Hollywood can make Bible-based films but they shouldn't tinker with the story

Noah film gets more people to read the Bible. Wikipedia

A majority of Christians are happy for Hollywood to make Bible-based movies but they should stick to the original story.

That's according to a poll by BibleGateway.com to coincide with the release of Noah.

The poll found that just over 60 per cent of Christians believe Hollywood adaptations of Bible stories are acceptable but only if they adhere strictly to the details of the original story.

Over a quarter (28 per cent) said Bible stories were a good fit for the big screen and can withstand artistic licence, while a smaller minority (11 per cent) think Hollywood should stay away from Bible stories. 

The release of Darren Aronofsky's version of Noah has stirred debate about the adaptation of Bible stories for the big screen and the extent to which it's acceptable for directors to be creative with the stories.

The Noah film has split opinion among Christians, with some outright refusing to see it. 

Those who have seen it are divided over whether it is good entertainment or whether the rock monsters, family feuding and other aspects of the film are a step too far from the original Old Testament story. 

Whatever people think, one thing it has done is stir up interest in the Bible story of Noah.  BibleGateway reports that the opening weekend of Noah at the box office saw a 223 per cent increase on the previous weekend in visits to their page on the Noah story.

Speaking to The Christian Post, film critic Brett McCracken questioned whether strictly adhering to the original version of any story was actually workable in practice.

"In any adaption of a text that is going from one medium to another, for example, from the written to visual on screen, you have to make some adjustments," he said.

"You have to add and subtract. You have to edit things and make adjustments and put dialogue in the mouths of characters.

"It wouldn't be much of a movie if Russell Crowe's character didn't say anything."

His comments echo those made by Emma Watson, who played Noah's daughter in the film. 

In the run-up to the film's release, the British actress said it had to be adapted for the screen to give the characters dialogue and create more female roles.

"If we had gone with exactly the original story, Noah doesn't say anything until he steps off the ark. You would have been watching a silent film," she said.

related articles
Noah and the flood: Was God evil?
Noah and the flood: Was God evil?

Noah and the flood: Was God evil?

Emma Watson: I believe in a higher power
Emma Watson: I believe in a higher power

Emma Watson: I believe in a higher power

Christians \'need to see Hollywood as a mission field\'
Christians 'need to see Hollywood as a mission field'

Christians 'need to see Hollywood as a mission field'

Could Noah's Ark really fit that many animals inside?
Could Noah's Ark really fit that many animals inside?

Could Noah's Ark really fit that many animals inside?

\'Most Christian films are bad\': Howie Klausner on film and faith
'Most Christian films are bad': Howie Klausner on film and faith

'Most Christian films are bad': Howie Klausner on film and faith

Noah Movie prompts more people to read the Bible; YouVersion reports 300 percent increase
Noah Movie prompts more people to read the Bible; YouVersion reports 300 percent increase

Noah Movie prompts more people to read the Bible; YouVersion reports 300 percent increase

Noah film is 'Noah without God': Darren Aronofsky's version gets the thumbs down from the Vatican

Noah film is 'Noah without God': Darren Aronofsky's version gets the thumbs down from the Vatican

News
CoE sees surge in interest this Christmas amid reports of a 'quiet revival'
CoE sees surge in interest this Christmas amid reports of a 'quiet revival'

The Church of England has said that it is experiencing a surge in interest and that it has registered a record number of services this Christmas.

Nicaragua bans international visitors from bringing in Bibles
Nicaragua bans international visitors from bringing in Bibles

Nicaragua has gone up the league table of anti-Christian persecutors.

The little-known prayers written by Jane Austen
The little-known prayers written by Jane Austen

It is now 250 years since the birth of Jane Austen whose books and their many screen adaptations are beloved around the world. Not many people know that she was a devout Christian who also wrote devotional prayers. This is the story …

The Anglican worldview of Jane Austen’s life and novels
The Anglican worldview of Jane Austen’s life and novels

16 December 2025 marks the 250th anniversary of the birth of novelist Jane Austen, who was born in southern England in 1775. Her novels are steeped in biblical analogy and practical theology. This is the story…