South African Study Backs Drugs Over Food in HIV Fight
Neither food nor food supplements are alternatives to drug therapy in treating people with HIV/AIDS, South Africa's top scientific advisory panel said on Tuesday, amid a controversy over the nation's AIDS policies.
Posted: Tuesday, August 21, 2007, 15:46 (BST)
Neither food nor food supplements are alternatives to drug therapy in treating people with HIV/AIDS, South Africa's top scientific advisory panel said on Tuesday, amid a controversy over the nation's AIDS policies.
The report by the Academy of Science of South Africa was issued as President Thabo Mbeki faced new criticism over support for his health minister, who promotes nutritional treatment for AIDS, and the sacking of a deputy minister who backed drug treatments.
The inter-disciplinary scientific panel, which advises the government on health policies, began studying nutritional influences on the human immune system in October 2005, focusing on the virus that causes AIDS and tuberculosis (TB).
"The panel has concluded that no food, no component made from food, and no food supplement has been identified in any credible study as an effective alternative to appropriate medication," said Prof Barry Mendelow, chairman of a 15-member panel from the Academy of Science of South Africa (ASSAf).
Mendelow told Reuters the panel found while nutritional intervention is "a valuable supportive measure", the primary treatment is anti-retrovirals and anti-TB drug therapy.
"It's not a question of one or the other," he added.
South Africa has one of the world's highest HIV infection rate with an estimated 12 percent of the country's 47 million population infected with the deadly virus.
Besides a struggling health-care system characterised by a lack of doctors and nurses, many of whom have left the country for better pay abroad, the fight against AIDS has been hampered by conflicting messages from senior government officials.
Mbeki sacked Deputy Health Minister Nozizwe Madlala-Routledge this month for insubordination, sparking an outcry from AIDS activists who strongly backed her policies and critics who say she was fired for political reasons.
Madlala-Routledge had clashed with Health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, dubbed "Dr Beetroot", who had horrified AIDS activists with her advocacy of garlic, lemon and African potatoes over conventional anti-retroviral drugs.
© Reuters 2007. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by caching, framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
Have your say on this article
The comments below are readers' personal opinions and are in no way intended to reflect the editorial opinion of Christian Today.
Added: Wednesday, August 22, 2007, 17:08 (BST)
I am writing to support President Mbeki and Minister Tshablala-Msimang.
I do so, based on my 25 years of direct experience helping tens of thousands of people with AIDS related conditions and fears.
In my opinion, it's long past time, for thinking people to recognize that the Behavior based-Syndrome in the West and the Poverty Induced-Syndrome in Africa are very different Acquired Immuno-Deficiency Syndromes, with very different causes.
According to Maxime Seligmann et al., writing in the New England Journal of Medicine, November 15, 1984, volume 311, page 1289: “the commonest cause of T-cell immunodeficiency worldwide is protein-calorie malnutrition (PCM). Malnourished children have defects in macrophage and T-cell function accompanied by increased susceptibility to infections. These effects are particularly marked in malnourished children. Bacterial super infection in these children is a major cause of serious disease and death.”
Instead of condemning President Mbeki and Minister Tshablala-Msimang, we should be commending them for insisting that meeting South Africa's basic nutritional needs is the necessary foundation of all health care in South Africa. It is basic common sense!
In closing, I too, question the use of toxic chemotherapies to treat immune-deficiencies and protest the junk-science that supports their use.
Rev Dr Michael Ellner
The writer is president of HEAL (Health Education AIDS Liaison-NYC,) one of the world's oldest and largest all volunteer AIDS Information Networks.
Rev Dr Michael Ellner, New York City, USA
