Pope Francis ambushed over whether Israel should be recognised as Jewish state

The head of the delegation of Israeli rabbis present at Pope Francis' visit to Rome's Great Synagogue has revealed he put him on the spot over the Vatican's relationship to Israel.

Rabbi Dr Ratzon Arusi told the Arutz Sheva news service that during the visit he turned to the Pope and asked him to declare that the Vatican recognises Israel as the state of the Jewish people.

He said the Pope, clearly embarrassed, responded with silence.

Francis used his visit to the synagogue to condemn religious violence, saying: "The violence of man against man is in contradiction with any religion worthy of this name, in particular the three great monotheistic religions [Judaism, Christianity and Islam].

"Conflicts, wars, violence and injustices open deep wounds in humanity that call on us to strengthen our commitment to peace and justice. Neither violence nor death will ever have the last word before God."

Rabbi Arusi told Arutz Sheva: "The Church ignores the state of Israel as the state of the Jewish people, they talk about the Holy Land, but not about the state of Israel.

"Therefore during the meeting with the rabbis after the public event, I turned to the Pope and I told him that we appreciate his words against anti-Semitism, but today there is a new and very fierce anti-Semitism built on the basis of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict."

Referring to the British politician whose support for the state of Israel was crucial to its establishment, he said he had urged the Pope to be "the Balfour of the Catholic church, and since the land of Israel is the Holy Land and they recognise our birthright, they should declare that the state of Israel is the state of the Jewish people by virtue of the Bible, without diminishing the rights of the Palestinians to a state".

Arusi said the Pope was "very embarrassed by my request, he was never told that directly, and afterwards he smiled but didn't say a thing". He added: "I think that the time has come for them to indeed recognise the state of Israel as the state of the Jewish people."

The recognition of Israel as a Jewish state is a highly controversial issue as it has implications for the country's sizeable Arab population, which includes Christians and Muslims.

Rome's recognition of the Palestinian state has infuriated right-wing activists, with Israel calling the accord a hasty move that could damage prospects for advancing a peace agreement and impact its future diplomatic relations with the Vatican.

related articles
US to \'reassess\' Israel policy after Netanyahu\'s declaration against two-state solution for Palestine
US to 'reassess' Israel policy after Netanyahu's declaration against two-state solution for Palestine

US to 'reassess' Israel policy after Netanyahu's declaration against two-state solution for Palestine

Orthodox Rabbis say Christianity is part of God's divine plan

Orthodox Rabbis say Christianity is part of God's divine plan

Vatican treaty with Palestine does not mean Pope Francis has abandoned Israel
Vatican treaty with Palestine does not mean Pope Francis has abandoned Israel

Vatican treaty with Palestine does not mean Pope Francis has abandoned Israel

Pope Francis visits Rome\'s Great Synagogue, condemns religious violence
Pope Francis visits Rome's Great Synagogue, condemns religious violence

Pope Francis visits Rome's Great Synagogue, condemns religious violence

News
Seeing God at work in everyday life
Seeing God at work in everyday life

In her new book, 605 Everyday Miracles, Alpha UK director Chloe Swart challenges the perception that miraculous healing is reserved for extraordinary people or church events.

More than 30 Christians Slain in Plateau State, Nigeria
More than 30 Christians Slain in Plateau State, Nigeria

Attacks on villages of one area also leave injuries and destruction.

Church vows to plough on with Project Spire
Church vows to plough on with Project Spire

Project Spire has been criticised morally, historically, theologically, practically and legally.

Extremist abductions in Nigeria surge by 153% as violence rises again, report finds
Extremist abductions in Nigeria surge by 153% as violence rises again, report finds

Abductions linked to extremist violence in Nigeria more than doubled in the final three months of 2025, according to a new report warning that insecurity in the country is worsening again after several years of comparatively lower violence.