Interfaith encounters: Why respecting other faiths doesn't mean compromising your own

Market traders with garlands for sale.

A couple of years ago I had what I confidently expected to be the holiday of a lifetime. For two weeks I was that traditionally well-meaning but awkward individual, the Englishman abroad. It was India.

As well as a large hole in the household budget, that holiday blew a larger one in some unsuspected preconceptions. One of these was that the Taj Mahal might be a bit cheesy; it's amazing, but that's another story.

As a Baptist minister, I'm what you might call professionally curious about religion. There are plenty of Hindus in Britain, but I've never seen much of Hinduism here and was hoping to find out more about it.

What challenged me was not the content of my discoveries, though. Hinduism has 36 million gods (yes, really), Ganesh is the elephant one – I vaguely knew that and I could have found it out from a textbook, anyway. I was struck more by some of the people I met. One of them stands out. Our guide in one of the cities was particularly devout and made a point of touching the doorsteps of the temples he showed us, pausing for moments of personal devotion and occasionally talking very naturally about what his faith meant to him.

article,article,article,article More by this author

We visited a particular temple at which the congregation was waiting entranced, singing a low, repetitive chant in front of a closed curtain. He asked us to wait for a few minutes. Not sure what to expect, we agreed. The curtain was drawn back and the crowd exploded into a shout of rapture as the image of the goddess Kali was revealed: clearly it was a moving and meaningful experience for them.

As we left, our guide draped garlands of marigolds around our necks and told us we shouldn't just discard them; they had been dedicated to the goddess and had to be laid beneath a particular tree, whose name I'm sorry to say I can't remember.

Here's the thing, though. I am an evangelical Christian, believing in the uniqueness of Christ, the incarnate son of God – and I didn't once try to convert our guide. I wore a garland dedicated to Kali, and at the end of the day I didn't just chuck it in the bin. I gave it to our driver to dispose of reverently, and if I knew which tree to lay it under I would gladly have done so myself.

So, did I compromise my faith? I don't think so.

This is a plea for that under-rated theological virtue: politeness. I was in the guide's territory; not just geographically but spiritually. My role was to listen. The garland was a gift and it was appropriate to respect it.

I was a tourist, and this hardly counts as deep inter-faith experience. But for readers privileged to enter further into the lives of people of other faiths, let me commend politeness as a good place to stand. In this context it means, I think, respecting the other person as a person, with all their intellectual and spiritual apparatus, and putting questions of ultimate truth aside until we are mutually secure enough to talk about them.

God, I believe, takes the long view: in our politeness, perhaps we are reflecting something about him.

Follow @RevMarkWoods on Twitter.

Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
related articles
Nine-year-old girl shoots and kills instructor - time for a rethink of gun laws?
Nine-year-old girl shoots and kills instructor - time for a rethink of gun laws?

Nine-year-old girl shoots and kills instructor - time for a rethink of gun laws?

Comment: Why Evangelicals can\'t support Israel\'s land grabs
Comment: Why Evangelicals can't support Israel's land grabs

Comment: Why Evangelicals can't support Israel's land grabs

Is Islam a violent religion?
Is Islam a violent religion?

Is Islam a violent religion?

The Government\'s blind spot: Why it doesn\'t get Islam
The Government's blind spot: Why it doesn't get Islam

The Government's blind spot: Why it doesn't get Islam

News
Calls for an end to the sexualisation of children in schools
Calls for an end to the sexualisation of children in schools

The Coalition for Marriage is taking on a "summer of sex" campaign planned by a Labour MP at Westminster.

Free speech concerns surround proposed conversion therapy ban
Free speech concerns surround proposed conversion therapy ban

Any law banning "abusive conversion practices" would almost certainly infringe on freedom of speech.

Pope warns of ‘digital neocolonialism’ and calls on Church to defend human dignity in age of AI in first encyclical
Pope warns of ‘digital neocolonialism’ and calls on Church to defend human dignity in age of AI in first encyclical

Pope Leo XIV has used his first encyclical to warn that artificial intelligence and emerging technologies risk deepening global inequality, concentrating power in the hands of a few and creating what he described as “colonialism in another form". 

A growing number of Protestants say others don’t know they’re Christian
A growing number of Protestants say others don’t know they’re Christian

The honesty of churchgoers about gaps in living unashamed reveals large numbers have room for growth in this important aspect of discipleship,” said Scott McConnell, executive director of Lifeway Research.