Woman convicted under controversial feticide law

 (Photo: Wikimedia)

A woman in Indiana was sentenced to 20 years in prison last week under the state's feticide law. 

Purvi Patel's case is the first in the country, and has drawn controversy from reproductive health advocates. 

The 33-year-old hid her pregnancy from her strict Hindu parents, and gave birth at their home in July 2013. She alleges that the baby was stillborn, and she put it in a dumpster before going to St Joseph Regional Medical Center.

The baby's age was disputed by the defense and prosecution, but experts placed it between 23 and 30 weeks. They also argued whether the baby was born alive, and conducted a controversial "float test" of the baby's lungs to support the argument that it took at least one breath. 

Patel ordered abortion pills from Hong Kong, and texted her friend saying she had taken them. However, there was no trace of the pills in her system, or the baby's. The jury believed that she did ingest the abortifacients, and convicted her of feticide.

Patel was also convicted of child neglect after the jury found the baby was born alive, and the mother made no attempt to save it. Prosecutors said the feticide and child neglect charges are not contradictory because an attempted feticide is enough for a conviction. 

Women's health advocates said that the Patel case set a disturbing precedent for women who suffer stillbirths and miscarriages. 

"Prosecutors in Indiana are using this very sad situation to establish that intentional abortions as well as unintentional pregnancy losses should be punished as crimes," said Lynn Paltrow, executive director of National Advocates for Pregnant Women.

"No woman should be arrested for the outcome of her pregnancy."

Patel plans to appeal the decision. 

Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
News
In many English cities, cathedrals play a major role
In many English cities, cathedrals play a major role

It’s impossible to imagine St Albans without its cathedral.

England’s cathedrals remain vital civic and spiritual ‘beacons’ despite mounting pressures – report
England’s cathedrals remain vital civic and spiritual ‘beacons’ despite mounting pressures – report

A new report from Theos found that cathedrals continue to play a uniquely important role in national life despite increasing secularisation and growing financial pressures. 

Thousands attend 'March for Jesus' in Belfast
Thousands attend 'March for Jesus' in Belfast

"The atmosphere was full of joy, faith and the presence of God," said organisers.

'Quiet revival' claims 'laid to rest' once and for all as study shows UK churchgoing continues to fall
'Quiet revival' claims 'laid to rest' once and for all as study shows UK churchgoing continues to fall

New figures from the British Social Attitudes survey also show there are no signs of a religious revival among young people.