After Larycia Hawkins, what next for Wheaton College?

It seems the melancholy saga of Larycia Hawkins and Wheaton College is finally at an end.

The professor who sent the evangelical world into theological meltdown by saying on Facebook that Christians and Muslims "worship the same God" and was facing the termination of her employment is indeed leaving, but with her head held high.

She and the college issued a joint press release two days ago saying they had "come together and found a mutual place of resolution and reconciliation" and had "reached a confidential agreement under which they will part ways". Hawkins says nice things about the college and Wheaton president Philip Ryken says nice things about her. Provost Stanton Jones, who had been in the front line of the battle, released an email apologising for any failings he had shown. In fact, the public demeanor of both sides has been very good throughout; no one has abused anyone and everyone has concentrated on the issues.

However, it is unquestionably Wheaton that has come off worst. Its reputation as an "academically rigorous Christian liberal arts college" has taken a serious blow.

Its actions have met massive resistance from among its own staff, almost 80 of whom urged the college to drop its action against Hawkins, and students, who demonstrated and fasted for her. A group of 20 former students who are now political scientists wrote an open letter to Ryken expressing their feelings about what the college's actions said about academic freedom, saying among other things they were "greatly concerned about the effect this incident will have on Wheaton College graduates pursuing an academic vocation".

Hawkins' defenders – including the college's own faculty diversity committee – said she was the victim of discrimination; the attitude of her attackers, including Franklin Graham, was "Shame on her!"

If the college is wise, it will mount a full-scale review into how things went so badly wrong. Among the issues to consider are indeed questions of diversity and discrimination, communication, accountability and all the other questions of how such an institution governs itself.

However, there's another question, and that is whether Wheaton will look at how it does theology. Because the issue was not one that needed to divide opinion to the extent that it did, as a moment's reflection would have shown. Instead, a knee-jerk reaction has led to a world of pain.  

It should be clear enough that the answer to the question, "Do Muslims and Christians worship the same God?" can easily be answered in different ways. Yes, in that Islam belongs to the same historical and cultural family tree as Christianity and that we share, to a greater degree than other religions, a common language about God. No, in that God was incarnate in Christ alone. Wheaton's instinctive exclusion of the former meaning and assumption of heresy has aligned it with an uncompromising, oppositional fundamentalism, one of whose hallmarks is a deep suspicion of Islam.

It is this, rather than failures of process, that casts the longest shadow over the college's future. While Hawkins and the college are parting friends, they are still parting. Any other professors with mildly unorthodox views will regard themselves as warned. Hawkins' experience will not encourage them to test the limits of the college's tolerance.

The danger for Wheaton – arguably the most prestigious of the self-identified evangelical colleges – is that it becomes the scene of a battle between conservatives and moderates reminiscent of the fraticidal struggle that gripped the Southern Baptist Convention during the 1980s, which is described – along party lines – either as a 'conservative resurgence' or a 'fundamentalist takeover'. It would be a pity to see that history repeat itself, and for so little cause.

Follow Mark Woods on Twitter: @RevMarkWoods

related articles
Muslim woman says Trump backers are supporting \'hateful rhetoric\'
Muslim woman says Trump backers are supporting 'hateful rhetoric'

Rose Hamid was ejected from a Donald Trump rally in South Carolina while engaging in a silent protest.

Wheaton students demonstrate for hijab-wearing professor as termination looms
Wheaton students demonstrate for hijab-wearing professor as termination looms

Hawkins was attacked for her statement in a Facebook post that Muslims and Christians "worship the same God"

Hijab-wearing professor Larycia Hawkins backed by Wheaton colleagues
Hijab-wearing professor Larycia Hawkins backed by Wheaton colleagues

The Wheaton College professor facing termination for alleged theological unorthodoxy has won the backing of the college's faculty council in her fight to stay.

Franklin Graham on Wheaton row: Muslims and Christians do NOT worship the same God
Franklin Graham on Wheaton row: Muslims and Christians do NOT worship the same God

Islam and Christianity "clearly do not worship the same God", according to leading preacher and evangelist Franklin Graham.

Hijab row professor Larycia Hawkins is to leave Wheaton College
Hijab row professor Larycia Hawkins is to leave Wheaton College

The American professor who was widely criticised after she wore a hijab throughout Advent in solidarity with Muslims and who stated that Muslims and Christians worship the same God is to leave her Christian college.

News
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain

Architectural historian Steven Brindle talks to Christian Today about the faith that shaped 1930s Britain, the churches that supported struggling communities and what lessons the decade might have for us today.

Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach
Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach

Shine Your Light is aiming to mobilise half a million Christians to share the gospel with five million people across the UK this Christmas, with more than 2,000 churches already signed up, organisers say.

The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'
The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'

The Church of England's uneasiness about the government's ‘conversion practices’ bill is a perfect lesson in the old adage, 'be careful what you wish for,' writes Dr Martin Davie.

Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns
Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns

An internal Home Office report lists concerns about immigration, multiculturalism and changing social values among the characteristics associated with what it calls "Christian extremism", it has been reported.