Exclusive: Mystery Over Whether Gay Vicar 'Outed' The Bishop Of Grantham

Father Andrew Foreshew-Cain (R) and partner.

A gay campaigning vicar has admitted that he spoke to a Sunday Times journalist about the Bishop of Grantham's sexuality before that newspaper was set to run a story on the subject.

Andrew Foreshew-Cain, who is well known in church circles for his forthright views on what he claims are fellow gay clergy who are not yet known about publicly, denied being the source behind the planned Sunday Times story when asked by Christian Today.

But pressed on the matter, he said: "Well, we all spoke to him [the journalist]. He was ringing everybody up who knew."

Foreshew-Cain said, "I am not a fan of outing" and added that the "progressive cause" had not been particularly helped by the revelation that the bishop, Nicholas Chamberlain, was gay, because "everyone rallied round him including the evangelicals".

However, he went on: "The fact that he is gay was widely known including by a lot of journalists. The question is why they do not pursue the Diocesan Bishops who are gay."

The Bishop of Grantham, Nicholas Chamberlain, was consecrated by the Bishop of Lincoln, who knew he was gay and in a relationship. Diocese of Lincoln

The Sunday Times was due to run a story on the bishop's sexuality on 4 September. But when the bishop was approached by the paper, his office in turn contacted the Guardian, which ran what the Sunday Times journalist in question described to Christian Today as "a spoiler" on 2 September.

Nicholas Hellen, the Social Affairs Editor at the Sunday Times, told Christian Today to "mind your own business" when questioned, and pointed out that journalists do not reveal their sources. He also expressed anger at the Guardian for implying that the Sunday Times was preparing to "out" the bishop.

"I am very unhappy because it is untrue, the report in the Guardian that we were going to out a bishop," Hellen said.

Some gay campaigners - including the pressure group OutRage! - believe that people who are not publicly gay should be 'outed' to help the LGBT cause.

A number of politicians have been 'outed' in the past including Peter Mandelson, when the former Tory MP and Times writer Matthew Parris revealed he was gay live on BBC's Newsnight.

But church figures are likely to be dismayed if the tactic has come to the church.

Simon Sarmiento, chair of the LGBTI Mission, said that he would be "surprised" if Foreshew-Cain, who is the vicar at St James' in West Hamsptead, was behind the story but added that outing bishops was "a very bad idea".

A spokesman for the Bishop of Grantham refused to comment on the sourcing question and merely said: "It's business as usual. We are getting on with the job."

Since it was publicly revealed that he is gay, Bishop Chamberlain has received some 700 letters, the vast majority of which are supportive.

related articles
Church of England bishop comes out as gay

Church of England bishop comes out as gay

Appointment of gay Bishop of Grantham a \'major error\' say conservative Anglicans
Appointment of gay Bishop of Grantham a 'major error' say conservative Anglicans

Appointment of gay Bishop of Grantham a 'major error' say conservative Anglicans

Bishop of Grantham: Conservative Christians who condemn me are still \'brothers and sisters in Christ\'
Bishop of Grantham: Conservative Christians who condemn me are still 'brothers and sisters in Christ'

Bishop of Grantham: Conservative Christians who condemn me are still 'brothers and sisters in Christ'

Top Anglican official backs Bishop of Grantham over sexuality
Top Anglican official backs Bishop of Grantham over sexuality

Top Anglican official backs Bishop of Grantham over sexuality

Same-sex attraction: Is celibacy sufficient to qualify for Christian ministry?
Same-sex attraction: Is celibacy sufficient to qualify for Christian ministry?

Same-sex attraction: Is celibacy sufficient to qualify for Christian ministry?

News
Richard Moth appointed as new Archbishop of Westminster
Richard Moth appointed as new Archbishop of Westminster

Bishop Richard Moth has been confirmed as the new Archbishop of Westminster, the most senior post in the Catholic Church in England and Wales. 

The mystery of the Wise Men
The mystery of the Wise Men

The carol assures us that “We three kings of Orient are…” and tells us they were “following yonder star”. Can we be sure there were three of them? Were they kings? Where in the Orient were they from? What was the star they followed? In fact, there is a lot that we just do not know. This is the story …

English Heritage deletes debunked claims about pagan origins of Christmas Day
English Heritage deletes debunked claims about pagan origins of Christmas Day

English Heritage has admitted it got it wrong when it shared false claims that the date of Christmas is derived from a pagan Roman festival in honour of a sun god.

Guinness Book of Records recognises 'the world’s longest serving Sunday School teacher'
Guinness Book of Records recognises 'the world’s longest serving Sunday School teacher'

Pam Knowles started helping out her church Sunday school in 1951 at the age of 13.