Ancient manuscripts suggest Muhammad did not write Quran, experts say

Followers of the Islamic religion believe that their holy book, the Quran, was revealed by Allah to their most revered prophet, Muhammad.

Ancient manuscripts obtained by the University of Birmingham, however, suggest that it was not exactly Muhammad who wrote the Quran.

Jamal bin Huwareib, managing director of the Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum Foundation, said based on the two leaves of an ancient Quran in the British university, Islam's holy book appeared to have been written by Abu Bakr, who was the Muslim prophet's close companion.

"It's the most important discovery ever for the Muslim world. I believe this is the Quran of Abu Bakr," bin Huwareib told BBC after examining the ancient manuscripts.

The scholar also suggested that Muhammad may have commissioned Abu Bakr, a caliph who ruled from 632 to 634, to write the Quran based on the high quality of the handwriting and the parchment used in the ancient manuscript, indicating that it was made for someone important.

"This version, this collection, this manuscript is the root of Islam. It's the root of the Quran. This will be a revolution in studying Islam," bin Huwareib said.

Radioactive testing done on the Birmingham transcript also dated the ancient manuscript between 568 and 645, or possibly 13 years after the death of Muhammad in 632.

David Thomas, Birmingham University's professor of Christianity and Islam, explained that this indicated that the manuscript already existed during the early days of Islam.

"The person who actually wrote it could well have known the Prophet Muhammad," Thomas also told BBC.

With these facts, Professor Joseph Lumbard from the department of Arabic and translation studies at the American University of Sharjah in the United Arab Emirates, said the possibility that Muhammad did not write the Quran himself cannot be ruled out.

"I would not discount that it could be a fragment from the codex collected by Zayd ibn Thabit under Abu Bakr," Lumbard said.

related articles
Islam a religion of violence; Quran directly incites terror, killing people of other faiths, Danish study says
Islam a religion of violence; Quran directly incites terror, killing people of other faiths, Danish study says

Islam a religion of violence; Quran directly incites terror, killing people of other faiths, Danish study says

Digital devotions' hidden risk: Malware found on hundreds of Bible and Quran apps

Digital devotions' hidden risk: Malware found on hundreds of Bible and Quran apps

Quran as Yale law book? No way, says Pat Robertson, since it\'s based on Shariah \'that has to do with beheadings\'
Quran as Yale law book? No way, says Pat Robertson, since it's based on Shariah 'that has to do with beheadings'

Quran as Yale law book? No way, says Pat Robertson, since it's based on Shariah 'that has to do with beheadings'

News
ACNA leader takes leave of absence amid investigation into alleged abuse
ACNA leader takes leave of absence amid investigation into alleged abuse

The head of the Anglican Church in North America has taken a leave of absence as an investigation into allegations of abuse leveled against him continues.

Bible reading linked to greater generosity, study finds
Bible reading linked to greater generosity, study finds

Research into Bible reading by the American Bible Society (ABS) has found that it impacts on generosity, compassion, and social attitudes.

What is the Filoque Controversy in the Nicene Creed?
What is the Filoque Controversy in the Nicene Creed?

The Nicene Creed was formulated 1,700 years ago in AD 325 at the Council of Nicaea. Later, one clause in it called the Filoque was a cause of division between the Eastern and Western Church. This is the story …

Top BBC journalist to speak at London church service
Top BBC journalist to speak at London church service

A leading BBC journalist will share insights gained while covering the war in Ukraine during a poignant remembrance service in London on the evening of 11 November.