned why protesters were allowed to gather in their thousands while congregations were being restricted.

"When many went to the streets to engage in 'political' or 'peaceful' protests purportedly against racism and police brutality, these protestors refused to comply with the pandemic restrictions," the church argued.

"Instead of enforcing the public health orders, public officials were all too eager to grant a de facto exception for these favored protestors.

"California targeted the wrong groups. California first lifted restrictions on gatherings that occurred outdoors — blessing after-the-fact the illegal conduct of the 'George Floyd' protestors. California then banned singing in worship services and then shut them all down — unless they could modify their services to operate identically to the now-legal protests."

On Friday, Judge James Chalfant, of the Los Angeles Superior Court, sided with the pastor by stating that the burden was on the state to demonstrate why it should be allowed to infringe on the constitutionally protected right of churches to exercise their religious freedom.

A full hearing is set for September 4 but the judge has permitted the church to continue meeting indoors on the condition that worshippers wear masks and observe social distancing between different households. 

MacArthur said of the judge's temporary order: "This vindicates our desire to stay open and serve our people.

"This also gives us an opportunity to show that we are not trying to be rebellious or unreasonable, but that we will stand firm to protect our church against unreasonable, unconstitutional restrictions."

News
Is this a turning point for parish ministry in the Church of England?
Is this a turning point for parish ministry in the Church of England?

Sarah Mullally’s Synod address offers a hopeful sign that the Church of England is listening to its parishes and taking seriously the pressures on clergy serving several congregations.

Where is this ‘space for faith’ that the King speaks of?
Where is this ‘space for faith’ that the King speaks of?

King Charles says the Church of England protects space for faith, but his words ring hollow at a time when the state he heads is harassing Christians for silent prayer and criticising Islam.

Wes Huff confesses to plagiarism, asks for prayer: 'It was sinful'
Wes Huff confesses to plagiarism, asks for prayer: 'It was sinful'

Canadian-born Christian apologist Wes Huff issued a statement Thursday confessing that he sinned by extensively plagiarizing other scholars and asked his followers to pray for his family.

‘Beyond astonishing’ that schools are encouraging children to play GTA 6, Christian group says
‘Beyond astonishing’ that schools are encouraging children to play GTA 6, Christian group says

Schools offered pupils gaming vouchers, raffle prizes and other incentives to keep them in class as the 18-rated game went on sale.