Vatican official opposes Synod plan for Church to integrate civilly divorced and remarried Catholics, warns of 'conflicts'

German Cardinal Walter Brandmüller says 'a contradiction between a papal document and the Catechism of the Catholic Church would not be imaginable.' (Veritas-vincit-international.org)

A high-ranking Vatican official has made known his opposition to the suggestion made at the Synod of bishops that civilly divorced and remarried Catholics may be allowed to become "more integrated" into the Church.

German Cardinal Walter Brandmüller, president emeritus of the Pontifical Committee for Historical Sciences, called the proposal "impossible" to implement since is not founded on the truths of the indissolubility of marriage and the sacredness of Holy Communion, LifeSite News reports.

Brandmüller made his position known on Wednesday, two days before Pope Francis is scheduled to release his Apostolic Exhortation on the family. The Exhortation will be released on April 8 at noon, Rome time. Two left-leaning cardinals — Lorenzo Baldisseri and Christoph Schönborn — will reportedly present the document, indicating that the document will have a progressive content, according to Vatican experts.

In his statement, Brandmüller warned that allowing civilly divorced and remarried Catholic to become "more integrated" into the Church would lead to "conflicts," "embarrassments," and an "undermining of the Church's sacred proclamation."

The German cardinal said a married Catholic who marries again even if civilly divorced is "committing adultery."

As long as such person is unwilling to end this sinful situation, he "cannot receive either absolution in Confession nor the Eucharist."

Any action taken other than repentance and change of life is "bound to fail" due to "its inherent untruthfulness," Brandmüller said.

This "untruthfulness" directly applies "to the attempt to integrate into the Church those who live in an invalid 'second marriage' by admitting them to liturgical, catechetical and other functions," he added.

Moreover, integration without repentance and change of life cannot be reconciled with the doctrines of the faith, Brandmüller said.

Referring directly to Pope Francis' forthcoming exhortation, the cardinal said the document must be in consonance with the unchanging dogmas of the Church, especially as expressed in the Church's Catechism.

"A contradiction between a papal document and the Catechism of the Catholic Church would not be imaginable," Brandmüller said.

related articles
Church guilty of \'abandoning the poor\', Synod told
Church guilty of 'abandoning the poor', Synod told

Church guilty of 'abandoning the poor', Synod told

Three years on, Pope leaves Catholic conservatives feeling marginalised
Three years on, Pope leaves Catholic conservatives feeling marginalised

Three years on, Pope leaves Catholic conservatives feeling marginalised

'The Joy of Love': Pope Francis' post-synod exhortation to be released Friday

'The Joy of Love': Pope Francis' post-synod exhortation to be released Friday

Synod on the Family: Will Pope Francis tear up the Church\'s rule book on Friday?
Synod on the Family: Will Pope Francis tear up the Church's rule book on Friday?

Synod on the Family: Will Pope Francis tear up the Church's rule book on Friday?

News
Marriage is the safest relationship, latest figures suggest
Marriage is the safest relationship, latest figures suggest

Of the eight children murdered during lockdown, 7 were killed thanks to the actions of a step parent or new partner.

Abortion rises in Northern Ireland for fifth year running
Abortion rises in Northern Ireland for fifth year running

Abortion was legalised in Northern Ireland in 2019.

Churches helping millions of Brits get by as living costs remain high
Churches helping millions of Brits get by as living costs remain high

Across the country, people are looking to the church for help.

Isaiah 41:10 is YouVersion's Bible verse of the year
Isaiah 41:10 is YouVersion's Bible verse of the year

Isaiah 41:10 had the highest international engagement on YouVersion during 2025, while in the UK it was Jeremiah 29:11 that topped the list.