CTindex - Christian Today UK Interactive Catalogue
Comments

It's as if the Reformation had never happened

The Pope's death exposes the erosion of confidence in our institutions

by Christian Today
Posted: Monday, April 11, 2005, 19:03 (BST)
Font Scale:A A A

It is a compelling measure of the personal and political impact made by the long reign of John Paul II - to say nothing of the changed nature of British public life during his 27 years as Bishop of Rome - that the death of the pontiff this weekend should have triggered such turmoil for the establishment of this notably un-Catholic country.

The funeral of a pope, let us be clear, has never until now been the sort of event deemed to require the attendance of the British prime minister - or even of the Archbishop of Canterbury. The late Lord Callaghan, who was premier when the previous two Popes died in quick succession in 1978, attended neither of their funerals. Nor did anyone at the time think it remarkable that he chose not to go. The more so when not even Dr Donald Coggan, Cantuar of that time, saw it as an essential duty to attend the funeral of John Paul I either.

This time, as yesterday's extraordinary flurry of hasty rearrangements showed, the assumptions could not be more different. No British prime minister, as far as I know, has ever attended a papal funeral, but Tony Blair will have been absolutely determined to be in St Peter's on Friday. Even more striking was the similar instinct in Lambeth Palace, where Dr Rowan Williams was yesterday reported to believe that, offered a choice between officiating at the royal wedding in Windsor or attending the papal requiem in Rome, Rome would win every time.

The immediate dilemma was caused by the unexpected coincidence of the papal funeral being arranged for the day of the remarriage of the Prince of Wales. But this upmarket diary clash conceals something deeper and even less easily resolved, a dilemma about how seriously to take our major national institutions at a time when they are losing public credibility and confidence.

As the first celebrity Pope, John Paul did for the papacy what Lady Di did for the royal family, giving it a superficial familiarity to millions that was quite unlike anything that previous generations had experienced. Friday's will be a celebrity funeral, as well as a religious event, and the world leaders now heading for Rome want nothing more complicated than to be associated with it. That is why George Bush is heading across the Atlantic for this week's event, while in 1978 the no less religious Jimmy Carter preferred to send his mother to John Paul I's requiem.

Even so, it is hard not to catch one's breath at the rupture with national history that all this represents. Ours is still, after all, legally established as a Protestant nation. Until very recently the mere idea that a prime minister or the head of the Anglican church might have any kind of dialogue with Rome - never mind rearrange the next Protestant king's wedding to suit the cardinals in Rome - would have been regarded as close to treason. Catholicism, in its time, was as anathema to the British state as communism was in a later era. Five centuries ago we broke with Rome so that a king could remarry. Today our re-embrace of Rome means that a future king's remarriage has to be postponed.
Yet this does not mean that 21st-century Britain is trying to find its way back into the Roman Catholic fold. There is no evidence of that - in spite of the striking number of prominent Catholics on the list of those attending the Vespers in Westminster Cathedral last night. The Roman church's teachings - and particularly those of the late Pope - on subjects such as birth control, homosexuality and women priests are too widely resisted for such a possibility.

The real dynamic behind this new pragmatic ecumenism towards Catholicism comes from the severe modern erosion of commitment and confidence in the national institutions handed down to us by history, notably by the Reformation and the Glorious Revolution. Legislation, such as the Acts of Supremacy in 1534 and of Settlement in 1701, has bequeathed us an established church, a limited monarchy and a system of parliamentary government. But the whole edifice is now in need of some serious repair work.



continue to read > 1 | 2

Copyright © 2005 Christian Today. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
The opinions expressed above may not reflect the views or opinions of Christian Today.

Have your say on this article
Light for Last Days
Google Advertisement
Externally generated - Report offensive links here
World Headline
Church groups respond as Congo conflict deepens

Church groups respond as Congo conflict deepens

Church-related aid agencies are assisting civilians displaced by the eastern Congo conflict as the UN special envoy...
Sponsored Features
Give a disadvantaged young person a brighter future this Christmas. Order books for all ages commending the free and sovereign grace of Almighty God.
01582 765448 For holidays and retreats in the Scottish borders. Whitchester Christian Guest House 01450 377 477 Friendly printing company for churches, charities and businesses nationwide!
Sanct Maria Abbey, NUNRAW
Cistercian Monastery and Guest House
Bookings: 01620 830 228
Email: nunraw.abbot@yahoo.co.uk
Google Advertisement
Externally generated - Report offensive links here