U.S. federal appeals court upholds Utah's ban on polygamous cohabitation

A U.S. federal appeals court has upheld Utah's ban on polygamous cohabitation, inflicting defeat to a family featured on the reality show "Sister Wives." The family earlier asked the court to uphold a 2013 ruling in their favour.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit ruled on Monday that the challenge to Utah's bigamy statute is "moot."

"It is not a 'Case' or 'Controversy' under Article III of the U.S. Constitution. We remand to the district court with instructions to vacate the judgment and dismiss this action," the appeals court ruled.

Under the Utah law, "a person is guilty of bigamy when, knowing he has a husband or wife or knowing the other person has a husband or wife, the person purports to marry another person or cohabits with another person."

Plaintiffs Kody Brown, Meri Brown, Janelle Brown, Christine Brown, and Robyn Sullivan form a "plural family." Kody Brown is legally married to Meri Brown and "spiritually married" to the other three women, whom he calls "sister wives."

When the Browns were featured in the TLC reality TV show in 2010, the Lehi Police Department opened an investigation of the Browns for violating a state law.

The family filed a case before a federal district court against the Utah governor and attorney general, saying the law violated their First and Fourteenth Amendment rights.

Judge Clark Waddoups ruled in December 2013 in favour of the Browns and the state appealed the case to the court of appeals.

Back then, Brown said "Sister Wives" became a venue to normalise polygamy before the public, the Christian News Network reports.

"When I talked with my children about doing the show, I said we have an opportunity to not only change our world, but to change the world for everyone else," he said.

The court then ruled that it "believes that Plaintiffs are correct in their argument that, in prohibiting cohabitation under the statute, 'it is, of course, the state that has equated private sexual conduct with marriage.'"

The Utah County Attorney's Office adopted a policy that it will bring bigamy prosecutions only against those who induce partner to marry through misrepresentation or are suspected of committing crime such as fraud or abuse.

However, the federal court denied the county attorney's motion to dismiss the case and granted a summary judgement to the Browns.

The appeals court ruled that the district court made an error by proceeding to the merits of the case.

"Federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction. They lack power to decide issues—however important or fiercely contested—that are detached from a live dispute between the parties," the court ruled.

It said the case should have been dismissed since the Browns were never charged with a crime.

"The record shows the [prosecutor's office] has adopted, and intends to abide by, a policy under which the Browns face no threat of prosecution," wrote Judge Scott Matheson.

Brown said he plans to appeal the decision, either back to the 10th Circuit en banc or to the United States Supreme Court.

related articles
Scottish bishop opposes gay marriage

As Scotland prepares to become the first country in the United Kingdom to legalise same-sex marriage by 2015, a Catholic bishop has suggested that changing the traditional definition of marriage could open up the gates to bigamy and incest.

Utah ban on polygamy overturned
Utah ban on polygamy overturned

The US District Court of Utah has overturned the state's prohibition on bigamy, effectively legalising polygamy in the process.

Judge rules polygamy ban violates religious freedom
Judge rules polygamy ban violates religious freedom

A US judge has ruled that a section of the law banning polygamy violates religious freedom, which could lead to the practice being decriminalised.

Montana man, inspired by legalisation of same-sex union, seeks to marry 2nd wife
Montana man, inspired by legalisation of same-sex union, seeks to marry 2nd wife

A polygamist man in Montana is seeking to marry his second wife after he was inspired by the US Supreme Court ruling that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide.

US same-sex marriage ruling used to back appeal against polygamy ban
US same-sex marriage ruling used to back appeal against polygamy ban

"This case is about criminalisation of consensual relations," said attorney Jonathan Turley.

Heard of sologamy? It\'s the marriage of someone to one\'s own self, and not a few women have already done it
Heard of sologamy? It's the marriage of someone to one's own self, and not a few women have already done it

There's polygamy (having more than one spouse at a time); there's bigamy (having two spouses at the same time); there's monogamy (having only one spouse at a time), and there's also such a thing as sologamy.

News
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain

Architectural historian Steven Brindle talks to Christian Today about the faith that shaped 1930s Britain, the churches that supported struggling communities and what lessons the decade might have for us today.

Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach
Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach

Shine Your Light is aiming to mobilise half a million Christians to share the gospel with five million people across the UK this Christmas, with more than 2,000 churches already signed up, organisers say.

The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'
The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'

The Church of England's uneasiness about the government's ‘conversion practices’ bill is a perfect lesson in the old adage, 'be careful what you wish for,' writes Dr Martin Davie.

Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns
Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns

An internal Home Office report lists concerns about immigration, multiculturalism and changing social values among the characteristics associated with what it calls "Christian extremism", it has been reported.