Baby Jesus figurines most stolen item in Nativity scenes during Christmas, church pastors say

This Christmas season, churches in the United States have been experiencing thefts targeting the baby Jesus in Nativity scenes.

They said the baby Jesus is the most stolen item during Christmas, Rawstory reported.

In Casco, Maine, someone stole baby Jesus and Mary from the Nativity scene at Casco Village Church.

"Our church is very old and so these things become part of the walls and windows and Nativity set," said the church's Pastor Joyce Long, according to WGME CBS 13. She said this meant the thief also took a piece of the church's history with them.

The Nativity scene pieces were hand-painted decades ago by a 91-year-old church member.

"So they're kind of irreplaceable," Long said.

She said during Christmas Eve service, "we gather around this Nativity scene and we sing Silent Night."

In Boise, Idaho, a baby Jesus figurine was stolen from the Nativity scene at Journey Church.

"Unfortunately it appears that Jesus has grown up and started his Journey of Faith as he is now missing from our manger at the church's display, but the display must go on. Praying for a safe Journey for Jesus," the church posted on Facebook, according to station KTVB.

According to Pastor Mike Boswell, the figurine is part of the display belonging to a family in the church that decorates the church for Christmas every year.

"We would love to have him returned, especially for the family in our church that he belongs to," he said. The station said thefts of baby Jesus have been reported in New Jersey, North Carolina and Indiana.

Another baby Jesus statue was reported to have been stolen in Saline, Michigan more than a week ago.

Pastor William Natsis said he went to the manger to pick up a shepherd when he discovered the theft.

"I noticed there was no baby Jesus in the manger," he said, according to M Live.

The statue has been returned to the Trinity Lutheran Church, thanks to a tip and action by the Saline Police Department.

"Anything you can fit in the palm of your hand is a lot easier," said Gregory Musick of Kaufer's Religious Supplies, according to KIRO.

He added, "Everybody likes a baby. They never steal the wise men or camels or anything like that. It's always baby Jesus."

Pastor James Carney of the Capitol Hill Presbyterian Church in Washington said the church's baby Jesus was stolen from the manger last year.

"It was as tacky, as cheap, as garage sale baby Jesus, mom and dad as you could get," he said.

related articles
No mince pies, by order: When Parliament banned Christmas
No mince pies, by order: When Parliament banned Christmas

No mince pies, by order: When Parliament banned Christmas

Could Bethlehem be the hottest new stag do destination?
Could Bethlehem be the hottest new stag do destination?

Could Bethlehem be the hottest new stag do destination?

School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars \'live\' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana
School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars 'live' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana

School presents mannequin Nativity scene after judge bars 'live' depiction, infuriating atheists in Indiana

How did the Star of Bethlehem manage to stop over the stable?
How did the Star of Bethlehem manage to stop over the stable?

How did the Star of Bethlehem manage to stop over the stable?

Anonymous donor hides $50,000 under baby Jesus for a children's home

Anonymous donor hides $50,000 under baby Jesus for a children's home

No \'Merry Christmas\' in Bethlehem, New York? Fearful town officials told putting up the sign poses no problem
No 'Merry Christmas' in Bethlehem, New York? Fearful town officials told putting up the sign poses no problem

No 'Merry Christmas' in Bethlehem, New York? Fearful town officials told putting up the sign poses no problem

\'McNativity\' window photo goes viral as Jesus birth\'s display in Tennessee thrills and inspires thousands
'McNativity' window photo goes viral as Jesus birth's display in Tennessee thrills and inspires thousands

'McNativity' window photo goes viral as Jesus birth's display in Tennessee thrills and inspires thousands

Bishop of Manchester: Why foodbank appeals are the new normal
Bishop of Manchester: Why foodbank appeals are the new normal

Bishop of Manchester: Why foodbank appeals are the new normal

Homelessness: Churches help thousands each winter, study finds

Homelessness: Churches help thousands each winter, study finds

Christmas Starts With Christ ad campaign banned from cinemas

Christmas Starts With Christ ad campaign banned from cinemas

News
Marriage is the safest relationship, latest figures suggest
Marriage is the safest relationship, latest figures suggest

Of the eight children murdered during lockdown, 7 were killed thanks to the actions of a step parent or new partner.

Abortion rises in Northern Ireland for fifth year running
Abortion rises in Northern Ireland for fifth year running

Abortion was legalised in Northern Ireland in 2019.

Churches helping millions of Brits get by as living costs remain high
Churches helping millions of Brits get by as living costs remain high

Across the country, people are looking to the church for help.

Isaiah 41:10 is YouVersion's Bible verse of the year
Isaiah 41:10 is YouVersion's Bible verse of the year

Isaiah 41:10 had the highest international engagement on YouVersion during 2025, while in the UK it was Jeremiah 29:11 that topped the list.