Ultra-conservative Society of St Pius X accuses Pope Francis of causing Church 'painful confusion'

An ultra-conservative Roman Catholic group has apparently abandoned efforts to reconcile with Rome after accusing Pope Francis of causing 'painful confusion' on Wednesday.

The controversial Society of St Pius X has said it "does not now primarily seek a canonical recognition" from the Vatican.

The society, founded by the late French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in 1970, mainly in opposition to the Second Vatican Council reforms, has championed conservative and right-wing positions and has been severely critical of several popes. Some of its members have been accused of Holocaust denial.

Popes have been seeking to reconcile with the group since 1988, when the Vatican excommunicated Lefebvre and four other bishops after Lefebvre consecrated them without the pope's consent. 

However, these efforts appear to have been conclusively rejected. The society wrote in the statement, released on its website, that there is a "great and painful confusion that currently reigns in the church" that "requires the denunciation of errors that have made their way into it and are unfortunately encouraged by a large number of pastors, including the pope himself".

Pope Benedict XVI made reconciliation a priority during his papacy. However, after three years of negotiations talks collapsed in 2012, due to apparent doctrinal difficulties.

The statement comes less than three months after Pope Francis met with the society's superior general Bishop Bernard Fellay at the Vatican in April. The pope had also earlier indicated a move toward reconciliation and the potential restoration of the excommunicated bishops.

In a September letter to the Pontifical Council for the Promotion of New Evangelisation, which is organising the Holy Year of Mercy, Pope Francis said that members of the Society of St Pius X would be granted faculties during the year to offer absolution of sins to those who approach them for confession.

The statement from the society ends by writing that "The society of Saint Pius X prays and does penance for the Pope, that he might have the strength to proclaim the Catholic faith and morals in their entirety."

related articles
Bishop excommunicated for a second time over illict consecration
Bishop excommunicated for a second time over illict consecration

Bishop excommunicated for a second time over illict consecration

Swiss Catholics accuse Pope\'s representative of disloyalty
Swiss Catholics accuse Pope's representative of disloyalty

Swiss Catholics accuse Pope's representative of disloyalty

Amoris Laetitia: How the Pope\'s exhortation could shake up the Church
Amoris Laetitia: How the Pope's exhortation could shake up the Church

Amoris Laetitia: How the Pope's exhortation could shake up the Church

Pope Francis: Church must ask forgiveness from gay people

Pope Francis: Church must ask forgiveness from gay people

Feast of St Peter and St Paul 2016: How and why do we celebrate these early church heroes?
Feast of St Peter and St Paul 2016: How and why do we celebrate these early church heroes?

Feast of St Peter and St Paul 2016: How and why do we celebrate these early church heroes?

News
Lessons from Old Testament figures: Jonathan
Lessons from Old Testament figures: Jonathan

As we continue our series exploring the lives of Old Testament figures, we turn to Jonathan - a prince and warrior whose remarkable faith, courage and sacrificial friendship reveal what it means to put God’s purposes above our own.

New resource launched to bring evangelism and social action together
New resource launched to bring evangelism and social action together

Christian charity Jubilee+ is launching a new resource designed to help churches connect their work tackling poverty with sharing the Christian faith.

500 million Christians worldwide face Bible access restrictions, report finds
500 million Christians worldwide face Bible access restrictions, report finds

At the same time, more than 125 million Christians want a Bible but do not have one, according to the 2026 Bible Access List.

Sukkot: humble hut or clouds of Divine glory?
Sukkot: humble hut or clouds of Divine glory?

Jewish academic and Hebrew scholar Irene Lancaster explains the significance of Sukkot in Judaism.