'Three parent family' proposal condemned by Christians

Proposals to make the UK the first country in the world to allow three-parent babies to be born have been strongly criticised by a Christian charity.

Nola Leach, the Chief Executive of CARE, said draft legislation introduced in parliament yesterday raises "profound ethical and identity questions" as well as "huge, unanswered safety concerns".

"It is quite extraordinary that the Government should contemplate asking MPs to vote on this hugely controversial legislation just before a General Election," she added.

Under the rules introduced by Public Health Minister Jane Ellison, IVF clinics will legally be able to replace defective mitochondrial DNA from an egg with healthy DNA given by a donor. This process – known as "mitochondrial replacement therapy" – would reduce the number of children born with serious inherited diseases such as muscular dystrophy, but would also mean those children would technically have two mothers, or three parents in all.

Ellison said in a written statement: "The Government has run a comprehensive and transparent process over the lifetime of this Parliament to review the public acceptability of mitochondrial donation and the ongoing evidence of safety and efficacy of the new techniques involved.

"The time is now right to give Parliament the opportunity to consider and vote on these regulations."

Chief Medical Officer Dame Sally Davies has said that if approved, the process will "keep the UK at the forefront of scientific development," but critics have denounced it as a form of genetic modification. The Government, however, has been keen to emphasise that no nuclear DNA, which provides physical and other traits that children inherit from their parents, would be contributed from the donor.

According to CARE, however, the process could have a devastating impact on sense of identity, particularly as the legislation stipulates that the donor parent would remain anonymous.

The charity notes that Secretary of State for Health, Jeremey Hunt, has commissioned three safety reports from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), but that the Government has proceeded without conclusions from pre-clinical trials to be published.

"They have also ignored evidence from their own consultation which showed clear opposition to the proposals," a statement from CARE adds.

"On the only occasion one of the proposed techniques (pronuclear transfer) was attempted in humans in China, it resulted in an abortion, a miscarriage and a stillbirth," Leach has pointed out, adding that support for the proposal has "fallen away dramatically across the course of the year".

"The Government is endangering patient safety - mitochondrial DNA provides far more than cell energy and actually informs the traits of resulting children making the term three parent children entirely appropriate," she concluded.

In August, the Church of England urged the Government to undertake more research before approving any plans, and called for children born from the process to have access to information about their donors.

"We believe that more research into the safety and efficacy of mitochondrial replacement therapy is necessary before regulations are introduced permitting the technique," a statement read.

"It is estimated that only around 10 children per year might benefit from current techniques while 1 in 200 children are born with some form of mitochondrial disorder. Further research, resulting in assured safety and efficacy is likely to be more beneficial in the long-term than premature application of uncertain techniques. The introduction of regulations ought to await the results of such research."

The legislation will be voted on by Parliament early in 2015, with the law to come into effect in October of the same year.

related articles
Aborting the disabled: \'Wrongful birth\' or unborn eugenics?
Aborting the disabled: 'Wrongful birth' or unborn eugenics?

We are apparently in a legal situation where it's acceptable to euthanise someone before they are even born.

Three parent IVF plan called \'dangerous and unethical\' by Christian lobbyists
Three parent IVF plan called 'dangerous and unethical' by Christian lobbyists

Lobbyist group Christian Concern issued a statement today calling the UK's proposal to allow two mothers' genetic material to be used for In vitro fertilization "dangerous and unethical."

Christian ethicists concerned over \'three parent baby\' IVF plan
Christian ethicists concerned over 'three parent baby' IVF plan

New IVF technique 'mitochondrial replacement therapy' raises questions over genetic modification of embryos.

Opposition to \'three parent\' babies grows
Opposition to 'three parent' babies grows

MPs and members of the public have been voicing their concerns about the proposed creation of 'three parent' embryos.

News
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain
Faith in difficult times: lessons from 1930s Britain

Architectural historian Steven Brindle talks to Christian Today about the faith that shaped 1930s Britain, the churches that supported struggling communities and what lessons the decade might have for us today.

Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach
Campaign aims to mobilise 500,000 Christians for Christmas outreach

Shine Your Light is aiming to mobilise half a million Christians to share the gospel with five million people across the UK this Christmas, with more than 2,000 churches already signed up, organisers say.

The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'
The Church of England should repent for previous calls to ban 'conversion therapy'

The Church of England's uneasiness about the government's ‘conversion practices’ bill is a perfect lesson in the old adage, 'be careful what you wish for,' writes Dr Martin Davie.

Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns
Leaked Home Office report links 'Christian extremism' to traditionalist beliefs and immigration concerns

An internal Home Office report lists concerns about immigration, multiculturalism and changing social values among the characteristics associated with what it calls "Christian extremism", it has been reported.