United Methodist pastors urge the church to remain unified in face of same-sex marriage debate

Logo of the United Methodist Church Wikimedia

Several hundred Methodist pastors signed a petition Friday asking the United Methodist Church not to split over the same-sex marriage debate.

The denomination is facing a possible schism as pastors disagree on whether gay marriage and gay clergy are holy or unholy.

Pastor John Hill of Suntree United Methodist in Melbourne, Florida said he is grieved by the dissention in the church.

"It's distressing to me that we're still focusing on minor issues, same-sex, homosexuality," he told Florida Today.

"Others may feel different, but the real issues that Jesus called us to confront are feeding the hungry, clothing the naked and not necessarily this issue. It's maybe important but not essential."

Hill was one of the pastors who signed Friday's statement.

Three weeks ago, over 80 Methodist clergy—representing all five jurisdictions and more than 30 Annual Conferences—released a statement saying that the church is in the midst of major crises, and proposing that the denomination be split into Traditional and Progressive sects.

"It is time to recognize that traditionalists and progressives are pursuing divergent paths as we try to follow Christ and be faithful to what we understand to be the Gospel," they wrote.

"Though there are deeper issues that divide us, our differences, unfortunately, have now come to the fore around the subjects of marriage and human sexuality."

The 80 Methodist leaders said that there is no middle ground or compromise that can be made between those who believe in biblical marriage, and those who include gay clergy and same-sex couples in the Body of Christ. For these leaders, the only acceptable answer is for the Methodist church to split.

Pastor Hill and hundreds of other pastors hope there is another solution.

"There have always been people who have been fringe groups, you have people who are pro-gay and anti-gay," Pastor Fred Ball of First United Methodist Church in Titusville told Florida Today.

"I don't see room for [division]. We are pro-people. We've been loving the community where they are for 100 years."

Methodist church member Mac McInnis said he hasn't heard talk of the denomination splitting, but isn't surprised.

"It seems like the whole nation is divided right now," he said.

According to a poll by Corporate Research and Research Now, more than 90 percent of United Methodist Church members believe the church should not split.

Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
What should Christians make of Tommy Robinson?
What should Christians make of Tommy Robinson?

In demanding that the likes of Robinson be banned from the Oxford Union, the clergy are in effect setting their own limit on freedom of speech and freedom of religion.

Christian woman persecuted by Iranian regime sentenced to 9 years in prison
Christian woman persecuted by Iranian regime sentenced to 9 years in prison

A Christian convert in Iran has been sentenced to nine years and eight months in prison on trumped-up charges linked to state security and anti-government activity.

John Lennox fears AI is making us lazy
John Lennox fears AI is making us lazy

Christian media leaders heard calls for courage, authenticity and discernment at the recent Revive 2026 conference.

Does the Church of England need to re-think its messaging?
Does the Church of England need to re-think its messaging?

If you look at the Church of England’s communications all that it ever seems to highlight is the good works that Christians do to improve the temporal well-being of their neighbours. It is right to highlight these things, but they are not the primary reason for the Church’s existence.