Ohio judge refuses to wed same-sex couple in defiance of US Supreme Court ruling

Judge C. Allen McConnell (seated at extreme left) together with other Toledo Municipal Court judges (Toledo Municipal Court website)

An Ohio judge assigned to officiate in marriages has refused to wed a same-sex couple two weeks after the US Supreme Court made gay marriage legal in the US.

Judge C. Allen McConnell of the Toledo Municipal Court declined to marry Carolyn Wilson and her partner on Monday at the courthouse.

McConnell later said his refusal was based on his personal and Christian beliefs.

"On Monday, July 6, I declined to marry a non-traditional couple during my duties assignment," he said, according to Reuters. "The declination was based upon my personal and Christian beliefs established over many years. I apologise to the couple for the delay they experienced and wish them the best."

Wilson told 12ABC Action News that "it's kind of surreal."

"I grew up never thinking that would happen to me and then it was about to happen and then it wasn't going to happen and then it happened," she said.

The couple went to the Toledo Municipal Court on Monday and paid $15 to be married by the duty judge between 1:30 p.m. and 3 p.m., based on the rules.

"It was a shock. I was angry, embarrassed, a little bit humiliated like we finally have the right and now they're saying we don't have the right," said Wilson.

The couple were eventually married by Judge Bill Connelly.

Deputy court administrator Michael Zenk told Reuters that it was the first time that the court was asked to perform a same-sex marriage.

"It is the policy of the court to accommodate wedding requests and we will continue to do that for both opposite and same-sex marriage," said Zenk.

McConnell still refuses to perform gay marriages and said he will "continue to perform traditional marriages during my duties assignment."

He said he will seek the advice of the Ohio Supreme Court "as to whether or not I can opt out of the rotation. Upon receipt of the advisory opinion from Supreme Court, I will abide by its decision."

Newsletter Stay up to date with Christian Today
related articles
US appeals court upholds gay marriage bans, reversing trend
US appeals court upholds gay marriage bans, reversing trend

US appeals court upholds gay marriage bans, reversing trend

Gay ordination supported by majority of Church of Scotland
Gay ordination supported by majority of Church of Scotland

Gay ordination supported by majority of Church of Scotland

\'Bible-believing Christian\' company refuses to print civil partnership invitations
'Bible-believing Christian' company refuses to print civil partnership invitations

'Bible-believing Christian' company refuses to print civil partnership invitations

Christian leaders vows civil disobedience if Supreme Court legalises same sex marriage
Christian leaders vows civil disobedience if Supreme Court legalises same sex marriage

Christian leaders vows civil disobedience if Supreme Court legalises same sex marriage

Five bad reasons to oppose same-sex marriage... and some approaches that might make more sense
Five bad reasons to oppose same-sex marriage... and some approaches that might make more sense

Five bad reasons to oppose same-sex marriage... and some approaches that might make more sense

\'Christian America is under siege\': Faith leaders unite vs. same-sex marriage ruling
'Christian America is under siege': Faith leaders unite vs. same-sex marriage ruling

'Christian America is under siege': Faith leaders unite vs. same-sex marriage ruling

News
Church of Scotland issues slavery apology
Church of Scotland issues slavery apology

The Church of Scotland General Assembly said it was “grieved beyond telling” for the suffering inflicted.

The Christian Church in mainland China since 1949
The Christian Church in mainland China since 1949

The history of the Christian Church in mainland China since 1949 is a story characterised by times of dramatic upheaval, near destruction and martyrdom, and unexpected revival.

Church of England releases prayer for national unity
Church of England releases prayer for national unity

Bishops in the Church of England have issued a prayer for unity in the UK that asks God's protection from "the perils of division and hatred". 

Police drop criminal investigation into street preacher
Police drop criminal investigation into street preacher

A pastor has hailed a "win for free speech" after police dropped a criminal investigation into him over comments he made about Islam and transgender ideology while street preaching.