Rural vicars struggling with multiple churches and dying congregations

 (Photo: Andreas Krappweis)

Vicars in rural Britain are rushing between multiple churches to take Sunday services while their congregations are dying off faster than they can be replaced, according to a new report.

Urgent calls for reform of rural ministry, such as appointing parish administrators to relieve clergy of the burden of running several churches at once, are proposed in the report, to be debated at General Synod in February.

Fewer than one in five rural churches is experiencing growth - a statistic repeated in urban areas - and parishes are struggling to fill all the positions on the church council, especially to find church wardens. In some parishes, if all positions were filled, they would outnumber the worshippers in the pew.

"There was a frequent lament that some (not all) congregations were stuck in a rut and were not open to new ideas or approaches but were desperate for people to come to church to ensure that the building remained open and the familiar worship continued," says the report, based on quantitative and qualitative research.

In one parish, no more than 2,000 people were maintaining six Grade 1 churches.

However, there was a strong commitment across communities to keep churches open, especially where they served as a hub for community activites and had good facilities. Initiatives such as Fresh Expressions and Messy Church were making a tangible difference.

One vicar said the age profile was heavily weighted in favour of older people. "Our numbers have stayed the same overall but I'm basically replacing the dead people with new people who are much younger but in the future when all the oldest people have died, there won't be enough 40-50 years old to take their places."

Nearly two-thirds of Church of England churches, 10,199 and two-thirds of parishesm, 8,394, are in rural areas. The population of rural England is 9.3 million, or 17.6 per cent of the population.

More than seven in ten are in multi-church groups, with more than 11 churches per group becoming increasingly common. Some groups cover hundreds of square miles, with tens of miles between churches.

Bishop of Knaresborough James Bell, who heads the synod's rural affairs group, writes in the report that ministry models that assume one church per priest are not effective in such contexts and clergy have mostly had to forge their own way ahead in order to offer effective parish ministry.

They were finding it difficult to focus on growth at a time when when the demands of a scattered population, bureaucracy, many buildings and social change in rural communities can be all-absorbing, he says.

Arguing that multi-church groups need not be seen as "instances of decline and despair" and that they can instead be vanguards in rethinking mission and ministry, he nevertheless admits that there can be a "reluctance to recognise realities and an inertia which drains energy, enthusiasm and potential from everyone."

More women clergy work in rural parishes than urban ones.

Clergy in rural areas feel pressured to conduct as many services as possible on a Sunday and they find it difficult to get to know congregations when there is no time to talk after the service because of having to rush to the next service.

The report is the latest initiative in a series of reports designed to boost growth throughout the Church to be debated at the next synod.

Released for Mission, Growing the Rural Church, also recommends more ecumenical partnerships.

Bishop Bell says: "A Christian presence in every community is more than a strap-line - it is the heart of English Anglicanism. It is the expression of our obligation, as the church for all the people of the nation, to leave no community untouched by the gospel of Jesus Christ, lived out among the people of every place.

"Ministry and mission in the rural church is highly demanding of energy and imagination. Growth is being realised but much needs to be done."

related articles
Radical shake up of CofE urged to stop \'terrifying\' decline
Radical shake up of CofE urged to stop 'terrifying' decline

Radical shake up of CofE urged to stop 'terrifying' decline

Linda Woodhead: Plans for CofE shake up are wrongly focused
Linda Woodhead: Plans for CofE shake up are wrongly focused

Linda Woodhead: Plans for CofE shake up are wrongly focused

Research finds major barrier to mission is \'paralysing fear of rejection\'
Research finds major barrier to mission is 'paralysing fear of rejection'

Research finds major barrier to mission is 'paralysing fear of rejection'

News
The story of the pope known as the Apostle to the English
The story of the pope known as the Apostle to the English

Pope Gregory I, known as Gregory the Great, was one of the most important popes, and his positive legacy is still felt today - not least in Britain. This is the story … 

Christians redouble efforts to stop assisted suicide
Christians redouble efforts to stop assisted suicide

Christians are doubling down on efforts to stop assisted suicide becoming legal in England and Wales after Kim Leadbeater's bill was debated in Westminster on Friday. 

Christian leaders unite in Westminster to kick off 2025 ‘Shine Your Light’ evangelism campaign
Christian leaders unite in Westminster to kick off 2025 ‘Shine Your Light’ evangelism campaign

More than 100 Christian leaders recently came together at a parliamentary reception in London for the launch of Shine Your Light 2025 — a bold evangelistic initiative aiming to bring the message of Christ to streets, neighbourhoods, and marketplaces across the UK.

Darlington nurses still waiting for single-sex changing space despite Supreme Court ruling
Darlington nurses still waiting for single-sex changing space despite Supreme Court ruling

An NHS trust has been accused of continually flouting the law around women’s rights by requiring female nurses to get changed in front of a biologically male nurse who goes by the name of “Rose”.