Atheist minister says not allowing her to continue in church ministry would be a 'betrayal'

The atheist minister of a church in Toronto, Canada has claimed that it would be a 'betrayal' to remove her from her position because she didn't believe in God.

Gretta Vosper, a 60-year-old minister in the United Church of Canada, told the Religion News Service that she was 'very surprised' to still be in her job after officially coming out as an atheist in 2013. 

She admitted her true beliefs about God and the divinity of Jesus despite having been the minister of West Hill United Church in Toronto since 1997. 

There were calls for her to be defrocked and the Toronto Conference asked the Church's General Council to launch a review into her suitability for ministry. 

However, before the review was due to start last year, the Toronto Conference and Vosper reached a settlement that allowed her to remain as minister of West Hill United Church.

She said that although she could not comment on the specifics of the settlement due to a non-disclosure agreement, she is 'able to function in ministry with all the rights and privileges that clergy have'.

She also said that she continues to teach in the church what she learned during her years in seminary. 

'Everything I teach is consistent with the theological training I received,' she said.

'I was taught the Bible was a human construction, and there is much wisdom in many texts, both ancient and contemporary.'

Vosper added that she has no plans to quit church ministry in spite of her atheism and that she thinks it would have been a 'betrayal' if she had been forced to go.

'I still feel that this is my denomination,' she told RNS. 'This is my heritage, and to refuse to allow me to participate and continue in ministry felt like a betrayal.'

News
Met accused of ‘ineffective’ policing at March for Life UK
Met accused of ‘ineffective’ policing at March for Life UK

Only one arrest was made on the day - a pro-lifer who was subsequently released without charge.

170 baptised at Bigbury-on-Sea
170 baptised at Bigbury-on-Sea

Mass baptisms in the sea are becoming more popular.

MPs vote against assisted suicide in 'victory for hope, compassion and life'
MPs vote against assisted suicide in 'victory for hope, compassion and life'

Almost the exact same Parliament voting for the almost exact same bill - but a very different result.

Historic UK churches face growing maintenance crisis despite £2.6m in grants
Historic UK churches face growing maintenance crisis despite £2.6m in grants

The National Churches Trust has warned that historic church buildings across the UK are facing mounting financial and maintenance pressures, despite awarding more than £2.6 million in grants during 2025.